evie mentioned later on that she meant that the doc fails if any other non-killing actions target her target
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC E.G.O Wielders Mafia - A 17P Role Madness (Game Thread) - MAFIA WIN
- Thread starter HydrogenHydreigon
- Start date
No I'm just dense
That still feels really fakable
It's 100% fakeable and I don't think Evie escapes suspicion but the possibility of it being real and blocking a nightkill is really strong
And if it is fake, Evie being alive protects a real doctor from nightkills inherently because mafia would be exposing one of their own by exposing a counterclaim
And if it is fake, Evie being alive protects a real doctor from nightkills inherently because mafia would be exposing one of their own by exposing a counterclaim
I love it when people overestimate my awareness of the present tense
Okay so the entire case is just "we want a vote that does nothing" which is just kinda ???
. . .
Wait yeah why ISN'T Evie dead?
Okay M2H did technically have a similar role.
Fine.
maybe they expected me to self target? Or that since my slot is still quite controversial they could try and push a vote on me much easier than on M2H
no I can see why if Evie is truly doctor she didn't die yesterday. M2H would've gotten a buncchhhhh of towncred today, so it makes sense that M2H died first.
I mean if evie is town the easy answer is, oh we will just have two actions target our kill target and now it's unblockable
I noticed NE's vote++ is not reflected in the vote count which does not seem very standard to me I wonder if that's something the host can confirm.
gamespec perspective: every role that's flipped so far has been fairly standard without any weird restrictions so that tends to make me believe that odds are fairly ok that NE and evie are probably lying about their role. NE's restriction is so bizarre and literally has anyone heard of something like that? on the plus side I guess it's kind of fun. Evie's restriction is just really odd too PLUS we already seem to have a ton of ways to stop or redirect night kills so idk. maybe someone can look into if evie slipped by calling Hal Hal, since unless they were scum buddies or it was mentioned in thread evie would probably call hal apricity.
I'm going to be honest guys I have a horrible timezone and I forgot deadlines are so fast. I don't have time tonight to read through the game or have an informed opinion on anything. I just kind of ended up getting subbed in, I probably would have declined had I understand the circumstances. Sorry
I noticed NE's vote++ is not reflected in the vote count which does not seem very standard to me I wonder if that's something the host can confirm.
gamespec perspective: every role that's flipped so far has been fairly standard without any weird restrictions so that tends to make me believe that odds are fairly ok that NE and evie are probably lying about their role. NE's restriction is so bizarre and literally has anyone heard of something like that? on the plus side I guess it's kind of fun. Evie's restriction is just really odd too PLUS we already seem to have a ton of ways to stop or redirect night kills so idk. maybe someone can look into if evie slipped by calling Hal Hal, since unless they were scum buddies or it was mentioned in thread evie would probably call hal apricity.
I'm going to be honest guys I have a horrible timezone and I forgot deadlines are so fast. I don't have time tonight to read through the game or have an informed opinion on anything. I just kind of ended up getting subbed in, I probably would have declined had I understand the circumstances. Sorry
definitely, which is a good thing for town because an additional mafia action going on the kill target means that action isn't going on a townie like it otherwise would be
In #2,008 NE said that it is reflected in the vote count
everyones been calling them hal + its their name in circus maximus discord + its in their custom title
real Quick Look at the wagons. I'm just willing to town clear everyone who voted Hal on day 2 (especially joey and skip as I said before). it seems absolutely crazy to me to bus your teammate the hopes that scum neon and scum Flanders will carry the team to victory. and we can probably clear neon harder because that's who Hal was trying to wagon.
des wist and pulsar are just people in this game I guess. at least pulsar was on a celever counter wagon.
ok it's just totally CRAZY to me that celever claimed tracker and everyone was like "lol k". oh my god I totally forgot CK is in this game that's right CK saw celever claim tracker and was like yeah idgaf get him out like HUH????? day 2 CK I don't really have a read on.
alright wist also knew that celever was a tracker and decided that was the best vote at the end of day 1. interesting. need to look like definitely but don't have time right now.
idk what chemdah's claim means I kind of what to ignore it because if it means what I think it means that evie is town. which is actually why we can't ignore it. I dunno - I guess if we do want to vote evie then chemdah needs to claim if they have information that would be useful as far as what we should do we an evie vote
follow up on my timezone. I have like 2 hours when I wake up to look at the thread which I definitely won't be doing because I need to go to class. so yeah. maybe I'll check real fast if I need to claim because I'm getting wagoned. alright I spent way too much time on this bye
des wist and pulsar are just people in this game I guess. at least pulsar was on a celever counter wagon.
ok it's just totally CRAZY to me that celever claimed tracker and everyone was like "lol k". oh my god I totally forgot CK is in this game that's right CK saw celever claim tracker and was like yeah idgaf get him out like HUH????? day 2 CK I don't really have a read on.
alright wist also knew that celever was a tracker and decided that was the best vote at the end of day 1. interesting. need to look like definitely but don't have time right now.
idk what chemdah's claim means I kind of what to ignore it because if it means what I think it means that evie is town. which is actually why we can't ignore it. I dunno - I guess if we do want to vote evie then chemdah needs to claim if they have information that would be useful as far as what we should do we an evie vote
follow up on my timezone. I have like 2 hours when I wake up to look at the thread which I definitely won't be doing because I need to go to class. so yeah. maybe I'll check real fast if I need to claim because I'm getting wagoned. alright I spent way too much time on this bye
no
can you explain to me why when you saw clever's claim of tracker, and in that moment you were not being pressured whatsoever, you decided the best place to leave your vote was on celever?
w that I have your attention
can you explain to me why when you saw clever's claim of tracker, and in that moment you were not being pressured whatsoever, you decided the best place to leave your vote was on celever?
why are you sr’ing AP when you havent even looked at any posts
would like to hear your reasoningings on the other scum reads
do you still want to vote out NE today? what do you think about NE's claim that he gets votes every time he correctly guesses how many actions fail at night
what people do you think could be the mafia team? is it still NE/skip/hal? if so, what do you think the mafia strategy day 2 was, with NE joining Hal on neon, and skip being a leading vote to get majority onto Hal?
if you are town I want to keep you in the game but I need something more to work with if possible. thanks. (and by me, I mean every town person because I won't be here lol)
read 2164 and 2167
the basic idea is that usually mafia want to vote out town and not their teammates. I usually use that basic framework to think about what the mafia is doing and what sorts of strategies they might want to pursue. of course this time I don't have a lot of time so I can't really super expand on these basic thoughts but maybe someone else can
I'm not scum reading AP I have him as vibe town but I really don't know
did you not put him as part of your scum team on 2169?