NOC E.G.O Wielders Mafia - A 17P Role Madness (Game Thread) - MAFIA WIN

Looking at ch3mdah I am teetering between wanting to throw him off a cliff for existing in the thread but posting nothing of substance except about himself while still posting mech spec, and giving him a pass for some early game stuff that seemed towny in a tonal sense
 
Re: wis scumgames, I keep putting thought into the question only to come out with an answer that doesn’t quite fit so I’ll just say that I think the main slip is that in liveposting where if you press her on train of thought she doesn’t really have answers that *work*
 
M2H said:
Looking at ch3mdah I am teetering between wanting to throw him off a cliff for existing in the thread but posting nothing of substance except about himself while still posting mech spec, and giving him a pass for some early game stuff that seemed towny in a tonal sense
Click to expand...
i mean if we were to throw chemdah off a cliff what would we get out of it? I feel like the answer is nothing but dead chemdah
 
Evie said:
My scumreads may be misjudged or of poor quality since i am not used to reads at all but here goes:

Celever- Im slightly scumleaning because there were a lot of aggressive reads that didnt make a ton of sense, and wasn't something i saw a lot of from them when i last played with them as town. I believe they might be trying to go off the fact that people would expect a strong mafia player to not make crazy scumreads as scum.

pulsar - i have a veryyyyy slight scumlean since a lot of their content is just small conversation, which seems like something a mafia who is trying to stay under the radar but still seem active might do. However I have never played with them before so this might just be normal for them, who knows.

ck - their day 1 seems similar to when i last played with them in that they tend to be active and push people with not much to go off, so im leaning town for them

a fairy- i think shes likely to be town since she has been pretty active in making reads and sparking discussion when i think scum fairy is much less likely to do so

will probably try make more reads in the future but this is what im feeling for now. take everything with a grain of salt
Click to expand...

evie transitions from a scumlean list to a townlean list midway through here which could be interesting
 
Evie said:
Ok ill come out and say it now since with Celever establishing a link between me and a fairy i dont think a fairy will try to link with me further.

In #446, I gave the inclination towards town fairy, however im actually more suspicious towards fairy than i said (not saying im scumleaning but i am suspicious). I did this to see if fairy would try to pocket me further, given that they would probably know im very vulnerable to pocketing (joey would know)
Click to expand...

interesting gambit
 
ok i havent been hallucinating ap has straight up missed both of my prods
whether it is on purpose or not do not know
wisteriapurple said:
i mean i'm definitely happy to talk this through
the whole readslist shenanigans we had earlier today particularly reminded me of her conduct in lumiose legends mafia, where i got the same feeling of pulling teeth when trying to get her to generate content. she wound up flipping town there too
i'm not saying that des is 100% town here, moreso that i'm definitely not gonna be fully writing her off i think :wo:
Click to expand...
bump
and bumping the joey null q
AngryPidgeon
 
##vote Evie

Both votes that Evie made yesterday were justified based on them voting her, while she gave vague justifications for them after the fact, the fairy gambit idea was awkward and it seems that Evie knew fairy/joey the best and thus a fearkill on fairy would actually make some sense from her POV, she comes into the thread at certain points in the celever wagon in what appear to be token attempts to show support for her team but lack any real teeth.
 
Evie said:
At the moment im incredibly suspicious of celever, mainly because of this vote. To me, this just seems like celever immediately jumping on the fact that someone else is suspicious of me and using that to try and start a wagon on me. I think I'd be very easy to start a wagon on due to having a relatively low post count and being new to mafia, as well as the fact that there was already some collective suspicion towards me. The fact that the vote wasn't posted without any reasoning of his own definitely doesnt help the case.
Click to expand...
Evie said:
this vote feels really opportunistic to me, as if flandrs might have realised his scumbuddy celever is getting too much heat and needs to switch it to someone who is gaining momentum.

I mean you said it yourself, im an easy target for scum counterwagons and that seems to be what youre going for here

Im reading a flandrs/celever scumteam who wanted to fight early in d1 to try and not appear linked, and flandrs is trying to save his scumbuddy now after the celever wagon got too big
Click to expand...
from evie: honestly the thing that pushes me most towards a flandrs celever scumteam is just the fact that i think theyve come off scummy to me

Evie said:
I was the first (or one of the first idk) to start the wagon on celever, and like yeah sure i posted my vote after hal's post but i think its a weird argument to make that i was being opportunistic

also the "manufactured" feeling might come from the fact im thinking more about how my posts come off as ive often been misunderstood in the past
Click to expand...

very defensive
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top