Let's Spice Things Up! New Concepts For Suffering Shinies

By skies and Swiffix. Released: 2023/04/29.
« Previous Article Next Article »
Art by Swiffix

Art by Swiffix.

Introduction

We all have our favorite and least favorite shiny Pokémon. But what makes a Pokémon's shiny good or bad? For starters, we can look towards some of the most notable fan favorite Pokémon shinies. Charizard is a perfect example of this; the color change is drastic, yet fitting to the theme of the Pokémon; the black is sleek, and the overall palette is pleasing to the eye. For lack of a better way to put it, Charizard's shiny has a "coolness factor" to it that makes people enjoy it.

Then we have the opposite end of the spectrum: the shinies that people just do not care for. The first that immediately comes to mind is Garchomp, which left many fans disappointed. The change in color is hardly noticeable, and for such a unique and popular Pokémon, it is no surprise that such a lackluster shiny upset people. This leaves us with the ultimate question: how do we tackle the issues of bad shinies? What makeovers can we give them to give them some more spice? There's a ton of ingredients that go into crafting a good-looking shiny, and in this article we will be going over our personal opinions on how to do so!


blissey

What went wrong?

skies

skies

Blissey is an unfortunate case of an interesting shiny losing its sheen upon evolution. While its pre-evolution, Chansey, has a clean, light shade of green when shiny, Blissey has... not much. Although my co-writer may disagree on the likeability of Chansey's shiny, I do concur that shiny Happiny's purple glaze is better than either of its evolution's colors. Really though, green or purple would be an improvement on Blissey's shiny. Turning the brightness up on Blissey doesn't do it any favors; if anything, it looked better when the stage lights were off.

Swiffix

Swiffix

The core issue with this shiny's concept is its lack of color contrast. I don't know who thought that making a Pokémon a couple shades paler would be a good idea for a shiny, especially when its original color palette is already made out of very light colors, but it wasn't. Shiny Blissey just looks like a regular Blissey that hasn't been exposed to sunlight for a while. I have to say though, I’m glad they didn’t give it the same ugly green treatment that Shiny Chansey received. Honestly? They should've just followed through with shiny Happiny’s purple hue.

How do we fix it?

Inverted

skies

skies

While still an overall subtle change compared to some outrageously overhauled shinies (see: Krookodile), an inverted color palette for Blissey is quite fitting with its docile nature. Soft, subtle, the light pink fringe against a clean white slate; Blissey looks fantastic! Sometimes the wheel doesn't need to be re-invented, and we think that this approach is dialed back to just the perfect amount.

Swiffix

Swiffix

What we did here is quite simple: we switched the colors of the original design, turning the white areas pink and vice-versa. The result, although slightly unsettling at first, is pretty cool. My favorite part about this redesign is that it's a simple yet creative change, proving once again that less can be more! Also, I can't help but picture a chessboard where opposing Blissey pieces would be these inverted versions of each other.

Sky Blue

skies

skies

It's said that blue can bring about feelings of serenity. Blissey, who has the ability Serene Grace and is well-known as a beacon of happiness and calmness, fits perfectly with this blue aesthetic. As Swiffix also pointed out, the teal only helps to emphasize Blissey's already angel-like appearance.

Swiffix

Swiffix

This is the random one of the batch, but I seriously love that shade of blue and find that it suits Blissey perfectly. It’s a very soothing color which conveys the ideas of health and motherly love. It also makes Blissey look a bit like an angel, especially when taking into account the feathery elements of its design.

Happiny's Purple

skies

skies

The most similar to Blissey's current shiny, Happiny's purple transfers onto Blissey in the most stunning fashion. Lilac is quite the endearing color to the eye; it's not too harsh, it's soothing, and it pairs nicely with Blissey's existing white colors! While I do believe it may have its own issue of not being exaggerated enough for my own liking, it's undeniably an improvement nonetheless.

Swiffix

Swiffix

This redesign has a lot going for it. First, it's reminiscent of shiny Happiny‘s purple, which is definitely the only saving grace of this evolutionary line's shiny forms. Second, and most importantly, it provides shiny Blissey with the color contrast it so badly needed. This is a shiny that wouldn’t force shiny hunters to pull out their magnifying glasses every time they encounter a Blissey!


marshadow

What went wrong?

skies

skies

For something to have gone wrong, something must've gone right somewhere... which is not the case for poor Marshadow. Unable to be viewed unless it enters its Zenith form, which it can only do while attacking, you wouldn't be able to pick out a normal Marshadow from a shiny Marshadow in a crowd. That's a problem. Marshadow is a shadow-dwelling mythical Pokémon, yet the execution of an interesting shiny must have gotten lost in the shadows, too.

