You have listed Metal Sonic as voting to lynch both yoshinite and CBT, but his most recent vote is for CBTerrakion. (although I don't think he ever posted "unlynch yoshinite" so i don't know how you handle that)
How can I find you on IRC? By which I mean, what is your alias there? Unless it's "shinyskarmory" and you just aren't online, in which case, when are you usually on IRC? I've spoken with More Cowbell, but I think you might also like to hear things I'm thinking of about the game as they come up; might make a slightly better postgame.
Sounds good, I think it'd be best to start ASAP. We also need a main flavour (like a thread opener, with an introduction to the situation) - I'll try to type that out later. Priorities look good as well.