NOC WikiMafia 2 Game Thread [Day 3]

[Dead by Daylight]

This is hilarious bc that was my exact reaction but also I think you're very likely scum but you're the one explaining why the person deciding not to vote you is scummy for not voting you??? @_@

I was gonna just write it off as me being paranoid tho bc I do think the post was p good so I get where peum would be coming from. Idk if you two are scum together this is some high art scum theatre

mindmelding with scum:

 

[StupidFlandrs48]

Our most legendary game since revival involved a ton of us half-joking about everyone being screwed if there’s a godfather and then there was a godfather and town won anyway

All of that is to say it’s in the realm of possibility setup-wise, even without Celever mentioning that the game is quasi-bastard

 

[Blizihguh]

Issuing correction to my previous post: you do not, under any circumstances, "gotta hand it to" bluedoom

 

[Dead by Daylight]

Blizihguh hey would appreciate if you'd post some form of updated readlist

 

[Blizihguh]

Blizihguh hey would appreciate if you'd post some form of updated readlist

I literally did this like fifteen minutes ago??????

 

[Dead by Daylight]

am i blind?

 

[Dead by Daylight]

Ftr I am not typing up my entire reads list on my phone in the car but this is close to where I'm at. Here are my patch notes:

AF and AirC townier, in my skim of EOD2 it seems like they could have easily voted saber and chose to help bury bd instead. Also given their antics at the start of today I don't think genisu can be scum with AF lol. In general I also get a good vibe off of AF's posting and analysis so they're more towny than Airc imo.

DBD I have redder, the early bd defense really reeks of scum trying to enable a hard lurking buddy imo.

Neutral on des, I haven't seen them do much but ig this is their meta

Saber prob town. Saber being the lynch dueling with bd is somewhat exonerating. That being said if they're town I would expect scum to have been voting them. With town saber I'd imagine at most one scum is on bd since any more and they actively chose to kill bd instead of saber. With the way bd was posting yesterday I think he had a fair chance to survive D3 if he actually made it out of D2.

By that same logic I think Phoopes and genisu look worse. Would not be surprised by scum as Phoopes genisu bd dbd + one person from the other wagon

ok i am blind oops

 

[a fairy]

Our most legendary game since revival involved a ton of us half-joking about everyone being screwed if there’s a godfather and then there was a godfather and town won anyway

All of that is to say it’s in the realm of possibility setup-wise, even without Celever mentioning that the game is quasi-bastard

was this pmd?

 

[Dead by Daylight]

decent readlist outside of me, hard agree on the Saber point

 

[StupidFlandrs48]

was this pmd?

Yes. All hail PMD

 

[a fairy]

i popped off that game

 

[genisu]

Btw speaking of this, we know that Bluedoom targeted Pulsar n1. This could be coached ofc because reading their ability there's no downside of giving it to mafia unless you're afraid of the locked actions. But certainly gives pulsar more credibility than a lot of ppl here.

how?

 

[Dead by Daylight]

blindness strikes pt. 2 - i cannot find airc's vote on bluedoom

 

[a fairy]

blindness strikes pt. 2 - i cannot find airc's vote on bluedoom

2210

 

[Dead by Daylight]

found ty, no objections to this

 

[genisu]

was pmd the charlie game, sorry i just got home

 

[genisu]

i finished running and cheering for my teammates at a meet

 

[genisu]

Ftr I am not typing up my entire reads list on my phone in the car but this is close to where I'm at. Here are my patch notes:

AF and AirC townier, in my skim of EOD2 it seems like they could have easily voted saber and chose to help bury bd instead. Also given their antics at the start of today I don't think genisu can be scum with AF lol. In general I also get a good vibe off of AF's posting and analysis so they're more towny than Airc imo.

DBD I have redder, the early bd defense really reeks of scum trying to enable a hard lurking buddy imo.

Neutral on des, I haven't seen them do much but ig this is their meta

Saber prob town. Saber being the lynch dueling with bd is somewhat exonerating. That being said if they're town I would expect scum to have been voting them. With town saber I'd imagine at most one scum is on bd since any more and they actively chose to kill bd instead of saber. With the way bd was posting yesterday I think he had a fair chance to survive D3 if he actually made it out of D2.

By that same logic I think Phoopes and genisu look worse. Would not be surprised by scum as Phoopes genisu bd dbd + one person from the other wagon

as later stated, saber is by no means exonerating. I'm also a little confused, do I look worse because i was on the saber wagon?

 

[genisu]

genisu: #2109 is quite bad, as he acknowledges one of the reasons for why bd is scummy but does nothing to defend him outside of a vote on saber. #1730 again has the same issue as #2109, although this time there is a half-cooked attempt at a defense. The progression from #1551 to #1923 doesn't seem clear to me either - there are no posts talking about this pairing until he shades Tommy at #1923. going back further, #1238 is also a post that doesn't come from town and to me is a scum pre-flipping in order to try and push a vote. Again, would put this slot towards the bottom of my POE.

is there a way to directly go to those posts, its kinda annoying to scroll tbh

 

[Blizihguh]

as later stated, saber is by no means exonerating. I'm also a little confused, do I look worse because i was on the saber wagon?

If saber is scum yeah

As we've established my reads post kinda overstated my feelings about saber. I do think town saber is more likely than scum now but mostly I just think if they ARE town we have a LOT of info about scum from the bd lynch

 

[genisu]

bluedoom came back, even though he likes to js chill as mafia, i think saber is the better vote ##vote: saberslasher11

I think bluedoom chills as both t and m ngl, hes not much of a yapper but tends to stay in the background on either alignment. Saber also I believed was a legitimate wagon(wait dbd you were on there too so)

 

[genisu]

If saber is scum yeah

As we've established my reads post kinda overstated my feelings about saber. I do think town saber is more likely than scum now but mostly I just think if they ARE town we have a LOT of info about scum from the bd lynch

so do you think its worth it to flip saber for the info? what kind of deductions would you make either way

 

[genisu]

i was actually one of the earliest people on bd helping the wagon form, but was really indecisive once bd came back and made a few decent posts

 

[genisu]

also who the fuck called pulsar towny because they were persuaded by bluedoom

 

[genisu]

there was no benefit to bluedoom to give town an extra shot, only to scummates right?