Swiffix

Swiffix

Having an element of a Pokémon's design only appear during an attack sequence? Very cool. Making it the only element that changes color in its shiny form? Much less cool. I understand that the whole concept behind Marshadow monotonous grey color palette stems from it being a shadow, but I still think that they could have treated its shiny form better. A significantly better alternative would have been to only turn Marshadow fully grey when attacking, since it makes sense that it would then enter stealth mode, and to let its color and potential shiny factor otherwise shine.

How do we fix it?

Constant Shiny

skies

skies

In the unlikely event that you actually have seen Marshadow's shiny, this iteration takes what its shiny Zenith form looks like and applies it to Marshadow permanently. Now you no longer have to attack to see a different color! The deep purple looks excellent on Marshadow, but it's very difficult to properly appreciate when you can only see it in specific circumstances.

Swiffix

Swiffix

Purple on Ghost-types is nothing new, but when paired with Marshadow's otherwise completely dark body, it takes on this incredible eerie yet vibrant look. The game designers made a really good choice when picking Marshadow's shiny color, so I don't understand why they've tried so hard to hide it by only making it visible 10% of the time... Let's fix their mistake and make it constant.

Blood Red

skies

skies

Marshadow is an ominous Pokémon who is said to linger in the shadows, and what better way to portray this than a blood moon-inspired Marshadow? A blood moon has been interpreted as an omen of something bad incoming, which perfectly aligns with Marshadow's mischievous nature. Considering the rarity of such eclipses happening, the rarity of encountering Marshadow happily fits the theme as well.

Swiffix

Swiffix

Marshadow's design clearly works well with its pair of piercing bright eyes and otherwise monochromatic body. We've taken these elements and revisited them under an entirely new aesthetic, and I must say that I am in love with the result! Not only is the contrast between the emerald green and blood red stunning, but skies is absolutely right in saying that it perfectly compliments Marshadow's eerie nature Ghost typing.

Ice Cold

skies

skies

Let's state facts. Marshadow isn't exactly the most approachable-looking Pokémon, nor the most friendly when approached. Having a frigid appearance lends itself quite well to this theme, and offers a drastic change to Marshadow's currently lacking shiny. As Swiffix has said, this shiny is meant to be chilly and strike some fear into anyone daring enough to wield Marshadow's power!

Swiffix

Swiffix

Although a radical contrast from the previous design, this one works just as well! Paired with Marshadow's small stature, the dominantly white color palette conveys conflicting images of playful snow spirit and deadly ice monster. However, one look at those icy blue eyes is enough to understand that you're dealing with what is essentially the Pokémon version of a Whitewalker. This shiny Marshadow is sure to send chills down your spine.


gengar

What went wrong?

skies

skies

Gengar is one of the most popular, well-recognized Pokémon across the franchise, yet its shiny is hardly distinguishable from its regular form. While both of its pre-evolutions receive subtle shinies, there's a certain sleekness to this kind of simplicity. Haunter's tongue merely changes to a light shade of blue, but the subtle change is quite noticeable given that Haunter's whole gimmick is its tongue. Yet somehow Gengar's shiny... just mutes its original color? Don't get me wrong, I'm a firm believer in less is more, but Gengar's shiny is unfortunately too little to achieve this.

Swiffix

Swiffix

Few shinies are as disappointing as Gengar's. Once again, the struggle with contrast is real. I can maybe understand the idea of wanting to make Gengar look more like a shadow, but even then the execution leaves a lot to be desired. What's even more upsetting is the fact that they clearly had better ideas — just look at shiny Mega Gengar and shiny Gigantamax Gengar! But no, Gengar continues to suffer from having a mildly desaturated version of itself as a shiny.

How do we fix it?

Haunter Shiny

skies

skies

While Haunter's shiny is quite simple—only changing the color of its tongue and eyes to blue—the concept is quite effective. Gengar's entire line has a large focus on its tongue, and the subtle change to blue is distinguishable enough to indicate that Gengar is shiny, unlike its current shiny. Sometimes, less is more, and I'd say that is the case here.

Swiffix

Swiffix

Shiny Pokémon don't always need to have a radically different color palette from their original form to stand out and work well, and Haunter's shiny proves that. The change from red to blue, although simple, is very effective, so we've implemented that into Gengar's design by making its eyes blue. This is an all-around great change, as is both fixes the issue of having a shiny that's indistinguishable from the original and is a clever nod to the rest of the evolutionary line.

