NOC Why is there a gun in my popcorn? GAME OVER SCUM WIN

Status
Not open for further replies.
pancake said:
my only nitpick with Flyhn is that he has previously (not in the last post) implied that low activity = scummy. This is generally not the case; the only type of idling that is scummy is when if the person posts, said posts have little to no valuable content, i.e. it looks like they tried to post reads, but the reads do not mean anything. This is both my premise for why I am not a good shot due to Flyhn's reasoning; while yes, both ended up being scum, josh doesn't know that lol, etc. I shouldn't have to point this out, but also the reasoning for my preferred shot of Former Hope; King_ would also be a fine shot that I would agree with due to similar reasoning to twin, I tried to read king's reads but they simply say nothing + some I can't read lol, and also I agree with Flyhn regarding moody, but to a lesser extent than I would like a former hope or king shot.

my initial scum team - 3/5

former hope
king_
moodycloud

my initial town core - 6 / 9

twin
me + jalmont lol
aura guardian
hitmonleet
flyhn

I also find Asek likely to be town, extremely meta read but I find this extremely chill / not caring style of playing is very typical for town asek, where I don't even know if I've seen mafia asek lol but town asek is like this. Additionally, I find Yeti likely to be town because her contributions honestly seem very natural and not forced, and I feel like she's going against what's typically expected by for example, scumreading sam and implying that flyhn has a decent chance of being scum, where a typical scum would just do what is expected of them in order to lessen that type of suspicious.

... which leaves the following players: UncleSam, Walrein, Blazade, two scum one town.

I find these four players the hardest to read, perhaps because I consider them among the better of the players in the game, perhaps because they're all idling fucks, besides walrein kinda. I find Blazade the most likely town out of them but that's kinda just a gut read w/e post more please, especially US and blazade.
Click to expand...
Are you saying wd and shubaka's posts weren't scummy idling according to your definition.
 
Thetwinmasters said:
Are you saying wd and shubaka's posts weren't scummy idling according to your definition.
Click to expand...

I honestly did not see them post more than like twice and I read the entire thing, so I did some research and my thought was correct about shubaka but not about wd, and yes I believe that wd's actions are scummy idling, but not shubaka's because shubaka posted like twice and they were like "yes" lol, clearly he was not focused on the game/that's what I would have thought if I were alive.
 
pancake said:
as for ag, i like his confidence in his reads and how he is pretty consistent, him referencing his previous posts in more recent ones shows this.
Click to expand...

I did indeed have reasoning, unless you are implying that this reasoning is invalid, which is (although subjectively) not true. see posts like 927 for town ag
 
Thetwinmasters said:
King_ is scum because he is doing the exact same shit in dbz and deathnote noc to a fucking tee. Post a reads list with extremely shallow reasoning on everybody. Then in his extremely shallow reasoning reads list put a scum teammate in one of most scum read which I think is sam rn so when they flip scum he looks better. Then when pressure gets put on him deflect to another scum read in his shallow reads list that ends up being town.
Click to expand...
I join game for 1 day, gets called scum by twin reason being "other games", you still haven't elaborated on why and you haven't answered most of my questions.
 
can we shoot king AND twin

i don't know if either is mafia and i don't particularly care, i just want them both to shut the fuck up and quit clogging the thread
 
Okay, I just did a quick mental ISO. Summary of King_: Overly defensive and confrontational, yet deflective. A lot of ways to say very little.

Unvote. Vote King_

I figure King_ is 2/3 likely, the remaining 1/3 is Twin. Almost can't possibly be both.
 
Hitmonleet said:
  1. Former Hope (Must I explain this?)
  2. Twin (His posts just don't feel towny, they're all over the place, and just wierd.)
  3. Unknown. Maybe AG? I really don't know who I'd shoot afterwards.
Click to expand...
I kind of dislike this post, at this point in time you should have more than 2 scum reads, or at least a better picture of where to go next, if you're town.

Hitmonleet what are your reads at this moment and why, what would make you posit scumteams based on FH and Twin flipping either town or mafia?
 
pancake said:
LOL so basically what you are saying is wow, pancake agrees with his sub, that means that scum is pushing me. even though you don't say I'm scum, you imply it. that is a large pile of bullshit.

in what way is me agreeing with josh "fit with a narrative that scum wants to push for you to be shot?" not only does that make no sense (it's baseless reasoning-wise) but it is also extremely, extremely vague. it's like saying oh I'm town scum wants me dead, lol.

vote to shoot Former Hope

Class is about to start but I elaborate more later.
Click to expand...
agree with this post too about fh, it was a really weird post for fh to have made. the logic in it is just ... ?

dramatic changes between subber and subbee are usually more indicative something is amiss than both parties agreeing on a read or continuing to push something. at the very least i see no reason for the joshcake slot to take pressure off FH.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top