I still think that dbd being mafia is unlikely, miyami could be but I still dont think so. We can get information on Celever by doing nothing, so I still think we can continue Scenario 2 by voting phoopes
-
Smogon Premier League is here and the team collection is now available. Support your team!
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Tracker Jailer Follower - Game Thread - Day 4!
- Thread starter AngryPidgeon
- Start date
looking at last game that could work out LOL
2. Dead by Daylight probtown
5. ShyPebble afk with reasoning, not gonna angleshoot, null
joey null
Peum probtown
8. Miyami~~~ probtown
9. phoopes probscum
10. pulsar512b null
11. ImaginaryNeon null
12. Celever probtown
13. jalmont slight scumlean
5. ShyPebble afk with reasoning, not gonna angleshoot, null
joey null
Peum probtown
8. Miyami~~~ probtown
9. phoopes probscum
10. pulsar512b null
11. ImaginaryNeon null
12. Celever probtown
13. jalmont slight scumlean
crazy that my second and third most scummy reads absolutely jumped on the chance to vote for me IMMEDIATELY after genisu claims follower and votes for me
just letting y'all know that it's not OMGUS should I end up voting for one of them
(the joey scumread is really just from AirC's slot because joey hasn't done anything one way or another to really move me in either direction)
just letting y'all know that it's not OMGUS should I end up voting for one of them
(the joey scumread is really just from AirC's slot because joey hasn't done anything one way or another to really move me in either direction)
Why are you surprised that once there's reasoning to not vote Celever (The Mafia Roleblocker and him not visiting) I would end up voting you
This was previous votecount
genisu unvote
Miyami vote genisu
genisu vote phoopes
joey vote phoopes
Peum unvote
Peum vote phoopes
phoopes unvote
so that gets us to:
genisu (3): Dead by Daylight, jalmont, Miyami
Dead by Daylight (1): ImaginaryNeon
Celever (1): pulsar512b
Peum (1): Celever
phoopes (3) genisu, joey, Peum
Not voting: ShyPebble, phoopes
since:
genisu unvote
Miyami vote genisu
genisu vote phoopes
joey vote phoopes
Peum unvote
Peum vote phoopes
phoopes unvote
so that gets us to:
genisu (3): Dead by Daylight, jalmont, Miyami
Dead by Daylight (1): ImaginaryNeon
Celever (1): pulsar512b
Peum (1): Celever
phoopes (3) genisu, joey, Peum
Not voting: ShyPebble, phoopes
walk me through how you got to Celever being mafia roleblocker
With the existence of both tracker and follower, we are either in setup 3 or 4. how are you so sure that Celever is mafia roleblocker when we could still be in setup 3? Peum
Post #458
Celever points out a Peum scumslip that no one else jumped on, but I made a note of. Very possible that Peum knows there is a roleblocker because he is part of mafia. I could be charitable and say, "maybe he knows we're in setup 4 because he's jailkeeper," but between the linked scumslip AND the fact that Peum specifically said "roleblocker," not "roleblocker/rolecop" (since mafia have a choice on what they pick) makes me think Peum has outed himself as mafia
##vote: Peum
Celever points out a Peum scumslip that no one else jumped on, but I made a note of. Very possible that Peum knows there is a roleblocker because he is part of mafia. I could be charitable and say, "maybe he knows we're in setup 4 because he's jailkeeper," but between the linked scumslip AND the fact that Peum specifically said "roleblocker," not "roleblocker/rolecop" (since mafia have a choice on what they pick) makes me think Peum has outed himself as mafia
##vote: Peum
That's not my reasoning, the reasoning includes mech stuff, Right now we're in between Setup 3 (Town Tracker, Town Follower, 8 VT and 3 mafia goons) and Setup 4 (Town Tracker, Town Jailkeep, Town Follower, 7 VT, 2 Mafia Goons and 1 Mafia Roleblocker) since 1 Mafia goon is dead we can affirm that if we were in Setup 4 there would only be a Mafia Goon and Mafia roleblocker, Genisu followed Celever and found out that they did no action, since mafia cannot kill and roleblock at the same time, it would mean that if we were in Setup 4, Celever would have to given up on roleblocking if he were mafia, as the other mafia would need to kill. (The other mafia being mafia roleblocker works the same), So now we're in a moment where we can confirm if we are in Setup 3 or Setup 4 by allowing jailkeeper to Jailkeep Genisu this night, if he dies. We're in setup 3, and if he doesnt die, we're in setup 4. And by the light of this if we were in Setup 4, this would paint Celever better. As for to him not to make an action, mafia would have to give up on an action the day after they killed the Tracker. Which gives him towncred.
ngl I forgot that they could even choose, but my post above works the same
dumb it down for me more please.
In this post, you say "Celever (The Mafia Roleblocker and him not visiting)."
This means you are calling Celever the mafia roleblocker with certainty and also saying that he did not visit anyone. Am I correct or am I misunderstanding you?
Do you think this is an honest mistake or a scumslip?
GOD FORBID SOMEONE READS THE OP
well, not this OP, the signup thread OP, but you get the point
handy link for you all since apparently you need it
handy link for you all since apparently you need it