NOC Everchanging Mafia - Game thread - Day 5!

[des121]

des121 why aren’t you mafia?

Om confused by the question

 

[Evie]

the extra discussion day is really not worth our doc

except it doesn't. this is assuming we misvote, and on d5 we lose in the voting world while NVing gives us that extra discussion day

 

[Evie]

Om confused by the question

why do you think we shouldn’t vote you today

 

[des121]

why do you think we shouldn’t vote you today

Because if I was mafia this game I would have lied and not been active I have only been mafia last game but that's about it

 

[Peum]

Because if I was mafia this game I would have lied and not been active I have only been mafia last game but that's about it

this is a strong argument

 

[Evie]

okay i dont think des is mafia

 

[Dead by Daylight]

the extra discussion day is really not worth our doc

we aren't losing our doc, we are simply guaranteeing an extra day over hoping our doc gives us that extra day

 

[Celever]

14/4 to start
No vote today
13/4 - N1
11/4 - N2
9/4 - N3
7/4 - N4
5/4 - N5

Misvote today
12/4 - N1
10/4 - N2
8/4 - N3
6/4 - N4
4/4 - N5

This is assuming the worst case, where we misvote all 5 times, but that's not uncommon for Smogtown tbh

ye idk

I don't think this is different to other games (generally town/mafia splits are determined by either "can town get an extra day if they block kill with doc", or "given the kp in this game, what ratio will have the least impact on the days town have with expected misfires" (if you've designed with me you'll have heard me talk about this, mafia designing having maths in it is so sad x3)

and ye what Evie said. giving ourselves an extra day isn't useful if we're no voting to do it, because the purpose of extra days is to give us extra kills. we're effectively taking our max day potential from +1 with one doc save, to +1 with 2 doc saves. it's def a net loss yk

 

[Laurel]

We can always NV in a later cycle. Please stop discussing it today hngggg

 

[Blizihguh]

Om confused by the question

How do you feel about other players (eg LonelyNess, DBD)

 

[Blizihguh]

##Vote: Flandrs
Gonna go to bed now so I'm throwing out a vote incase deadline is in the next 8 hours and I just completely missed that somehow

Flandrs talk more pls

 

[Blizihguh]

Also des pls post more and everyone else, please don't just decide des is town from her making two posts lol

 

[Dead by Daylight]

##Vote: No Vote

giving ourselves an extra day isn't useful if we're no voting to do it, because the purpose of extra days is to give us extra kills.

having an extra day to discuss is also a major benefit which this completely ignores

 

[vishy fishy]

Wait how do you vote?

 

[AirC]

Yeah, this is why I put my vote on DBD - I’m heavily suspicious of anyone who agreed with me on when it is very clear that the generally agreed upon thing to do in a NOC is to never no vote.

Not really, at first I agreed with you and just didn't say it in thread, you made a reasonable it's not that hard to believe that people could agree with it

 

[des121]

How do you feel about other players (eg LonelyNess, DBD)

Idk but dbd and lonely are fine

 

[pulsar512b]

##VOTE: pulsar

she often puts a lot of effort into providing content that goes against the thread’s grain as scum bc it’s on paper towny to do that, and I think she misread the room on backing no vote counting as this so she went for it after discussion kinda progressed into the consensus view

ITS HAPPENED EVERYONE
SOMEONE'S READ ME TRYING AS SCUMMY

 

[pulsar512b]

BREAK OUT THE CHAMPAGNE FOR THIS GREAT THING THAT DEFINITELY DOESNT HAVE NEGATIVE REPERCUSSIONS ON THE QUALITY OF MY PLAY AS A WHOLE

 

[AirC]

Can anyone that's sayins a NV is good explain to me what happens after we NV and mafia doesn't kill?

 

[Celever]

ITS HAPPENED EVERYONE
SOMEONE'S READ ME TRYING AS SCUMMY

no it's about the specific content you chose to go with lol

continue trying, I often can read you as town when you try as town

 

[pulsar512b]

Can anyone that's sayins a NV is good explain to me what happens after we NV and mafia doesn't kill?

we have effectively 2 days of yapping to work from (or 3+ depending how long we wanna go with it)

 

[AirC]

Can anyone that's sayins a NV is good explain to me what happens after we NV and mafia doesn't kill?

Rewriting because I messed up words :
Can anyone saying that NV is a good thing explain to me after we NV and mafia doesn't kill?

 

[pulsar512b]

no it's about the specific content you chose to go with lol

continue trying, I often can read you as town when you try as town

yeah no this is literally me trying as town

 

[pulsar512b]

so

 

[AirC]

we have effectively 2 days of yapping to work from (or 3+ depending how long we wanna go with it)

Wtf do we have to yap about, vibes will only get us so far