• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

NOC Paranoia Mafia Game Over - Mafia Wins

Status
Not open for further replies.
honestly i think gale is a town tryhard who's read something he personally found off and capitalised on it and wont let go in an effort to lynch his scumread i mean read what actually happened not his take on it do you see that as a scum slip? Make your own informed decision about it and dont just consider his telling of the story. i have nothing else to say we dont habe time for this bullshit

i dont scumread twin because of his reluctance to hop on this bandwagon of which i know is a townie lynch(me), im willing to discuss asek but idk who im lynching yet
 
Gale Wing Srock said:
And this is really REALLY interesting!

This tells you, that he believes that you don't see him as scum, and neither does anyone else. And knows that people will not vote for him.

Can you imagine a townie thinking this way when we are 8 down and probably have to find three scums in a row to win the game?
Click to expand...
He's just stating a fact here, in that everyone left in the game (at that time) was townreading him, or fairly convinced that he was town. I don't think it was overconfidence or anything.

Gale Wing Srock said:
You think me and Texas are town?

Unlynch
Lynch Hawkie

There is no way you can be certain I am town.
Click to expand...
This is the same issue that you were pushing me for when I thought Texas/twin was a tvt, he's townreading both of you.

Gale Wing Srock said:
Hawkie is scum dude ^

Someone who finds it difficult to scum hunt, is confident that he is being town read, says he will get into the mindset of town and forget he is scum. Then gets upset when you and me Scum read him
Click to expand...
are there people who dont get upset when they are scumread?

Gale Wing Srock said:
I had him under town too, until today.

It definitely surprised me too, to see him play that way. But that is the way it is.

If we are so bad in position is because the scums are good in what they are doing. And if we find slips from them, that make sense, we have to bond together.

There is no way Hawkie cannot be scum this game, he has shown so many signs of caught scum.

Tell me if you are boasting as town, will you change to apologizing as town if two people start suspecting you?

He cannot even guarantee that I am town yo!
Click to expand...
tbh this is a fine point but I still do think it's kind of weak. Having one kinda bad day doesnt really offset his super townie behavior from the previous days for me.

Gale Wing Srock said:
Dude, this is clear scum behavior!

Don't judge me by my slip? Do you remember Dentricos from Neighborhood Mafia?
Click to expand...
Those are two different things of widely different magnitudes, regardless of whether you read his actions as slips or not its not something thats an undeniable slip like calling a chat your scum chat.

A question for you gale: If hawkie is scum, who would his scumpartner(s) be?
 
rssp1 said:
He's just stating a fact here, in that everyone left in the game (at that time) was townreading him, or fairly convinced that he was town. I don't think it was overconfidence or anything.


This is the same issue that you were pushing me for when I thought Texas/twin was a tvt, he's townreading both of you.


are there people who dont get upset when they are scumread?


tbh this is a fine point but I still do think it's kind of weak. Having one kinda bad day doesnt really offset his super townie behavior from the previous days for me.


Those are two different things of widely different magnitudes, regardless of whether you read his actions as slips or not its not something thats an undeniable slip like calling a chat your scum chat.

A question for you gale: If hawkie is scum, who would his scumpartner(s) be?
Click to expand...
Rssp1, the game now is to lynch Asek. We can get to this tomorrow. I promise to respond to this tomorrow okay?

Tell me what you think of Asek.
 
ok
I'm not sure what to make of Asek. When he subbed in he had a lot of quality posts and was bringing good insight to the table + Flyhn's play felt townie to me originally. However, with him being busy lately his post quantity and quality has declined a lot. The arguments he brought up against me were really bad / arbitrary which I really didn't like, but i'm super wary of pushing people for that reason after that caused the Dentricos mislynch.
 
Texas could be scum, thinking about it the push off of Aubisio was used to go on FH but I still dont see why scum!texas would defend aubisio at all
I really don't think gale is scum
borath is mia he was here like an hour ago but hes gone now
 
gale ngl I think there are two scum left because I have a seriously hard time finding 3 people of those remaining who could be scum
I can see arguments for asek/twin/texas/borath but they get weaker as I progress down that list (asek first, borath last)
 
i think gales push on me was town it reminded me of my aubisio push or rssp1s dentricos push at both these three points we were desperate to find scum we capitalised on something we'd usually reconsider

town: rssp1, twin, gale, borath?

? : texas(his eagerness to reconsider me is worrying when he is under pressure from twins tunnel could've seen it as a way out but didn't want to commit fully in case the lynch fell through which it did) asek(post plZ)
 
my main argument for twin being town is that he tried to spur activity when the game was dead, with a side argument of him tunneling texas being a weird thing for scum to do
The second one is incredibly weak as a townread and the first one is a read on the level of my townread for texas (him defending aubisio)
so i would be ok with a twin lynch although I dont know if its the right one
 
rssp1 said:
my main argument for twin being town is that he tried to spur activity when the game was dead, with a side argument of him tunneling texas being a weird thing for scum to do
The second one is incredibly weak as a townread and the first one is a read on the level of my townread for texas (him defending aubisio)
so i would be ok with a twin lynch although I dont know if its the right one
Click to expand...
so you think I'm more town or scum then
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top