Skyward Sword HD:
Ok so I never played this one on the wii so I was excited to play this one with the remaster on switch, especially sans the motion controls.
On the whole it's still a zelda game so it's automatically excellent. Having said that, it is easily the worst mainline 3D one that I've played (I absolutely hate majoras mask too but wouldn't rank it lower here because I feel without the time loop aspect it would be on the same level as ocarina so meh).
The problem here is they traded out the motion controls for clunky ones, and while I appreciate the change overall since it is nice to play while handheld, it cannot be denied that needing to take frickin 4 or 5 steps just to throw a bomb is irritating, especially when fighting a boss that requires it.
Needing to swing in certain swipes is actually a neat mechanic, but the chess-like combat (as opposed to botw's freeform combos) is hampered by the fact you need to manually block after every swing. Unlike in botw you do not auto put your shield up while targeting the opp. This was so frustrating when fighting enemies like lizalfos which require you to swing and block attacks in succession, and it's like, I already have my shield out and blocked, please just re-block after I swing...
The other major issue I had with the game was the amount of empty space on the bird you're forced to travel through repeatedly, like Hyrule Field but 1000x worse. Ya flying was cool but not if that's all I'm doing.
And finally Fi is easily the worst companion in the series, like way way worse than Navi or Tattle. Like way worse. And she's like 90% of your interaction in the game. The other 10% is taken up by the Gaston-esque Groose and the homeliest Zelda in the series. Just horrendous.
Overall the bulk of the gameplay is great, the exploration and puzzles are fantastic, and the characters that aren't humans or Fi are charming, especially Machi. Still would recommend for hardcore zelda fans, but for casual fans you're really not missing anything here.
Ok so I never played this one on the wii so I was excited to play this one with the remaster on switch, especially sans the motion controls.
On the whole it's still a zelda game so it's automatically excellent. Having said that, it is easily the worst mainline 3D one that I've played (I absolutely hate majoras mask too but wouldn't rank it lower here because I feel without the time loop aspect it would be on the same level as ocarina so meh).
The problem here is they traded out the motion controls for clunky ones, and while I appreciate the change overall since it is nice to play while handheld, it cannot be denied that needing to take frickin 4 or 5 steps just to throw a bomb is irritating, especially when fighting a boss that requires it.
Needing to swing in certain swipes is actually a neat mechanic, but the chess-like combat (as opposed to botw's freeform combos) is hampered by the fact you need to manually block after every swing. Unlike in botw you do not auto put your shield up while targeting the opp. This was so frustrating when fighting enemies like lizalfos which require you to swing and block attacks in succession, and it's like, I already have my shield out and blocked, please just re-block after I swing...
The other major issue I had with the game was the amount of empty space on the bird you're forced to travel through repeatedly, like Hyrule Field but 1000x worse. Ya flying was cool but not if that's all I'm doing.
And finally Fi is easily the worst companion in the series, like way way worse than Navi or Tattle. Like way worse. And she's like 90% of your interaction in the game. The other 10% is taken up by the Gaston-esque Groose and the homeliest Zelda in the series. Just horrendous.
Overall the bulk of the gameplay is great, the exploration and puzzles are fantastic, and the characters that aren't humans or Fi are charming, especially Machi. Still would recommend for hardcore zelda fans, but for casual fans you're really not missing anything here.