Mega Shiny

skies

skies

One of the most recognizable shinies, Gengar's Mega and Gigantamax forms both don a stunning white with shades of pink laced throughout it. With how rare it is to find a straight-up white shiny with such a drastic color palette, and showing that the company is capable of producing a great shiny for Gengar, it makes no sense as to why its original doesn't take on this palette.

Swiffix

Swiffix

This shiny exists, and it's among the best of the franchise. All we need now is to see GameFreak implement it to Gengar's regular form, a change that'll hopefully occur in Gen 9.

Ectoplasm

skies

skies

Gengar is quite tricky in the way it presents itself. It's translucent, and appears when it feels the need to, otherwise hiding in the shadows. Ectoplasm directly lends itself to this idea due to its relation to spirits and the visual representation of such spirits. Thus, a darker green tint to highlight this idea would be an upgrade from Gengar's rather bland shiny.

Swiffix

Swiffix

I LOVE this concept! I don't know if it's the Danny Phantom green eyes or that beautiful change in hue for the body (probably both), but this redesign is definitely my favorite. I'm not even that big of a fan of the color green, and Arceus knows that we have more than our fair share of ugly green shinies, but this one just suits the Pokémon perfectly.


audino-mega

What went wrong?

skies

skies

Mega Audino suffers from being arguably the most unpopular Mega Evolution. Losing Regenerator for a rather useless ability, taking up a Mega slot, and being incredibly passive leaves much to be desired competitively. Meanwhile, design wise, I personally find it to be quite nice. However, its shiny is not so nice. Being a very minuscule change with only its eyes and undertones being changed to different colors, not much changes when Mega Audino is shiny. This, combined with everything else that is disliked about our forgotten Mega Evolution, only dampens Mega Audino further. Perhaps if it had a better shiny, more people would be interested in it!

Swiffix

Swiffix

I'm not gonna lie, I don't love Audino's design. The Pokémon in general just screams "meh" to me. Sure, Mega Evolution made it slightly more interesting, but it comes at the cost of losing its otherwise decent shiny. Instead of trying to make this boring Pokémon more appealing to the audience, GameFreak just gave it the shiny Blissey treatment and called it a day. For the sake of skies's fondness of Mega Audino, let's think of something better.

How do we fix it?

Inverted Original

skies

skies

Taking on a huge shift from Mega Audino's clean shade of white and turning it into a very much deeper shade of beige simply looks much better on the sheer fact that it is a noticeable change alone. The pink accents in the eyes and lower half of Mega Audino compliment this beige very nicely, making Mega Audino look almost like a dessert! This is far more interesting than its current shiny.

Swiffix

Swiffix

The combination of beige, pink, and white is very soothing and therefore fits this Pokémon perfectly. The bright pink eyes are reminiscent of innocent bunny eyes, and something about the creamy coat just makes it seem like Mega Audino gives the warmest hugs. All in all, this redesigned color palette is an excellent choice for a cleric such as Mega Audino.

Purple Fairy

skies

skies

Here we see Mega Audino take on the colors already found in its original shiny, only amplified to the max. Remaining within its theme of being a delicate, healing Pokémon, the purple color scheme fits right in. The color purple is associated with both royalty and serenity. Quite fitting for Mega Audino, no?

Swiffix

Swiffix

Why fix what's not broken? Audino already had a decent shiny, with a purple hue that fits it very well. All that's left to do is add a pink-ish accent to that purple, implement it into elements of Mega Audino's design, and there you have it: a shiny form that just screams elegance and Fairy-type!

Turquoise Ends

skies

skies

Mega Audino takes on a Listerine-like appearance with this shiny, and, quite honestly, I love it. The blue is the appropriate shade to match the lightness that Mega Audino already radiates. Its colors bounce off of each other very nicely, and I find this shiny to be much more pleasant to look at than its current shiny.

Swiffix

Swiffix

I love the color turquoise, and I think it looks amazing on Mega Audino! To me, this reimagined concept turns Mega Audino into some type of deity of nature, and I'd even go as far to say that it elevates it to the level of some mythical Pokémon. Definitely a shiny I would rather have over the current one.


garchomp

What went wrong?

skies

skies

Garchomp... the poster child of shinies gone wrong. Garchomp's shiny is notorious for being underwhelming, and it's one of the biggest flaws of the Pokémon as a whole. Similarly to Gengar, Garchomp's pre-evolutions at least have a noticeable shift in color to indicate that they are shiny. However, Garchomp simply looks like its color got muddled. What makes Garchomp's shiny stick out like a sore thumb even more is similar to the reason Gengar's does—its shiny is a vastly different color. Unfortunately, something has to be done to fix up this lacking design.

