-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Paranoia Mafia Game Over - Mafia Wins
- Thread starter Andy Snype
- Start date
- Status
I would like to point out how void the posts that Dentricos is making are, they literally say nothing / really obvious things while showing some sort of attempt to contribute. I would say this is scummy but this is kind of like he was in neighborhood too. So is that just the way he is? Also the Dentricos "slip" wasn't actually a slip, do you guys even mafia lol
Hawk was acting a little weird before but tbh he's back to normal hawkie now, I liked his contributions somewhat at first, but then his most recent posts have half-bw-former half-dumb shit, which isn't great.
I like some of Texas's contributions, but tbh I think he just made that really long post because people think long posts make them look town, which isn't necessarily true (lol); still slight townread, but not a ton
Former Hope was being really defensive but then he stopped, so I really don't think he should be the person who we lynch today, and he made his priorities (although dumb) clear. I like that.
Walrein is hard to read, as usual... slight town, gut read
Blazade is null, I'm frankly confused by his posts
Aubisio should be more active
I don't like Flyhn's read post on page 5 because
Josh is slight town, he needs to explain what he is doing more, especially why he is lynching someone
Betathunder null, contribute more you idling nerd
I'll also post my opinions on the votecount once Steven posts it!
Hawk was acting a little weird before but tbh he's back to normal hawkie now, I liked his contributions somewhat at first, but then his most recent posts have half-bw-former half-dumb shit, which isn't great.
I like some of Texas's contributions, but tbh I think he just made that really long post because people think long posts make them look town, which isn't necessarily true (lol); still slight townread, but not a ton
Former Hope was being really defensive but then he stopped, so I really don't think he should be the person who we lynch today, and he made his priorities (although dumb) clear. I like that.
Walrein is hard to read, as usual... slight town, gut read
Blazade is null, I'm frankly confused by his posts
Aubisio should be more active
I don't like Flyhn's read post on page 5 because
because setup spec is contributing, depending on what it is but it still is contributing. It's also better than null reads (cwl).Flyhn said:
Josh is slight town, he needs to explain what he is doing more, especially why he is lynching someone
Betathunder null, contribute more you idling nerd
I'll also post my opinions on the votecount once Steven posts it!
tbph i had no idea it was that long until i got on my laptop lol, it seemed like a p average post length from a mobile screen. though in fairness i also had a lot to respond to given the allegations against me from walrein and twin at the time
what is that reasoning lol?? thats really sketchy its like ur tryna get people off him/defend him without being obvious lol
is what is that reasoning lol a question
I liked how Former Hope is no longer being defensive and making his priorities clear? I feel like if a person were scum and no one pointed out to them if they were being defensive they would continue being defensive..
Idk what betathunder is smoking that interaction seemed TvT
Vote Betathunder
Walrein is probably the bad one considering Snype's post on balance but I'm nowhere near addressing that conflict now.
I think a Hawkie lynch is bad he seems genuine atm.
Texas I am literally just back from work, calm your nips. I'll write more in a little bit.
Vote Betathunder
Walrein is probably the bad one considering Snype's post on balance but I'm nowhere near addressing that conflict now.
I think a Hawkie lynch is bad he seems genuine atm.
Texas I am literally just back from work, calm your nips. I'll write more in a little bit.
wait what? if someone were being defensive and then stopped being defensive and no one in the thread told them they ere being defensive AND you believe that they would continue being defensive otherwise would that not scream scum to you as someone on their team told them they were being defensive in private?
Am I fucking crazy or is nobody else seeing how #149 is texas saying he doesn't want to tie himself to any potential mislynches in hawkie then throws a low responsibility vote on betathunder?
No you're just fucking crazy
Myself said:
At no point did I say I wouldn't tie myself to any mislynches, what I said was that I wouldn't come down hard on a vote I was only 60% confident about
As my post says, at the time I made it I thought there was reasonable doubt about scum-hawkie
At that point in time betathunder had made zero contributions. Voting him either: targets a scum idler, which is beneficial to town, or targets a town-idler which then motivates them to start contributing. At that point there was nothing suggesting that they wouldn't be mafia, whereas there was for hawkie
Honestly you just completely misunderstand the mindset in which I operate
Lolz I like how I'm scummy for thinking Hawkie's lynch on Aubisio was fine. Expecially for an early lynch where the purpose is to pressure people into contributing more insightful things.
