NOC D6 Mafia Game Thread [Day 4; Deadline June 1 at 6 PM EST]

Status
Not open for further replies.
I could say the same thing about your read on me tbh.

The difference is that you are not one of the concencus lynches, and I am also not pushing for you to be lynched right now. Another difference is I've mentioned concrete things that you can defend such as your athena read and the game spec thing.

I do think you should be watched carefully tomorrow especially if I am the lynch today. I think atp me being in the game might serve as a cover to you or DF if you are scum because I feel that both of you have been able to coast through the day to some extent.
 
I am honestly confused by you because you have a fairly towny tone most of the time but your reaction to Jordan and Athena was kinda bad.

You still haven't explained why you think Athena was wasteful in the back and forth with DS.

Agree with the first part. Another post later on that I forgot to quote said something like "immature town" but tbh Clarinet's tone changed drastically (at least in my eyes) between yesterday and today? Does anyone else see how drastically different his posts yesterday were, compared to the posts early this morning (Idk like 8 hours or so I guess). It makes him REALLY hard to read, but also he is coming in with barely any meta whereas most of us have at least one game together. (Except Athena who is also going off barely any meta which is why i'm not going to give Clarinet a free pass for being jumpy with his reads / outbursts)


Feeling zol is getting subbed out, he hasnt done anything he is hard null for me

wtf Zol is in this game? I want to say on ps I don't remember him ever hard lurking as town but it's been years so I'm not confident in this. Jordan might be better to answer this.


View attachment 176512
samo and whydon go in neutral tbh.


not familiar with hal's scum game yet but he seems pretty similar to the other games I've played with him and he's been town. I think saying I'm town lean overall and proceeding to continue tunneling me all day is kind of lol tier and maybe a reason not to put his as a full town read but that's the sort of thing I expect from town!hal at this point.

hannah comes off tonally very pure in the posts that she has made and I don't want to say she's obvtown because she's been a little less active that I would like to say that but I think she's the towniest person in the room if I had to make a bet.

jordan comes off very different from how he played as mafia in role madness and eimm. Maybe those two consecutive losses made him reconsider his playstyle, but I don't think that this is scum!jordan atp. I think the clarinet vote is probably a natural progression from what he was posting about before, and doesn't seem to be preplanned or forced.

Athena feels pretty good here. She had a fairly good start and maintained that image in my mind I think.

Caffeine also feels pretty good. I angleshot him reading small street which makes me feel like he was genuinely trying to solve my slot. Ig its also possible that he is after town cred for opposing my lynch but I think that possibility is pretty small tbh.

whydon, zestoflife are null for now. hopefully zest's sub will be easier to read.

DF feels towny for the most part but I think his judgement is clouded on jordan/hannah. Tbh I just have a bad gut feeling about this slot. He tunneled me, unvoted me and kinda set up himself up to not be too suspected if/when I flip, and I think his current srs (me/jordan/hannah) are odd and only make sense if you think scum!me is going to be wide open about who his teammates are which is possible ig but not really when im the main lynch. I don't really want to give my validation to this slot but I also don't want to necessarily say to go after him bc tunneling is in his meta.
Samo vote and unvote was kind of strange ngl.

More aggressive samo could be either a scum playstyle change like I said was possible in the case of jordan or it could just be his town meta.

DS I don't like to make judgements about this slot just bc he's usually scummy even as town. I think he comes off a little self-conscious about his posting habits with his original vote on me and his current vote on athena feeling like a reaction to that. I think immediately going to setup spec rather than reads in that little convo is kind of an lol moment. ngl I don't like the Athena read and I think athena's entrance was pretty okay but maybe I'm giving her too much credit. This is a slot I wouldn't want to lynch necessarily, but I think I'd suggest paying a little more attention to it.

BD tbh I like most of his content but I don't like his tone, he still comes off lurky in the way that he did in eimm and his long post today sounds like the early stuff he posted in eimm. I think trying to argue that my lynch is neccesary rather than arguing why I am scummy is bad and, like clarinet, comes off as not owning your reads.

I've said p much everything I want to say about Clarinet. Basically he has a fairly towny and pure tone but his actions don't make much sense from a town mindset as he's omgus'd me, jordan, and athena to some extent, he has qualified most of his reads (with the exception of jordan i think?) with statements that don't give him ownership over his reads.

atp my tentative solve for the game is either samo/clarinet/df or ds/df, clarinet, and bd tbh.

I like this post, and I know people called you out for mostly meta / gut reads but wtf else do you really have to go off of d1? No associated flips, not a ton of content. I stand by thinking you're town, and I think it'll become much clearer later in the game that you're town.

By the way did I like, miss all of BD's content? I only remember seeing him say he just woke up and then leaving again??
 
The difference is that you are not one of the concencus lynches, and I am also not pushing for you to be lynched right now. Another difference is I've mentioned concrete things that you can defend such as your athena read and the game spec thing.

I do think you should be watched carefully tomorrow especially if I am the lynch today. I think atp me being in the game might serve as a cover to you or DF if you are scum because I feel that both of you have been able to coast through the day to some extent.

Bluedoom also thinks I'm scum and yet he is voting you. How does that parse for you?
 
Votecount 1.3
-----------------
MewtwoHidden (4)- Samoyed, Clarinet, Duskfall98, Whydon
Clarinet (3)- Athena_57, XnadrojX, CaffeineBoost
bluedoom (2)- apricity, MewtwoHidden
Athena_57 (1)- DS.
DS. (1)- bluedoom

Not Voting (2)- ZestOfLife, Hannahh

Deadline is 23 May, 2019 at 6:00 PM EST.
 
The difference is that you are not one of the concencus lynches, and I am also not pushing for you to be lynched right now. Another difference is I've mentioned concrete things that you can defend such as your athena read and the game spec thing.

I do think you should be watched carefully tomorrow especially if I am the lynch today. I think atp me being in the game might serve as a cover to you or DF if you are scum because I feel that both of you have been able to coast through the day to some extent.

Unless I am mistaken with the vote count, the lynched are currently you and clarinet and you choose to vote for me instead of clarinet who you are also scum reading
 
okay so wagons are tied, watch who moves where and ill try and be back around 3 but if i do end up back im gonna be there with like 2 minutes to spare and im basically gonna need someone to tell me what the votes are at so i can vote
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top