OK so I'm feeling fairly caught up
Don't think I have much time to do a super duper comprehensive reads breakdown but I can give my one sentence thoughts on each?
TOWN
Prophylaxis
LEANING TOWN
Paperblade - he's been popping in with thoughts but most of these thoughts I've agreed with, and people have meta softcleared him. If we miss then I'll take another look/reread but have liked his presence thus far
Knights - reminds me more of his town game, has some townie phrasing used in his words. Honestly, this might be a townread I need to re-evaluate because OUTSIDE of that I haven't remembered much of what he has done, but I feel fairly confident reading Knights so this is a read that you will see me update
Josh - lots of townie frustration/genuine emotional reactions for me. if he's good at faking this, then well done, but i haven't met too many scum good at faking stuff like this. I think I did a good rundown of his mindset as scum last night
LightWolf - like his engagement/willingness to work with metal sonic and his reads list, doesn't feel as manufactured/fake like it did in the last game I played with him
Empoof - solving, has good thoughts
Metal Sonic - his persona seems really difficult to fake if he's scum and multiple people have backed this up. plus, again, like his engagement with lightwolf and his tunneling on josh (I mean, I think Josh is town, but hardtunneling someone like that seems kind of untenable if you are actually scum)
Asek - liked his posts while he's been around but 875 is a thing and I need to look at it again
-----
NEUTRAL
Yeti - now, I haven't gone much into Yeti when I was reading, and I think she pointed this out. my reasoning here is because, she hasn't really done much that was noteworthy? someone characterized her play as like "offering up comments/thoughts on things from a neutral standpoint" and I think I agree with them. she went blobposting for the first half of day 1 and the second half.. she's been around, but I can't really recall what strong pushes she has made etc. Will need to ask her some questions to figure her out
Moody <- TTM - hasn't really posted much, people said that TTM was in his scum meta but I don't have that type of experience to make that judgement call
Walrein - similar boat to Yeti IMO where he's been offering thoughts but not been super duper townie. hasn't made much impact on the game IMO
FH - hasn't been around though I'm in the same game as him so yeah
-----
LEANING SCUM
Da Letter El - made a bunch of dropin posts that felt.. pretty alien to thread behavior at large in the early game, then said that he'd kick it into high gear and then made a pretty bad reads list. then he votes walrein which seems like a pretty weak vote. then he says he doesn't have enthusiasm for mafia which... sure I guess, but that doesn't really excuse your play thus far.
so yeah, I feel pretty caught up in this game, feels good for day 1
will try to be on more at eod but will focus on [ongoing game] now
