Alright everyone, thanks for all the responses so far. I have a few things I'd like to comment on for now, but please do keep up this discussion.
StarmeiTheGod, i think keeping this more NU related for now is the best way to go. Although I do agree with you that every community on Smogon has similar problems, there are enough differences between each of them that the exact solution would be different. Going forward, I hope that we can set a positive example for how to deal with these kinds of issues.
I think
soulgazer really hit the nail on the head with his points. If we could just respect each other a bit more, we could return to the glory days of the BW2 NU.
I was asked earlier about what I want NU to be, so I figured that I should share my vision for NU, and a bit of a plan on how to get there.
To me, the most important thing in the NU community is mutual respect. Back in BW2, when the community was much smaller, the degree of respect between players was solid. There were conflicts and people who didn't like each other, but because we all loved NU and Pokemon, we were able to put aside those feelings and work together when the situation called for it. Nowadays, with the community growing so large, it has become more and more difficult for this kind of respect to remain, but I think that if we set our mind to it, its something we could bring back. So to all of you reading this that are involved in a conflict with someone else, try to put it aside and look ahead. Things here are a lot more fun when you aren't upset!
Something else that is important to me that we have failed at is being a welcoming place to new contributors. As
Can-Eh-Dian said, becoming a part of the "in" group on your first day is not realistic, when you're new to NU, you'll still be learning about what it is you like, and whether or not its the right place for you. But what we as a staff have failed at is helping to assist new people and make them feel welcome. Trust me, you are welcome here, if you ever feel lost, im sure a member of our staff will be willing ti help you.
Cause if they dont ill woop them So if any of you have had negative experiences with the NU staff before, please give us a second chance, we will do a better job now!
A big thing I want to focus on going forward is not who was right and who was wrong in getting us to this point, but instead accepting that things are not OK as they are now, and working together to find a solution, I don't want this to end up in a blame game. Some things were done poorly by NU staff members, myself included. But we are dedicated to making things in NU a positive experience for everyone involved. I think what
hollywood covered earlier shows a lot of the things we need to do better going forward to make the forums a better place, while I have my ideas about how to make the PS room a better place
- More active staff members
I don't mean that you can't idle in the room and have to be available 24/7, but having someone around who is willing to help is something we need. During peak hours it shouldnt be hard to find someone. Beyond having staff physically there, making sure that the same few people don't get burnt out is a priority as well, so hopefully with what was posted here, we can get our staff motivated to improve the room as well!
- Building rapport with room regulars
This is something else that we will have to do a better job of going forward, as including people who reached out to me privately, there are many people in the room that just feel like they don't fit in, whether its due to social struggles or anything else like that. Reaching out to people that want to be a part of the room, but arent quite ready to do it on their own, is something I will personally try to improve on going forward.
One of the things that people have commented positively on is our regular room tournaments, although the culture around them is still a work in progress, they will become more common in the future!
- Fostering competitive discussion
This isn't something that was touched on a whole lot in this thread, but a lot of the time its difficult to have good competitive discussion in the NU room. Now I don't expect it ti ever be like the IRC days in BW2, simply because our audience now is so much larger, but going forward we will try to focus more on making the room about the NU metagame, and less about our in-jokes. We will still have fun though! Fun is allowed.
Improving the PS room is a very important thing to me, and by hearing what many of you had to say, I think I have a better understanding of what our room culture is like.
This thread is still open for any ideas you guys have to improve NU, or anything you think we might have overlooked in regards to fixing the current situation. Just remember to try and stay positive and avoid placing blame!