NOC E.G.O Wielders Mafia - A 17P Role Madness (Game Thread) - MAFIA WIN

I reread Evie and I don't think she's necessarily a bad vote. She's done two things this game

1. The thing with a fairy which is either a) town gambit, or b) mafia defense
2. Retaliating against people who voted her (including hopping on the Celever wagon based off this)

I'd still rather vote Skipper or NE today and I'm sure people are tired of me saying that

But I would definitely supporting voting Evie over hal right now.

Hal's pushing of the Celever vote isn't particularly sus to me, I found his reasoning to be pretty compelling yesterday and I can see it coming from a town pov. Today I don't really know what to make of any of the arguments but I'm almost feeling like the biggest characters of the day (hal/ap/m2h in my view) are potentially all town
 
I reread Evie and I don't think she's necessarily a bad vote. She's done two things this game

1. The thing with a fairy which is either a) town gambit, or b) mafia defense
2. Retaliating against people who voted her (including hopping on the Celever wagon based off this)

I'd still rather vote Skipper or NE today and I'm sure people are tired of me saying that

But I would definitely supporting voting Evie over hal right now.

Hal's pushing of the Celever vote isn't particularly sus to me, I found his reasoning to be pretty compelling yesterday and I can see it coming from a town pov. Today I don't really know what to make of any of the arguments but I'm almost feeling like the biggest characters of the day (hal/ap/m2h in my view) are potentially all town

Evie interactions with hal are also pretty sus.

Hal on Cel isn't very sus to me, but the jump from Hal to AP / me is a bit harder for me to buy. I would expect Hal to be a little more pragmatic in solving the less active slots / null slots here because I know town!hal knows this game is headed for the trash heap at this point.
 
Can you expand on this / point me to a post

I feel like I completely missed that

well evie is a player that seemed very scared of being pocketed by you and fairy, but she piggybacked pretty hard on hal's celever case and didn't really seem skeptical about hal's slot at all. there is also the timing issue where it seems to me that evie came in just a few hours before deadline iirc to bolster the celever wagon and then dissapeared d2. i could see her getting pinged in the scumchat to show up and say anything and she tried her best at eod but overall her game as a whole is flighty and evasive. I sense a lot of fear coming from that slot.
 
Back
Top