Tldr I've nothing solid but there's people making me go 
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
NOC Fire and Ice (9-2-2 Multiball) [won by town]
- Thread starter HeaLnDeaL
- Start date
that's mafia, baby!Tldr I've nothing solid but there's people making me go
They are all lazy I would be worried if you said otherwise lmao
I think Texas is town because he's playing to his new "I don't care as much anymore mafia is for fun not tryharding" that he's been doing lately where he's kinda trolly as town
You are initially towny but I do actually think you have a very good scum game from the last time I played with you although you will try disagree. A lot of what you have done is similar to the last game I played with you I understand that you created your town meta perfectly so I'm backward 180 trying to read that other people who know you better would say this is how you would act as town. But I'm weary although you might play like this as town you are capable of replicating as scum. But to add another layer of syrup to the waffle, I dunno if I could see you tryharding this game as much as scum as you might as town, because the last game I played with you, probably meant more as you had a lot more friends involved and it was probably a playerlist you enjoy more? Maybe? I'm gonna read you on your progression and see if you can keep up the intrigue and solving.
You are initially towny but I do actually think you have a very good scum game from the last time I played with you although you will try disagree. A lot of what you have done is similar to the last game I played with you I understand that you created your town meta perfectly so I'm backward 180 trying to read that other people who know you better would say this is how you would act as town. But I'm weary although you might play like this as town you are capable of replicating as scum. But to add another layer of syrup to the waffle, I dunno if I could see you tryharding this game as much as scum as you might as town, because the last game I played with you, probably meant more as you had a lot more friends involved and it was probably a playerlist you enjoy more? Maybe? I'm gonna read you on your progression and see if you can keep up the intrigue and solving.
I'm playing 4f mafia yes
I meant 4d but I guess 4f is even bigger brain
The funny part is he looks like a killjoy when he does it. But, yeah, watching him bust out a case made my read on him less begrudging.
He's not being mean he's just teasing
i'm they/them but go off
i hate buddying amy in our first game together in years but she's right on so many levels that i'm about to catch the dropkick and slam dunk you
PS swooping in with a one liner is In Character but NAI, can we get some Meat in here? dusk's reads are like sucking marrow out of yesterday's stewed bones, so weak even i could've come up with them
standby for
Was this you slamdunking me?
In order of scumminess:
1. CaffeineBoost - high activity for a front half, fell off as soon as pressure came on. Might be cooling down because of high volume/low content and current trends are anti-that, but thenight day is still young
2. Duskfall98 - the reason we started talking about LOLIS is because Dusk dropped an LOL I'm Scum statement, and spent the rest of Early D1 trying to defend it and meme around it. plenty of interaction with PS, could just be riffing, could be a repertoire to be susp of.
3. Panic Station -
4. Waterlily3 - meme'd, also LOLIS, but listens to kpop and has Jisen as pfp so i'll lynch her later.
5.Thunder~BALLZ
6. Sultan of Skook
7. OM - literally confirmed and AFK'd. OM git gud
8. Fenrir Aesir - confirmed, tagged TBZ, and oneliner'd texas's elucidate comment while also sucking up to Shub/Dusk/Amy. Might just be low effort town.
9. Texas Cloverleaf
10. U-Turn Out - confirmed, two vote posts and asked for elaboration. got that elaboration almost 24 hours ago at this point. U-Turn Out git gud
11. heuryalone - low volume/high content comparatively. doesn't like class clown Panic Station, and seems to be the target of quite a bit of ire. not quite sure where the ire is actually coming from, literally why
12. Ampharos - high volume/high content, making reads that feel In The Box. That's not Inherently wrong, but throwing a vote and Then finding the reasoning feels off. Especially when it's halfway to hammer, and you spent long enough riffing and meme-ing to throw meme votes around first. however, notice that i'm still putting her at like, most townie. I don't like her play style but i don't think it's mafia, i think it's just Bad Town :P
13. Shubaka17 - me, player of pokemon, catcher of poison types, and slayer of Gen 5. my pronouns are they/them u assholes.
I need to go do some errands and should be back in like 40 minutes, but this will get re-posted with everyone and more in Depth stuff
1. CaffeineBoost - high activity for a front half, fell off as soon as pressure came on. Might be cooling down because of high volume/low content and current trends are anti-that, but the
2. Duskfall98 - the reason we started talking about LOLIS is because Dusk dropped an LOL I'm Scum statement, and spent the rest of Early D1 trying to defend it and meme around it. plenty of interaction with PS, could just be riffing, could be a repertoire to be susp of.
3. Panic Station -
4. Waterlily3 - meme'd, also LOLIS, but listens to kpop and has Jisen as pfp so i'll lynch her later.
5.Thunder~BALLZ
6. Sultan of Skook
7. OM - literally confirmed and AFK'd. OM git gud
8. Fenrir Aesir - confirmed, tagged TBZ, and oneliner'd texas's elucidate comment while also sucking up to Shub/Dusk/Amy. Might just be low effort town.
9. Texas Cloverleaf
10. U-Turn Out - confirmed, two vote posts and asked for elaboration. got that elaboration almost 24 hours ago at this point. U-Turn Out git gud
11. heuryalone - low volume/high content comparatively. doesn't like class clown Panic Station, and seems to be the target of quite a bit of ire. not quite sure where the ire is actually coming from, literally why
12. Ampharos - high volume/high content, making reads that feel In The Box. That's not Inherently wrong, but throwing a vote and Then finding the reasoning feels off. Especially when it's halfway to hammer, and you spent long enough riffing and meme-ing to throw meme votes around first. however, notice that i'm still putting her at like, most townie. I don't like her play style but i don't think it's mafia, i think it's just Bad Town :P
13. Shubaka17 - me, player of pokemon, catcher of poison types, and slayer of Gen 5. my pronouns are they/them u assholes.
I need to go do some errands and should be back in like 40 minutes, but this will get re-posted with everyone and more in Depth stuff
Ps sorry for pronoun mistake
no, i'll just hit u irl later
not sure if this is a mischaracterization or just a misread, but i thought i made it pretty clear that i already had the reasoning when i made the vote
i DID have a brief moment of "hold on lemme go doublecheck this real quick" after the fact but the vote was entirely motivated by the reasoning i later gave
and i only spent like... 20 minutes riffing? and it was way past rvs so like
call me bad one more time m8 i fookin dare ya
Almost page 10 and only thing we can agree on is Amy is bad :(
this is literally every game he's ever played
i voted heury for the same reason as ampy
cb read was pulled out of my ass for reaction testing, sad no one bit on it
You'd know if you read literally just the first few pages of CK9++