Swiffix

Swiffix

Of all the Pokémon in this selection, Garchomp is the one which personally saddens me the most. Not only did they give this beast of a pseudo-legendary the terrible desaturation treatment, but they also blatantly ignored the epic-ness of shiny Gible when deciding on shiny forms for the rest of the line. I mean it was right there! Instead, the Garchomp line's shiny forms literally only get worse after each evolution stage and I hate them for it.

How do we fix it?

Inverted Original

skies

skies

Personally, I find this shiny an improvement, albeit a slight one. The red is a bit harsh, almost to the point of looking like Garchomp has become a representative for McDonald's with the shades of red and yellow laced throughout it. However, despite these flaws, the change still allows for a shiny Garchomp to very clearly be noticed as being shiny, and is thus still an improvement.

Swiffix

Swiffix

I know, I know, we keep inverting the colors of Pokémon and calling them better shinies, but they really are! I must say that I don't totally agree with skies on this one; the red, although bright, is a glorious color on this deadly landshark and truly makes the yellow highlights on its head and chest pop! Furthermore, the contrast between the white claws and red body really conveys the idea that Garchomp is a killing machine that you should not be messing with.

Mega Shiny

skies

skies

The comparison that Garchomp has a shiny, and really the main reason you'd be interested in obtaining a shiny Garchomp, a shiny recolored to match Mega Garchomp's shiny is undeniably an improvement. Pink gives a bit of a more feminine feel to clash with the tough appearance of Garchomp, a contrast I feel is quite interesting to explore. Given that Garchomp's Mega Evolution already takes on this concept, it only makes sense for Garchomp's original shiny to match.

Swiffix

Swiffix

I'm not gonna lie, I've never been a fan of shiny Mega Garchomp. Pink shinies in general don't particularly look good to me (looking at you, Heracross), and its mostly because pink often feels like a completely random choice on them. Garchomp is no exception—I simply don't get the pink. I would honestly rather change Mega Garchomp's shiny as well than recolor Garchomp's shiny based on it.

Sand

skies

skies

An entirely new shiny with a sleek reference, sand Garchomp has to be my favorite recolored shiny. It's a bit reminiscent of Krookodile's shiny, but with less saturated colors. Garchomp is a sand dweller, and its shiny being the color of sand makes perfect sense. Furthermore, the grey accent down the middle ties the entire look together by giving Garchomp a more menacing feel rather than being entirely beige.

Swiffix

Swiffix

Actually, this redesign is inspired by Hippowdon's color palette! It's a really cool concept for Garchomp, as the earthy colors clearly indicate its Ground typing while the draconic elements of its design are conveyed through it's rugged appearance. I wouldn't mind seeing it used on the entire evolutionary line!


persian

What went wrong?

skies

skies

Persian suffers the unfortunate fate of being too insignificant of a change that other mentioned shinies share (looking at you, Gengar). Persian is often noted as being a symbol of sophistication, yet its shiny does not reflect this. Normally, its shiny simply changes Persian's coat and inside of its ears. Really though, you will only notice the ears; the change in color on its coat is only slightly lighter. What fun is it to have a shiny with different colored ears? It certainly needs some help.

Swiffix

Swiffix

Persian's shiny must have been picked by a radical dog person. There's literally nothing special about it, which is unfortunate given the opportunities that its design allowed. Yes, Persian's concept is a rather simple one, but they still could have played with the color of its gemstone or something. Instead, we get yet another shiny that you would not be able to tell apart from the original 80% of the time.

How do we fix it?

White Cat

skies

skies

It's been noted in Persian's Pokédex entries that its gem will glow. How nice would it be if that gem glimmered a nice cyan rather than the lack of color change on its gem in its current shiny? Not only that, but a white coat gives Persian a much sleeker look to it. Changing the shiny to be white also gives Persian a more peaceful look, a nice contrast to its notable temperamental nature.

Swiffix

Swiffix

skies put it perfectly; Persian is a symbol of a sophistication. If you ask me, the silky white fur and glimmering turquoise gemstone elevate this aspect of its design to a whole other level. A white shiny Persian also offers a refreshing contrast from Persian's usually darker personality, which might be just what this Pokémon needs to step out of the shadows and become slightly more relevant.

Black Cat + Gold

skies

skies

Similar to Persian's Alolan form, Persian now dons a gleaming black coat. However, unlike its Alolan form, now its gem is gold! Gold is the perfect association here given Persian's association to money. Black and gold always look great together, and it applies here as well. Black is a color of elegance, something Persian's known for, so this shiny is only fitting for it.

Swiffix

Swiffix

I tend to associate the combination of black and gold to Ancient Egypt, and this case is no different! I can't help but picture this Persian being stroked by a Pharaoh while some Arabic music plays in the background. This redesign is extremely elegant and makes Shiny Persian appear much more powerful than its regular counterpart.

