So whatever I think about PMD is gonna be clouded by blind nostalgia for the first two installments (I mean they're good games, but sky is my favorite game etc etc love those). However, I played through super mystery dungeon recently and I can't help but feel that so many of its flaws are directly related to some really conflicting design choices. I've seen several people here call it their favorite of the franchise, so maybe you guys have some thoughts?
Basically it feels like they tried to go two ways. There's a huge epic plot that's supposed to be amazing and magical and draw in all the kids, and then there's being able to collect literally every mon relatively easily and without needing to search up where they all hided and use hordes and all that complicated stuff. Both of those are fine on their own but the way they did it really conflicts. For example, starters kinda suck. They give you an overlevelled salamence really early which spells out pretty clearly that you're gonna rely on other mons to do shit for you. IQ gave the mons you used more actual buffs, but anything can hold a looplet and pick up emeras so clearly there's a change of tone. But then there's this whole plot epic that makes you more invested in using those starters to the point where they've got [redacted] legendary doing [redacted] and telling you you're the only one who can save the planet. There's a whole emphasis on your connection, like there always is because it isn't PMD if someone go bye-bye and someone feels sad. Even afterward there's the mechanic where mons can't get used for a few days after you take them... except for the starters. Which you weren't supposed to need so much. It's your starters who wake up on their own in the society and are special members so it makes sense from a plot angle, but the mechanics conflict when you want to use your starters less in actual explorations. Even in this thread people are telling stories specifically mentioning not using starters. There's other conflicting things like constantly tossing out mons stronger than the super special starters when their specialness ostensibly is completely transferrable to, say, any legendary nearby, or how shoehorned in and low stakes the boss battles feel compared to previous installment's skill at slowly building anticipation, sometimes over multiple dungeons, before slamming you with the Groudon you've been waiting for, but the other thing for me is the plot and that's more rantable.
plot rant tangentially related to point about game mechanics
Then there's the plot that throws out contrived gimmick like the scarves and keeps trying to emulate the older ones with copy pasting an ostensibly nuts but secretly incredible explorer, adding in double crosses except this time they're terribly executed, and even shoehorning in the Jirachi fight, which is the point where I kind of lost faith in the makers. In Bidoof's wish there's a massive buildup with a character I'm invested in before we get to touch Jirachi, not to mention it certainly wasn't the easiest fight. Did they really need to throw in a Jirachi boss battle just to meet the requirement on the lower screen when there's already so few and they really aren't that challenging at all? It's not interesting or funny, there's no buildup, there's no challenge other than oh man I wasted a reviver seed or two maybe. I mean yeah mons is never gonna be hard but I really disagree with people who thought this was harder than rescue and it feels on par with the easiest ones in explorers. To play the game I had to get through the plot, which was a great driving force in the first two but just feels obnoxious and out of the way with all the retreads and characters you can't give a shit about. The point where you jumped up the tree was truly the low point because the characters are being told by everybody they can do it and they're the best and all these legendaries are here for them and I was just sitting there not really giving a shit about the world they created. And back to sky (sigh), they proved that we can become way more invested in characters without cool graphics n shit, even before the extra missions the guild was way more identifiable and likable so why have to rely on giving us massive cutscenes to try to create impact? Style over substance much?
Even if you find that biased because I like sky and super is dumb therefore better plot, the plot mechanics really get in the way of the game in a fundamental level. The game wants you to explore a world larger than ever before with way more dungeons... which are all samey retreads. Without actually going to all of the plot dungeons that are given emphasis and feel unique like in past titles, I don't get a sense that anything is different. I'm sure I'm not the only one who can name like, all of Sky's dungeons in order because they felt unique and I love them. This game I remember that one cool looking cliffy thing, the haunted place with the absolutely trash giratina thread that was handled so poorly, plot mountain, and the final dungeon. I even went back to one of the important plot dungeons and seriously played halfway through wondering why it felt so familiar before I googled it and realized I was here before to stop [redacted] from doing
Spoiler
. I only notice dungeon uniqueness when I accidentally wander into something 3 stars stronger than I wanted to and get sent home early. Even the music doesn't help, I'm pretty sure they just shuffle a bunch of tracks and it's random what you get or something? As opposed to individual themes you knew for each dungeon (mostly, anyway, for sky etc) there's no marker to really suggest that anything is different. Also personally I think the music is mostly way worse other than remakes of past game music and also dungeon_02 is amazing but nothing has the same kind of personality as drenched bluff or spinda cafe or anything like that because it's forced to be generic stuff, not specific and awesome like amp plains. The plot can't take me through any of these dungeons therefore they aren't made unique therefore why do I give a shit about going through them? Oh yeah, recruiting all the mons. It starts to turn the one thing the game did incredibly, really well done, into more of a grind because it's not supported by anything else the game does.
Anyway I like ranting on too long about this but I really see super mystery dungeon as something that they put out flawed, enjoyable but hurts to play when you can see these basic design contradictions. The game does a lot right but these things sorta kill it for me. However, since people here seem to love it over the games I follow blindly into nostalgic bliss, I thought I'd drop my 2 cents (more than that tbh, I really didn't mean to write so much) and see how people feel about the game so maybe I'll appreciate it enough to finish getting every mon.