NOC E.G.O Wielders Mafia - A 17P Role Madness (Game Thread) - MAFIA WIN

Celever said:
And both of these are different to corroded forms? During my 5 minute look at the wiki yesterday I think I saw a pic of a corroded guy and he looked both abnormal and distorted :row:
Click to expand...
yep, basically abnormalities are supernatural monsters, and being distorted is when you go insane enough that you transform into your own abnormality themed around you. Main difference between corrosion and distortion is that corrosions are only temporary while distortions (aside from a few special cases) are permanent transformations

yeahhh some corrosions are pretty insane
 
gm smogtown. I haven’t been posting too much and that trend might continue because of irl factors and me multitabling other mafia games I’m more invested in rn, but I’ll write a little bit of a catchup.


Pg. 1-5
Evie said:
Hello chat how are we feeling

btw do we know how many mafia roles there are
Click to expand...
I think this is a villagery opener, I know the question is fakeable yada yada but Evie kinda randomly segued into it mid typing the post in a way that I think is a natural spontaneous thought process rather than pre-planned to look uninformed.
Celever said:
Gm

We don’t it’s a fully closed setup which is fun bc they’re oddly rare on Smogon

With 17 players it’s realistically (if just town vs mafia) 4 or 5 though. Probably a tad likelier to be 5
Click to expand...
Mech/Setup talk bores me to death but yeah this is probably roughly what it looks like.
ImaginaryNeon said:
I'm assuming that the Crreamy/Wisteria shit is based on one of the games I missed (presumably one of the OCs), so I don't think there's much to read into there. (Also happy birthday, Wisteria.)
And there's not much else to read into at the moment other than maybe pulsar not knowing about ITAs, which is NAI as hell, so...Go-Go Gadget random image from my phone.
View attachment 751761
Click to expand...
Slightly towny from neon to actually give a fuck about the wisp lore and try to see if there’s anything to read into with it.
AngryPidgeon said:
##Vote: Des121
Click to expand...
This is a super random naked vote and idk what the purpose of it is, but we’re still in RVS I guess.
skippergamez said:
Guys what does it mean when my role pm says “5x night shot”????
Click to expand...
lol
StupidFlandrs48 said:
I've sort of accomplished something: noticing that Neon's posts are actually coherent and somewhat thought-out on a consistent basis. Last time I saw that he was my scummate, so this is somewhat concerning.
Click to expand...
I’m not sure how serious this post is meant to be but it reads to me like either a lazy read at best or just throwing shade at neon, like why would you assume it’s concerning to have coherent thoughts just because neon did once when they were scum with you lol.
pulsar512b said:
this might be a weird hill to die on but i really think neon has been trying and succeeding in helping more and more and making better posts, and i think its really disrespectful and if i was him i would feel a little discouraged so id recommend you avoid saying this sort of thing. also its d1 youre basing this off 2 posts chill
Click to expand...
+1
pulsar512b said:
i generally dislike this sort of reasoning but its probably a slight townread for you (even if im not sure if youre right) based on effort to argue for someone being town. like i dont think mafia does this whole jumping around? im not sure. its probably literally nai though
Click to expand...
I’m pinged a bit by the hedginess at the end of this post, also think yapping about mech is generally pretty NAI and a good way to look like you’re doing something without doing something as scum.

Pg. 6
NightEmerald said:
this is town, by the simple rule of oh my fucking god please smogon town have some initiative please I fucking beg
Click to expand...
Complaining about inactivity is pretty NAI, though there are good reads to be made based on the urgency to get the ball rolling after complaining about inactivity (scum tend to moan performatively then not really do much about it, town show initiative to start solving the game that is usually quite noticeable when you’re paying attention to it.)
NightEmerald said:
It’s lone town hunting in a way that feels entirely selfish. Mafia wouldn’t have to do this, since they already know who’s town, and skipper unless they went to the mafia monks in the himalayas wouldn’t really post that type of line of reasoning when they could latch onto the convo at hand
Click to expand...
NightEmerald said:
i think that selfish “in a good way” because it’s solving for yourself as opposed to solving for someone expecting an answer out of you
Click to expand...
I think this kind of conviction in a read on a slot that’s more in the perimeter of the game (idk if this makes sense but w/3) is a good look for NE, I also see the reasoning and it makes some sense.
wisteriapurple said:
rip too late

anyway i did re-read AP and off-vibes i'm thinking town? his progression on cel seems legitimate and i liked #119 from him
on the other hand, #113 from flandrs makes me feel a tad woozy, mainly because

reads like "reading too much into something" at best and "grasping straws to discredit a slot" at worst
instinct says these two are unpartnered at least

i want to say i agree with the trs NE posted but i feel like skip has posted too little for me to solidly endorse a tr on them

someone massping me to read the rest of the (more than one)posters later on but for now i'm content to shelf everyone else who has (more than one)posted as "not scummy" since i haven't seen anything particularly egregious
though it would imply that scum is in the inactives which is mildly annoying
Click to expand...
Bolded section is pretty bad especially after digging into flandrs and getting scummy pings from him, I just don’t see why V!Wisp would be so willing to churn through LHF zero posters after her previous posting.

If you don’t wanna read allat just ask me abt stuff in thread.

Also additional thoughts I couldn’t really convey in my multiquotes, I think ch3 and skipper just randomly partial claiming roles is something that’s more likely to come from town than not, and cele has overall been posting well recently just not anything in particular I can glance on and be like oooh that’s villagery.

