NOC E.G.O Wielders Mafia - A 17P Role Madness (Game Thread) - MAFIA WIN

n1: 4 n2: 2 if that matters to anyone, both didn’t work.

Wrt my reds, it’s realiti/ck as the primary one, ck was interacting with the thread boringly and I feel like i can argue that he was avoiding thread conflict over solving, and realiti is aforementioned
 
it’s something i want to do an idea list (similar to what i did w skipper for) because tmk evie’s been so incredibly one note and reactive (as opposed to proactive) that they just read as perpetually frozen, but I feel like that started even before they were pressured and it’s icking me
 
NightEmerald said:
it’s something i want to do an idea list (similar to what i did w skipper for) because tmk evie’s been so incredibly one note and reactive (as opposed to proactive) that they just read as perpetually frozen, but I feel like that started even before they were pressured and it’s icking me
Click to expand...
but rn i wouldn’t vote them because i don’t think I’ve put in the effort to read them and even if id done THAT id vote realiti first
 
joey said:
you are AP and hal is ap, not confusing at all
Click to expand...
:psycry:

--

Here is where Im at

JALMONT is absolutely not voteable today. Because hes one of the few people actually providing content in the thread and trying to solve the game. That said he needs to polish his opinions cause some of them seem a bit rough.

M2H kill / Evie claim. For me this is the elephant in the room. Evie claimed to protect him, but he died anyways. Evie's role restriction is a very convenient claim and Evie even agreed with me today that maybe claiming the restriction was maybe not the wisest idea. I think its pretty much guaranteed that either Evie is mafia or there is a mafia non-killing role that also targeted M2H last night. Im going to say I know Skippergamez targeted M2H last night. There may be someone out there who also targeted M2H but is obviously not admitting to it. I can confirm 100% that I did not target M2H last night and I think at some point we need to resolve this. Anyone who can prove they didn't target M2H last night has an alibi and cant be the guilty party in the M2H kill. So tentatively I think one of Evie/Skipper is mafia here but there could be some other unknown person who actually targeted M2H to blank Evie's role who is simply never going to admit it.

NE Claim. I dont like that NE hasn't claimed the numbers he guessed on N1/N2 or that he didn't come out with the info right away that his role shows up in the VC. His role is a pseudo information role because it does indicate how many people were or weren't blocked. But since presumably he failed both nights, that gives us much less info to go off of. Still he should have claimed the guessed numbers even if its not quite as useful information. Im tempted to vote NE for meta reasons and for my gripes about his claim, but there is also an air that NE is a de facto lynch today and Im worried its a sign that scum is pushing him. Oh bonus I still believe he had no real reason to be upset with me on D2 and Realiti seeing the same thing makes me more confident that its not just me being too close to the situation to have an unbiased opinion.

Chemdah claim. So far a nothingburger and I feel like he might be stringing people along just like that fable of the woman who told part of a story to the evil tyrant every night so that he wanted to hear the ending and kept her alive. Pretty much my entire view of Chemdah is that.

Joey/Wisteria. Dont like that he dodged my (albeit deadend) question about being a deepwolf. Or did I miss it? I also dont like that Wisteria responded to my accusation of Joey before Joey even had a chance to see the question. I think Joey being a deepwolf would make sense if he is a late voter on the Apricity wagon and hes been fairly careful to avoid conflicts in the thread so far. I wouldnt be surprised if Apricity told him in mafia chat to bus. I havent seen too much progression from Joey in later days, definite coasting vibes. Also to answer Wisteria's question, it unironically did come to me in a dream. I took a week off from being a stoner so my dreams are coming back and I do dream about mafia when I fall asleep scrolling the page.

Des121. Probably not mafia with Evie. I dont understand her progression on Apricity(??). She said she was wrong about her reads but I still dont understand what read she thinks she was wrong about. She said Apricity could be mafia and was overall fairly fence-sitty about that read so its odd to say she was wrong. I think Des has been less proactive than other games about asking people specific or interesting questions. I know I know she is broadly being Des, but something is missing. Big FoS on Des and honestly I could see her being mafia with almost anyone from a pairing/unpairing perspective.

--

Realiti, JALMONT, pulsar, Neon earn a pass for me for now. Skipper Im still inclined to believe is town but the Evie/M2H situation NEEDS to be resolved.
 
i also need to reread to find the person who said m2h sred me because they’re a townie who’s reading thread from the iss

hi ap
i told you the answers late cause they’re werent specified in my pm
wrt guesses yes that was my bad
 
With tracker dead and AP not visiting M2H I am a little bit confused on what role AP would be but maybe it shouldn't be further clarified, I don't expect that he would be making up a result here
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top