• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

NOC Paranoia Mafia Game Over - Mafia Wins

Status
Not open for further replies.
oh
unless you read d3 early tomorrow you're gonna run out of time, dl is tomorrow and there isnt really any strong agreement on who to lynch. Your thoughts on that would be appreciated.
 
rssp1 said:
oh
unless you read d3 early tomorrow you're gonna run out of time, dl is tomorrow and there isnt really any strong agreement on who to lynch. Your thoughts on that would be appreciated.
Click to expand...

Alright, I can do that.

Without having seen Day 3, I don't want to lynch thetwinmasters, Tex, OM room, or myself. I can provide defenses for all of them if needed.

You haven't impressed me with your content but you've made a point of interacting with me which I approve of. Wagonomics looks poor for you but that isn't the end of the world. I'd be willing to lynch you, but I would do it begrudgingly.

That leaves Flyhn's replacement, Aubisio, Hawkie, and Former Hope.

At least a 25% chance of hitting scum if you shot in there randomly in my opinion.
 
defense for om room please
do you mean each of those four individually has a 25% chance of hitting scum?
i'd read d3 since that would change your opinions on flyhn's replacement (asek) and hawkie imo
 
rssp1 said:
defense for om room please
do you mean each of those four individually has a 25% chance of hitting scum?
i'd read d3 since that would change your opinions on flyhn's replacement (asek) and hawkie imo
Click to expand...

Defense for OM room is simple. I think they were fine overall and I'll trust Josh's opinions on the matter since he was so adamant.

This way if I'm wrong I can blame him, see?

I'll take your word for it that Hawkie and Asek look good from Day 3.

That leaves FH and Aubisio, both of which I would've voted at various points throughout Day 1 and Day 2.

Solid PoE.
 
By "fine overall", what do you mean?
I thought his posts were on the same level of Aubisio in terms of noncontent and had a hard time distinguishing the two based on how helpful/useful they were.
 
Asek said:
DO NOT WORRY THE SAVIOR OF SMOGON NOC IS HERE

the texas chains of iso seemed like more of a scum than town action to me. It looks like contributions but it generally deflects away from the user doing them.... but the reaction to josh pointing out something similar looked like how texas responded as a townie in the last game. But having only played one game with him, I'm sure he would pick up on this and try use it as a townie points if he was scum...not opposed to the lynch if thats the direction it takes.

Twins an odd one to read right now but that is indicative of the fact that he is generally a hard player to read. seems to be playing a fair bit softer than his usual game though? could be something to note....

Former hope vs hawkie interaction felt like a TvS to me, and along with some other posts / votes by him I'm leaning a fair bit towards former hope being scum and hawkie being clean, but i feel like a flip on one would reveal a fair bit about the other.

I generally dont like using the logic of 'hosts will have balanced the game this way so this person is scum' but I'm going to do it shamelessly anyway and say that since blazade flipped town im inclined to believe walrein is scum. Its not like there havent been things in is postings have bothered me as well, but the scumbag tactic i stated above puts some more 'oomph' behind this read for me. i will iso if i must point things out, but i generally dont believe iso adds too much to a format like this.

My stab at solving this game: 1 or 2 of the above people ive mentioned is scum and then one of either aubisio/ OM room / one of those lurking noobies is scum with them. I feel like a scum is lurking in the noobies / lurkers.

with that being said lets put some pressure on those lurkers
LYNCH AUBISIO

START TALKING

AMA
Click to expand...

Will you marry me?
 
welp it looks like this isnt going to be active until tomorrow
i'm gone until a couple hours before deadline if i'm lucky, maybe right before deadline.
I think OM Room is probably scum, with FH/Aubisio as other possibilities.
If anyone else has any other ideas, it'd be nice to hear them.
 
hey y'all I'm working 5 days in a row public holiday rates in a tourist town for massive bank so my activity's gonne be kind of shite for the next few days

walrein poaching someone i assume he knows from another forum pretty much locks that dude in for town. as much as i hate using a sub to clear someone theres no way in my mind that Scum!Walrein would go to this much effort to find a good sub. Borath the Oscillator : casa micasa baby

I really dunno what to think about OM room considering theres such a lack of anything to think about lol. I think at least one of them or aubisio is scum but what have I got to work with to judge either on them really other than the fact that they are idling and generally just shitposting when they actually do decide to check the thread lol

I'm going to lay out the game as it is for me right now (THIS DAY)

Town circle : Borath, Texas, Hawkie
Dunno: Rssp1, Twin
Lynch targets: Aubisio, Former Hope, OM Room.

I think I'm missing a player from that list but I can't pin down who it is off the top of my head and i dont wanna check the OP

If I need to lay down more thoughts on why I'm saying this stuff I can, but I've put a lot of my thoughts into yesterday about what I thought if Dentricos flipped town and none of thats really changed

Quote or highlight me for questions and I'll answer, but uni and work are bitches so dont expect immediate replys.

my votes not moving for now btw and i havent forgotten about it
 
I'm on mobile so won't be checking the thread v much until I get home
I'm honestly fine with a lynch on former/om/Aubisio but I'm not sure who I prefer. If this is the last day before game end it's probably better to stack our votes on one person instead of spreading them out over everyone we find scummy
This may not be the last day though so I'm not sure if that's important
 
Not sure what else there is to say at this point outside of reiterating the stances already established. Unless Aubisio starts posting or Former Hope makes a convincing defense one of them is likely getting lynched and their flip is the next catalyst for discussion. I know on my end I have my clear beliefs on where the scum lie and have laid out as much in my past posts and that generally seems to hold true for most of the rest of us. Except twin who never actually posts any content beyond votes and saying "wtf is this post even."

If I had to solve today my best bet would be Former Hope / Twin / Aubisio. Former I'm confident is scum, twin could be rssp, and aubisio could be om room, but I'm confident that myself, asek, hawkie, and Borath are all strong towns. Speaking of Hawkie it would be lovely if you'd drop in some input today and more lovely if it included other ideas in addition to your Former scum belief.

Also your work isn't being wasted Borath the Oscillator, I'm very much taking note of the thought processes you're using so I can try and incorporate them and use them in future games where I'm town. Don't know if it's worth the effort to you to go through d3 too but the effort posts are valued.
 
hijustgothome

At this point i townread Texas(stated previously), Borath the Oscillator(putting this much effort into the game as a sub, i previously townread walrein), Asek(pmuch the same thing)

null/???: twin(as far as i'm aware it's not his meta to tunnel someone haaard as fuck but whenbut you have a scumread its a scumread so this wouldn't bother me that much except other than basically belittling people's posts all the time and giving reads every once in a while he hasn't done much else, idk if he got the tunnel thing from how i played d1 but whether that's true or not it just makes me feel like there's some dishonesty in how he is playing),
rssp1(how he's playing feels weird to me, i keep jumping from trusting him to doubting him. As previously stated I feel his Dentricos push was town, as if he was desperate for his scumread to get lynched so he could have some credibility/do something for town, he's tried to generate useful discussion and gives opinions and new information where he can, but rssp1 plays a good scum game, im not 100% on him yet so he's not in my townpile)
OM Room: POST MORE. His initial attitude after subbing was off to me and looking back i should've tried to push on it(although afaik others have tried to encourage him to post but he hasn't), it wouldn't surprise me if he was scum, but it also wouldn't surprise me if he was town. so idk basically

scum reads: Former Hope(read my posts), Aubisio(i haven't felt good about him ever since D1, but he's acted like a complete and utter idiot this game and i honestly wish he hadn't joined. i can like 10% see him being retarded enough to flip town so i'd prefer lynching fh)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top