My reads so far look like

Town
Nightemerald
Celever
Skipper
ch3
Neon
Evie
——-
A fairy
Des
Joey
Apricity
DBD
M2H
——-
Pulsar
Flandrs
Wisp
Scum

In order


##Vote: Wisteriapurple
 
Celever said:
“Mafia are in the inactives” scumtell popping off in the thread damnnn
Click to expand...
i can reframe my thought if it'd better make sense for u :sob:
like i'll admit i've been lazier this game than i usually am but rn my head's at
AngryPidgeon - probably just town for reasons i've stated in #146
Celever - probably just town too (i didn't mention it earlier but your posting seems genuine and hence is likely coming from a town POV)
pulsar512b - vibes hit towny here as well, #120 reads defensive of neon in a towny manner (it doesn't read partnered at all) + i like the effort she employed to read AP in #123; not a fan of the whole d1 is usually NAI thing tho i can see where that comes from :stares at my second-to-last tier:
NightEmerald - vibes hit towny thus far and i'm usually able to snipe his alignment early on so i'm decently confident
wisteriapurple - me
skippergamez - three posts but one is a read, i guess i see what NE means but like i said earlier i don't want to solidly endorse a tr on skip yet before they post more. #85 is probably genuine in that i don't see anyone bringing up "5x night shot" unprompted
a fairy - off skim her ISO seems null-ish which is ? for how much she has posted. might have to cross-ref this with her posting in lumiose
apricity - no posts
Ch3mdah - posted a NV + some discussion of flavour i.e. NAI
CrreamyKitty - nothing on CK i just famously suck at reading him so i'm holding off on this one first
Dead By Daylight - no posts
des121 - two posts, both NAI
Evie - one post that is about the possible number of mafia present (i.e. NAI)
ImaginaryNeon - i see the sentiment about him posting with more effort than usual, personally i want to see if he employs any analysis of fellow users in the game before i make a decision
joey - five posts, all of them NAI
M2H - no posts
StupidFlandrs48 - i've expressed my doubts about this slot in #146, im not 100% on this being scum yet but still
rn i have 10 slots in null with 7 of them being there because they don't have enough for me to go off of (hence why i mentioned the "scum lies in the inactives" thing)
trust me i've expressed a dislike of that notion before (NE and CK may be able to attest to this?) but i was serious when i said i felt like i was hitting walls here

wait lmao cel you got me to re-read everyone i guess i will be efforting the game
maybe it's too early for a coloured readslist but also i really just want smth going on help
 
CrreamyKitty said:
gm smogtown. I haven’t been posting too much and that trend might continue because of irl factors and me multitabling other mafia games I’m more invested in rn, but I’ll write a little bit of a catchup.


Pg. 1-5
I think this is a villagery opener, I know the question is fakeable yada yada but Evie kinda randomly segued into it mid typing the post in a way that I think is a natural spontaneous thought process rather than pre-planned to look uninformed.

Mech/Setup talk bores me to death but yeah this is probably roughly what it looks like.

Slightly towny from neon to actually give a fuck about the wisp lore and try to see if there’s anything to read into with it.

This is a super random naked vote and idk what the purpose of it is, but we’re still in RVS I guess.

lol

I’m not sure how serious this post is meant to be but it reads to me like either a lazy read at best or just throwing shade at neon, like why would you assume it’s concerning to have coherent thoughts just because neon did once when they were scum with you lol.

+1

I’m pinged a bit by the hedginess at the end of this post, also think yapping about mech is generally pretty NAI and a good way to look like you’re doing something without doing something as scum.

Pg. 6
Complaining about inactivity is pretty NAI, though there are good reads to be made based on the urgency to get the ball rolling after complaining about inactivity (scum tend to moan performatively then not really do much about it, town show initiative to start solving the game that is usually quite noticeable when you’re paying attention to it.)


I think this kind of conviction in a read on a slot that’s more in the perimeter of the game (idk if this makes sense but w/3) is a good look for NE, I also see the reasoning and it makes some sense.

Bolded section is pretty bad especially after digging into flandrs and getting scummy pings from him, I just don’t see why V!Wisp would be so willing to churn through LHF zero posters after her previous posting.

If you don’t wanna read allat just ask me abt stuff in thread.

Also additional thoughts I couldn’t really convey in my multiquotes, I think ch3 and skipper just randomly partial claiming roles is something that’s more likely to come from town than not, and cele has overall been posting well recently just not anything in particular I can glance on and be like oooh that’s villagery.

My reads so far look like

Town
Nightemerald
Celever
Skipper
ch3
Neon
Evie
——-
A fairy
Des
Joey
Apricity
DBD
M2H
Click to expand...
Angrypigeon
CrreamyKitty said:
——-
Pulsar
Flandrs
Wisp
Scum

In order


##Vote: Wisteriapurple
Click to expand...
EBWOP I forgot AP existed lmao
 
NightEmerald said:
It’s lone town hunting in a way that feels entirely selfish. Mafia wouldn’t have to do this, since they already know who’s town, and skipper unless they went to the mafia monks in the himalayas wouldn’t really post that type of line of reasoning when they could latch onto the convo at hand
Click to expand...
Omg NE thinks I’m town #townlock

I do feel like this string of posts from NE feels towny from him. iirc NE tends to pop in and give some comments. He often gets scumread for doing too little (including by me). But he flips town a lot even then.
 
wisteriapurple said:
tbh the only other time i played with neon was 6 months ago (oml) and the only thing i remember of it was he subbed into a town slot mid-game and was struggling to catch up with 100+ pages of posts
Click to expand...
This is basically how trying to sheet MU games winds up going for me but instead of subbing in and persevering I in normally and give up when I'm thousands of posts behind on a site with a significantly higher density of reads than on here.
 
Latter half of 104  could imply 3p!AP trying to steer discussion away from the potential existence of a 3p but I'm not really confident enough in that read to push it that much.
But it is at least  something, and we are on D1, so I might as well vote it.
##Vote: AngryPidgeon
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top