NOC D6 Mafia Game Thread [Day 4; Deadline June 1 at 6 PM EST]

Status
Not open for further replies.

im probably like here (with no real in depth thought given)
176361
 
Interesting wagon on Clarinet building. Certainly getting some strange vibes based on the way they're posting. Specifically it's hard to tell if these random thoughts they seem to be posting are fabricated. Bordering between neutral and scumlean for the time being (neutral on the list).


So you scumread bluedoom based on inactivity yet have Zest as neutral? Also if you scum read bluedoom then why haven't you voted for them?
ZoL is always MIA but bluedoom disappears as scum
 
m/f on Clarinet lynch
Haven’t played with them before but I sorta liked what they were putting out
Then I realized it was a lot of filler
I could get behind more pressure on them but I like having my vote on mewtwo
 
Ahahahhaha, I must have triggered a scum? I sure hope so, XnadrojX is my guess

as for engaging you, Athena, I'm not sure what you want.

I've observed your back and forth with DS. and it felt wasteful, that's when you were demoted to a lower position and I could no longer trust you.
Keep in mind, that I'm unfamiliar with all of you, I only heard of .DS while browsing a different site
Okay this has tipped me over the edge. Bad reaction to being voted and making excuses immediately afterwards. Certainly worth a scumlean for now.
Unvote: Samoyd
Vote: Clarinet

could be ebil: Athena/Hannahh/XnadrojX
Could you please elaborate on these reads/leans? Why are these three players in particular more likely to be evil than your nulls?
 
Think I've explained why Athena, Hannahh has posted but I'm not getting solid stances and XnadroX feels sly with every post
Your reason for Hannahh was that she seemed to be posting fluff mainly.
I've observed your back and forth with DS. and it felt wasteful, that's when you were demoted to a lower position and I could no longer trust you.
You have DS in Town despite being in the same "wasteful back and forth". Please explain what differentiates DS and Athena in detail.
Also please explain what makes you feel that Nadroj's posts are sly.
 
Actually I lied couldn't stop myself from reading the game after.

Town block:Duskfall,Athena(both are more game solvey,checks out with their meta),Samoyed(lesser town read, he's not as lurky and more aggressive so probably town here?)

DS feels like mafia to me just off of thread flow, he only posts when prodded by other players and he spent a lot of his posts on setup spec instead of sussing out some people and following his leads. If you think athena is sus,why haven't you pursued any line of questioning or dialogue with him regarding his alignment?
vote:DS

Felt like it was scum!jordan based on his opening where he supported the mewtwo wagon which felt like going with the consensus read to blend in. XnadrojX who reads as mafia to you right now and why?

apricity what about jordan's posts indicate him as town? Mostly cool with your reads except for #238, if you think mewtwo's recent reaction is mostly town,what home did he dig himself into that needs him to flip?

https://www.smogon.com/forums/threa...dline-may-23-at-6-pm-est.3650484/post-8135212

for reference


I can see scum!m2h based on his opening being all over the place and lacking conviction but I'm feeling unsure about it because he has had a stagnant wagon for a day,so the votals may suggest otherwise.
 
Your reason for Hannahh was that she seemed to be posting fluff mainly.

You have DS in Town despite being in the same "wasteful back and forth". Please explain what differentiates DS and Athena in detail.
Also please explain what makes you feel that Nadroj's posts are sly.

so it appears for Hannahh

DS. made it easier for all to understand his position whereas Athena seemed to be nitpicking and wasting time with this argument. I guess Athena felt more rambling and I wasn't fond of that.

XnadrojX had a recent pop-in that felt sly to me, because he's not sure about my alignment, but then he quickly chooses to vote me, seeing how Athena started a wagon. I want for him to expand more on his reads, why so much town certainty for Hannahh after she posted once or twice
 
okay so now that bluedoom is here if he can keep this up I’m good with him
if he disappears again he might still be scum
I do disagree with finding DS scummy though. You can find reasoning why he’s town in my very first post this game
 
Waiting for Athena, I feel like her vote is based on my comment, finding her suspicious, I also feel like XnadrojX voted me because I haven't been impressed by him. Those votes came AFTER my negative impression of them so they feel a bit unnatural. I can understand Caffeine's erratic emotion but other votes have a seed of omgusiness about them. Don't think they're both scum
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top