because celever said so, mostly
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Town of Salem 2 Mafia: Revival - WON BY THE MAFIA AND THE WITCH
- Thread starter Ehmcee
- Start date
since when did we trust the moderation of this site
Only when it’s against another mod
just shoot me man
power is in your hand I’m literally just following whatever seems most likely to save me
just say it1! don'ty hide behind thes e theatrics 1! if t;s bad for town to vote a wagon tbat is gainng steam just ay why1! !
bro yall are getting whispers..
Idk to be honest.
I see there was no movement on the transporter contact front
I mean if we are living in that universe then I have to think someone is just lying if there's no other viable mechanically solution. so surely voting in the "knot" is better than picking people at random.
I do think celever has had some good posting but I think it's important to be wary at the same time too since celever is probably the best person in this game at posting a lot of words and sounding town so when they say "voting AG lets us learn a lot about that wagon" as a major justification I kind of squint my eyes at that.
I mean if we are living in that universe then I have to think someone is just lying if there's no other viable mechanically solution. so surely voting in the "knot" is better than picking people at random.
I do think celever has had some good posting but I think it's important to be wary at the same time too since celever is probably the best person in this game at posting a lot of words and sounding town so when they say "voting AG lets us learn a lot about that wagon" as a major justification I kind of squint my eyes at that.
idk after rereading i think fairy's desvote reasoning was mid at best and her explanation was bad, but the evie jump was equally bad
There is a mechanical conclusion where all 4 knotters are telling the truth
joey man you're driving me insane. i'm looking up the nearest mental asylum
how would this info be bad for town
I promise I will whisper you if we both are alive next day
hyhy i can't lie
you whispered to me saying "hello"
i responded saying "yo"
and then you ghosted me
you whispered to me saying "hello"
i responded saying "yo"
and then you ghosted me
rushed reads
TOWN
hyhy- pretty self explanatory based on joey's reasons- this slot is never scum unless alice is and i think alice is town
TOWNLEAN
Alice- slot is a bit worse to me then before due to random vote on af, but she is most likely town based off mech stuff i only sorta get
joey- i agree with their opinion on ag, their posts seems to come from a town pov, i think i would not vote this slot until much later
SLIGHT TOWNLEAN
dbd- i like their vibes- i don't buy the evie flashwagon
jalmont- feel like he would play a bit more agressively if he was scum instead of being extremely passive
NEUTRAL
af- the des vote justification is pretty weak- shes not an info vote, des is always a vote because shes scummy and justifying it as an info vote feels like a way to quickly get rid of blame if des flips town- her position on des is too hedgy- not scum because i hate the wagon on her
celever- on a skim i think i dont buy the wagon but it wasn't as bad as i thought from the person starting it
airc- new player low activity weird post abt des cant be mafia could be tmi but not convinced
SCUMLEAN
miyami/evie/ecat- random unexplained votes on af feels like a prime towny mislynch angle- evie is the best out of the 3 but ecat feels a tiny bit worse out of the 3 because im not convinced by the evie flashwagon either especially since it just feels like smth scum would do but they are here for the same reason. ecat moving off demonstrates hedginess im not sure i like tbh because it feels scummy
SCUMREAD
AG- scummy- i hate the post calling for transporters to claim twice- feels like anti town info- i also dont like the hedginess on the af vote cuz he could easily just say he didnt vote af and based off smogtown exp we would just forget that he was pro voting af but didnt vote
des- have explained this before
TOWN
hyhy- pretty self explanatory based on joey's reasons- this slot is never scum unless alice is and i think alice is town
TOWNLEAN
Alice- slot is a bit worse to me then before due to random vote on af, but she is most likely town based off mech stuff i only sorta get
joey- i agree with their opinion on ag, their posts seems to come from a town pov, i think i would not vote this slot until much later
SLIGHT TOWNLEAN
dbd- i like their vibes- i don't buy the evie flashwagon
jalmont- feel like he would play a bit more agressively if he was scum instead of being extremely passive
NEUTRAL
af- the des vote justification is pretty weak- shes not an info vote, des is always a vote because shes scummy and justifying it as an info vote feels like a way to quickly get rid of blame if des flips town- her position on des is too hedgy- not scum because i hate the wagon on her
celever- on a skim i think i dont buy the wagon but it wasn't as bad as i thought from the person starting it
airc- new player low activity weird post abt des cant be mafia could be tmi but not convinced
SCUMLEAN
miyami/evie/ecat- random unexplained votes on af feels like a prime towny mislynch angle- evie is the best out of the 3 but ecat feels a tiny bit worse out of the 3 because im not convinced by the evie flashwagon either especially since it just feels like smth scum would do but they are here for the same reason. ecat moving off demonstrates hedginess im not sure i like tbh because it feels scummy
SCUMREAD
AG- scummy- i hate the post calling for transporters to claim twice- feels like anti town info- i also dont like the hedginess on the af vote cuz he could easily just say he didnt vote af and based off smogtown exp we would just forget that he was pro voting af but didnt vote
des- have explained this before
that's news to me can you explain or point out which page I should reread. how could targets get redirected without another transporter here
lets do it
fair enoguh