NOC Working Title Mafia (Game Thread) [Mafia Wins]

Alice Kazumi said:
I agree with m2h on ecat being different from his previous game. M2H do you still think des is town? She was really into reads doing last game and correctly called out players like AP being scum, she is not attempting them this one.
Click to expand...
oh if this was the case im way more sus of des now the fact that they dont seem to be even putting the effort makes me feel she might just trying to skate by as "probably newbie town" in an noc where ppl might be lighter on her for being new
 
joey said:
in trying to write out my defense to what I said I have come to the conclusion that I was wrong

here was my original thought process that I was trying to write out
"we have backups" isn't really good argument imo. Even if we would still have a tracker should the first tracker die, it's still a significant hit at town to lose one layer of defense on their ability to track

if someone CCs tracker, what do we gain today that we couldn't gain equally tomorrow? If someone CCs tracker right now, do we vote out Lechen immediately? I don't think so, that would mean we potentially waste our D1 vote and lose a PR (and this is where I realize that then whoever CC'd them gets voted out day 2 regardless and trading the 1 tracker for a mafia member is probably worth it so yes we do vote lechen out in this scenario)

conclusion i need to think more about my takes before I post them
Click to expand...
unironically joey feels townier from this post the thought processes/progression/whatever you call it from this feels super genuine
 
HydrogenHydreigon said:
oh if this was the case im way more sus of des now the fact that they dont seem to be even putting the effort makes me feel she might just trying to skate by as "probably newbie town" in an noc where ppl might be lighter on her for being ne
Click to expand...
I agree, better vote than redless imo. Vote des121
 
ok i think ive pinpointed why
all of pulsar's reads come off as super intentionally hedgy; the all have the format like oh this is [towniesh phrase here] but [mafiaish phrase here] or vise versa
 
After re-reading a bit, I think Redless is a bit suspicious. I didn't see him talk about many things, I think half of his posts are about Lechen and confirming what's already been confirmed.

The suspicions against Des don't make much sense to me. Des is behaving a bit strangely, yes, and isn't arguing much. But I think I read that she or someone said she would provide more analysis when she had information from Night 1 and when the game had developed more. Voting for her at this moment doesn't seem positive to me, her participation isn't having much impact. I think we should let her catch up a bit.
 
hh seems like a solid tr, pulsar isnt good at making reads besides when shes trying to mislynch me, i dont see what was so good about joeys progression besides that he realized he. posted smth stupid
 
The wagon on Jalmont doesn't catch my attention much, his playstyle is a bit unpredictable, but I see him as someone quite coherent when asked questions.

For now, I'm going to vote for Redless, with the possibility of changing my vote tomorrow.

vote Redless

If I change it, I honestly think I would go for Saber. I feel like he is staying too much on the sidelines. I don't feel like he's getting involved with the town.

Regarding Pulsar, I'd like to read the reads he said he would send tonight.
 
ElectricityCat said:
The wagon on Jalmont doesn't catch my attention much, his playstyle is a bit unpredictable, but I see him as someone quite coherent when asked questions.

For now, I'm going to vote for Redless, with the possibility of changing my vote tomorrow.

vote Redless

If I change it, I honestly think I would go for Saber. I feel like he is staying too much on the sidelines. I don't feel like he's getting involved with the town.

Regarding Pulsar, I'd like to read the reads he said he would send tonight.
Click to expand...
#1 why do you think redless is scum, #2 where did the insights on jalmonts playstyle come from, #3 do you have general townreads/scumreads?
 
genisu said:
also ElectricityCat i am having a glitch with my image signature could you help me troubleshoot it ty
Click to expand...
1721443922660.png

whats the glitch exactly? you can pm me in discord if its not related to the game
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top