NOC Animal Mafia ~Game Over~

Status
Not open for further replies.
Aubisio: no clue
Thetwinmasters: dead villager
Haruno: probably mafia
Earlio: i think he's more likely village than not but definite possibility of being mafia
DurzaOffTopic --> proph: could be mafia
Jalmont: xD
Whydon: if u take his claim then village
3P1K: i think he's town
Blazade --> FH: if u believe the claim village? claim is sketch af though/. at this point i want to hear ap confirm he was redirected (or jordan...)
Mithril --> texas: probably town given that watch claim
XnadrojX: probably mafia
Asek: dead villager
MoodyCloud: i read as town but could be mafia
Hawkie --> leet: prob town but then disappeared. maybe mafia? null i think
KnightsofCydonia: probably town
apricity: probably mafia at this point?
Thunder~BALLZ: probably town

so the mafia is aubisio, haruno, apricity, and then like proph??? idk there's a lot of good town posting i see that might just be scum. idk hard to say.
 
OK, finally finished my homework.

Catching up now, should be available throughout the night, but my goal is to fully catch up in the next 2-3 hours and provide initial reads on all players to be refined tomorrow morning.
 
Jalmont said:
Aubisio: no clue
Thetwinmasters: dead villager
Haruno: probably mafia
Earlio: i think he's more likely village than not but definite possibility of being mafia
DurzaOffTopic --> proph: could be mafia
Jalmont: xD
Whydon: if u take his claim then village
3P1K: i think he's town
Blazade --> FH: if u believe the claim village? claim is sketch af though/. at this point i want to hear ap confirm he was redirected (or jordan...)
Mithril --> texas: probably town given that watch claim
XnadrojX: probably mafia
Asek: dead villager
MoodyCloud: i read as town but could be mafia
Hawkie --> leet: prob town but then disappeared. maybe mafia? null i think
KnightsofCydonia: probably town
apricity: probably mafia at this point?
Thunder~BALLZ: probably town

so the mafia is aubisio, haruno, apricity, and then like proph??? idk there's a lot of good town posting i see that might just be scum. idk hard to say.
Click to expand...
Okay thanks, can you elaborate on your read on apricity ?
 
Deadline is 2:30 tomorrow eh

Agreeing with pretty much everything Jalmont said this page except for scum!apricity

Happy to sit on a Jordan Lynch but I don't see many world's where haruno isn't a guarantee of a scum flip given the lack of my death last night
 
The timing of Whydon's claim and the fact that they haven't posted today are weird but I guess the most likely scenario here is that one of Haruno/Knights is maf (heavily leaning towards haruno) and Texas/Whydon are town, not sure we should lynch Haruno today though, if Whydon dies at night we get 100% confirmation that he's legit, if he doesn't there's a chance he gets more results so it seems like it can wait for d4 ?
 
If we assume the persuade exists then it follows that it's definitively scum aligned which should pseudo-clear whydon and aubisio given the other claims (2 shot track, 2 shot redirect)

But for some reason I'm kind of inclined to think it's scum! aubisio who just faked the persuade. Persuade just doesn't fit the setup given the known and implied PRs
 
The timing of Whydon's claim isn't weird at all, this is exactly the time you wait for as town before revealing info that can lead to a guilty, let scum walk into their own traps
 
I mean, there's also nothing right now that says haruno/knights can't be both town or both scum so I think it's interesting you auto came to that thought moody...
 
I mean, it's an inference based on the lack of the kill and it's not unreasonable. But it's also not unreasonable that it has nothing to do with the kill. It's sort of a WIFOM 50/50 thats resolved through the 2 players role claims (if haruno is active enough to do one....)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top