Grey Cat

skies

skies

With a grey shiny, Persian adopts a similar color palette to its Alolan form. Although it is the same colors, somehow this shiny still works. The shift in color makes Persian much more distinct, and its blue gem is a great flip from its usual red gem. Really, the grey on Persian gives it an even more somber appearance that helps it give off a more elusive vibe.

Swiffix

Swiffix

I love the reference to Alolan Persian's color palette, and I even think that I prefer it on the Kantonian variant. Sure, this Persian is not a Dark-type, but grey + blue never really screamed "Dark-type" in the first place. If anything, this darker design is on par with Kantonian Persian's dex entries, which describe it as being proud, mean, and temperamental. All in all a very solid redesign.


zekrom

What went wrong?

skies

skies

Unfortunately, Zekrom's shiny suffers a similar issue to Marshadow's—it is hardly noticeable unless you are in battle. When Zekrom is shiny, the tip on its forehead becomes a bright green, as does its tail when in combat. Admittedly, the shiny does look good in battle, but it can certainly be improved to give it even more uniqueness and flare.

Swiffix

Swiffix

Both of the Unovan box legendaries suffer from rather underwhelming shinies, but Reshiram's golden rings are at least somewhat noticeable and offer a minimum of contrast from its regular form. On the other hand, Zekrom just takes on a blueish tint, with no highlight or particularity whatsoever. They honestly just should've given the two dragons a color swap and called it a day. But they didn't. So here we are to fix it.

How do we fix it?

Silver

skies

skies

A sleek silver Zekrom immediately makes Zekrom's shiny more noticeable and exciting. With some pops of blue here and there, Zekrom receives a refreshing update to its shiny. Personally, I do think even this shiny could use some improvement, though it still benefits Zekrom as a whole by giving it more distinction than it currently has.

Swiffix

Swiffix

This dragon looks like it's made out of titanium and would blind you if you stared at it directly under the sunlight. The silver on Zekrom takes the "legendary" element to another level, almost reaching the status of divine. My favorite element of this redesign, however, is the electric blue highlights in the eyes and horn. Zekrom's eyes are usually red, which works well with its predominantly black color, but turning them blue along with the new silver brings the whole design together and adds a nice reference to its Electric typing.

Reshiram

skies

skies

A common theme from Pokémon fans has been wondering why Zekrom and Reshiram didn't swap their base colors for their shinies. Well we finally have one here! I am in the boat of this change being what should have been done originally, but alas. Zekrom swapping colors with its counterpart makes sense as another balance between their yin and yang dynamic.

Swiffix

Swiffix

Just color swap them man, it really wasn't that complicated of a decision to make. A shiny Zekrom boasting Reshiram's colors would work perfectly with the story in Black/White and the sequels, and it simply looks badass! Would it have been the easy way to go? Maybe. Would have been the better way to go? Absolutely.

Electric Blue

skies

skies

Here, we've taken an electric blue to overhaul Zekrom's shiny. The colors are vibrant, electric, and immediately let us know that Zekrom is bursting with energy. Not only that, but the blue ties it back into the final piece of the legendary trio, as it now has an electrified version of Kyurem's blue color.

Swiffix

Swiffix

This version of shiny Zekrom feels slightly weird to me. My main issue with it is that it uses a color that is very bright as base, which kinda makes the whole design unnecessarily "loud" to me. I do like that the color brings forward Zekrom's Electric typing, but the execution of it should probably reworked. Maybe doing something similar to Reshiram's shiny, where only some elements of Zekrom's body would take on this electric blue color, would make this design less aggressive on the eyes.


Final Thoughts

Shiny Pokémon are among the most magical and exciting features of the Pokémon franchise. Everyone remembers what their first shiny was and how they obtained it, and some of us dedicate hours to finding shiny variants of our favorite Pokémon. Shinies have the power to turn a Pokémon that you otherwise wouldn't care for into one of your all-time favorites. That being said, we've seen throughout this article that the opposite can also be true, with some shinies being so unremarkable that you might even let out a sigh of frustration when you encounter them.

That being said, Pokémon redesigns are not unheard of, so there's always a possibility that GameFreak might correct some of its mistakes in the future. And, who knows, the end result might look something similar to one of our suggestions! In the meantime, we can only share our thoughts and ideas for new versions of shinies, and hopefully you've enjoyed reading through them! And until we decide to explore some more disappointing shiny concepts, we bid you farewell for now!

HTML by Lumari. Avatars by Ciran and fx.
« Previous Article Next Article »