NOC Paranoia Mafia Game Over - Mafia Wins

Status
Not open for further replies.
i'm not tunnelling i've scumread you since D1 and have presented reads on other people/took time to make sure i was sure of my read on you and not just for "one" of your posts but ALL of them.

so stop trying to downplay the situation as u have been since D1, it wont work forever
 
Hawkie said:
hi
Soz
back btw mobile

Texas Cloverleaf - I don't actually think he's scum? Texas has been a solid contributor from D1 onwards and hasn't been afraid to share even his more "outlandish" theories, while the flip yesterday DOES make him look bad, have any of you considered that Haruno was bw'd by scum to make him look bad??? Who was on haruno yday

Former Hope - omg why is he still alive LYNCH FORMER HOPE ever since D1 he's been weary of confrontation and being put in the spotlight and has at times reacted in really weird ways to reads being presented on him?? Also his filler posts like literally everywhere like remember "Aww rip Blazade :( ..." like actual bye

rssp1 - My 2nd scumread and i think him + Former could very well be the scumteam, his activity seems "forced", half of his posts are reads posts and the other half are promising reads posts, he does use good logic in his reads but rssp1 is a very convincing scum, idk though i think he'd be more active if he was scum but irl busy probably has a hand in it too. Still a strong scumread.

OM Room - idk man he subbed for Flyhn who didnt do very much and so far he just reeks of silly townie to me, although he's being very "nice" towards everyone which is a kinna scumtell for me but not enough to push on.

Walrein - ????? he could be either way tbh, he's been very involved this game with good posts and activity but with how it's went so far you can't help but wonder if scum are leading town

Aubisio - too stupid to read

Dentricos - i read him as town

Asek - he's just came into the game but he's been really good so far, i'll have to wait until there's more posts to analyse
Click to expand...
Walrein texas rssp1 dentricos was the votes for haruno and dentricos last minute broke the tie between texas and haruno which is why I believe its dentricos+texas
 
Dentricos said:
Lynch Haruno

Me protecting texas like this as scumbuddys would be 100% stupid... Im also multitasking with eso.

Sub imo I can't think for shit and this game has me so stumped. Though no sub until the start of next day I have one more contribution to make.
Click to expand...

what the actual fuck is this post that's just threw me

yeah i can definitely see Dentricos/Texas but i'm still set on Former Hope/rssp1
 
Hawkie's scumread on me makes little to no sense, esp given that he was scumreading me before my activity went up / I started posting useful things (imo). Unless he was scumreading me for low effort content before and is now scumreading me for... forced content? ok

Texas Cloverleaf said:
I think I figured out what Josh meant when he said "you guys are looking at this game all wrong"

One of rssp1, walrein, and twin are scum. A second might be scum. All three are definitely not scum.

Reason being: they are all almost universally townread.

Here's the rub in the game's mechanics: scum have no motivation to do anything other than act like a perfect town. They don't need to keep each other alive. They don't need to create misdirection. They don't need to lead mislynches. The only thing they need to do to win is to avoid suspicion being on them. Once the game hits a certain number of people remaining as long as any scum is alive they win. Guaranteed at least one of them is the sheep in wolf's clothing, possibly two, while the last scum takes on a more active, dissident voice.

Unvote Lynch rssp1
Click to expand...

Walrein's nowhere near close to being universally townread
What you stated is also how literally every other mafia game works, the only difference here is that we can vote to end the game early. The "too townie" argument is terrible and it rarely ever works (and if you are calling me/twin too townie then I highly doubt it works in this case either).
Who is the active, dissident voice in this case?
 
No I don't believe it is considering that in other games the town has information gathering roles among others and the mafia has to work to make sure they're misdirecting effectively. In this game that's not the case and if you are above suspicion you will never be lynched because there's always someone more suspicious to push the lynch onto. I can't say I have a specific bead on a dissident voice but my gutshot would be Former Hope.

Walrein may not be universally town read at this specific point in time, but he is currently mostly town read and was universally town read up until halfway through d2
 
If you're scum playing like perfect town the information roles wont incriminate you because they wont target you? The only role that would incriminate you is something like watcher, which wouldnt be related to how you're playing in the day.
The point about Walrein is fair but I don't think it's due to him acting as a "perfect town" but more due to him seeming townie in his contributions/defense after being suspected, which is different for the reasons myself and twin are being townread.
 
twin's overall posting style/contributions have been good, although his tunneling on you lately has been kinda bad.
would like to hear from twin about who he thinks scum are should texas be lynched and flip town
 
Texas Cloverleaf said:
I think I figured out what Josh meant when he said "you guys are looking at this game all wrong"

One of rssp1, walrein, and twin are scum. A second might be scum. All three are definitely not scum.

Reason being: they are all almost universally townread.

Here's the rub in the game's mechanics: scum have no motivation to do anything other than act like a perfect town. They don't need to keep each other alive. They don't need to create misdirection. They don't need to lead mislynches. The only thing they need to do to win is to avoid suspicion being on them. Once the game hits a certain number of people remaining as long as any scum is alive they win. Guaranteed at least one of them is the sheep in wolf's clothing, possibly two, while the last scum takes on a more active, dissident voice.

Unvote Lynch rssp1
Click to expand...
How is this a real fucking post lmfao just look at how many times this guy has flipped his views today.
 
Oh for fuck's sake take your head out of your ass

I'm really fucking tired of you shitting all over everything I say based on absolutely nothing like this is the same shit from your "iso" on me

Not everyone thinks the way that you do, not everyone posts the way that you do, not everyone plays mafia the way that you do and the people that play differently from you aren't always scum. Get a fucking clue

No wonder you're winless in NOC
 
I'm soooooo fucking sorry that when I think about stuff and come to a new opinion I post it even if it's different from what I thought before I was thinking about stuff fucking honestly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top