As for reads I have not had a reason to think any players are more town than before. Everybody I pushed legit just OMGUSed so hard lel
Pancake townlean for saying things I agree with (someone said I slipped not knowing it was vanilla)
Josh scumlean for trying to set lynches but refusing to post reads,
Hawkie is saying things I agree with still
Flyhn scumlean for posting reads but staying out of conversation in general :/
Still learning what works :/ I honestly dont see why what I'm saying is being dismissed as lack of content when I've pushed for reads, posted reads, and talked about things that other people had wrong so everybody could get a clear picture...
As for reads I have not had a reason to think any players are more town than before. Everybody I pushed legit just OMGUSed so hard lel
Pancake townlean for saying things I agree with (someone said I slipped not knowing it was vanilla)
Josh scumlean for trying to set lynches but refusing to post reads,
Hawkie is saying things I agree with still
Flyhn scumlean for posting reads but staying out of conversation in general :/
Still learning what works :/ I honestly dont see why what I'm saying is being dismissed as lack of content when I've pushed for reads, posted reads, and talked about things that other people had wrong so everybody could get a clear picture...
And for the record that post happened well before all the stuff that went down today and right now I don't believe Hawkie is scum anyway
recently you have had a lot of posts like that one post where you just bandwagoned and the other post where you just said "lol" and so far you are just trying to get my activity up which tbh isn't really contributing either, I'd like some real contributions from you throughout the day instead of just stopping right after you have a vote on someone
I have no reads to post but I can post random content less gut reads like you and say I think most likely scum team is flyhn/dentricos/twin right now imo, with hawkie texas and aubisio as next most likely. My vote has not been taken off of of flyhn for a reason. Dentricos is acting exactly like the noob scum he was last game (when he turned out other be scum) and twin I just have a gut feeling, nothing substantial to say.
There are probably 3 terrorists btw. No way there'd be 4 when town is so weak and has no power roles, that'd be stupid, I suppose there could be 2 but 3 seems most likely
There are probably 3 terrorists btw. No way there'd be 4 when town is so weak and has no power roles, that'd be stupid, I suppose there could be 2 but 3 seems most likely
Flyhn is Flyhn, nothing ever changes for this guy
I'm willing to buy Josh's "Town is harder than scum" attitude but it doesn't ease my suspicion, only my investigation for now.
Texas actually seems to have gotten better, the defensiveness reads similar to when he was on the chopping block in neighborhood. I can see Twin being bullheaded here.
Everyone's giving me a reason to believe in them except the idlers, I'm calling All Village Trollfest.
pancake's opener is not impressive imo but he's busy so it's going to affect his image so eehhhhhh.
Aubisio's dropped off the face of the thread which would be alignment indicative if people weren't giving him shit for his behavior so idk.
rssp1 isn't having a specatular opening but I townread shubaka and he acted like this in DBZ (albeit with a few more useful posts)
I'd lynch in {Aubisio, Flyhn, Betathunder, pancake, rssp1} today
I'm willing to buy Josh's "Town is harder than scum" attitude but it doesn't ease my suspicion, only my investigation for now.
Texas actually seems to have gotten better, the defensiveness reads similar to when he was on the chopping block in neighborhood. I can see Twin being bullheaded here.
Everyone's giving me a reason to believe in them except the idlers, I'm calling All Village Trollfest.
pancake's opener is not impressive imo but he's busy so it's going to affect his image so eehhhhhh.
Aubisio's dropped off the face of the thread which would be alignment indicative if people weren't giving him shit for his behavior so idk.
rssp1 isn't having a specatular opening but I townread shubaka and he acted like this in DBZ (albeit with a few more useful posts)
I'd lynch in {Aubisio, Flyhn, Betathunder, pancake, rssp1} today
Thanks for reads. Explain noob scum thing please :)
- Status