To be fair, my previous vote for Caff was also basically just bandwagoning.
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Pokemon Mystery Dungeon NOCfia DX
- Thread starter charlieum
- Start date
Clarinet said that Caffeine should be rolecopped
Caffeine inferred that to mean that there is a rolecop in the game, and that that rolecop is likely mafia -- this part makes sense to me and I agreed with it when he posted it.
He then took it a step further and said that "he thinks he knows who the rolecop is" and voted clarinet in a way that made it seem that he already knew that clarinet was a rolecop -- this is confusing to me pre-clarinet flip
clarinet flips rolecop
now caffeine being right about not only clarinet scum, but clarinet rolecop seems a bit sketchy.
To put it better.
If I publicaly shame someone for saying they kick puppies, does that mean I'm a puppy kicker, too?
If I publicaly shame someone for saying they kick puppies, does that mean I'm a puppy kicker, too?
but you're forgetting the part where Caff said "I think I know who the rolecop is" and voted Clar.
I think you are missing a vital piece of my case, and that may be why you don't understand where I am coming from.
I get where you're coming from. I also think you don't understand what a fucking Freudian slip is.
Clar literally said what was on his mind, which happened to include his role PM.
Freud·i·an slip
/ˌfroidēən ˈslip/
noun
noun: Freudian slip; plural noun: Freudian slips
/ˌfroidēən ˈslip/
noun
noun: Freudian slip; plural noun: Freudian slips
- an unintentional error regarded as revealing subconscious feelings.
I mean I guess? I took it more to be a slip that scum had a rolecop. I still think its disingenuous to say I'm misrepping Caffeine tho when I'm quoting exactly what he's saying and just interpreting it a little bit differently than you.
I'm a fucking psychology major you asshat
The slip is definitely TMI, but it's not Caff's TMI.
The misrep is you're attributing Clar's guilt to Caff because Caff saw the slip and knew that role cop is scum exclusive.
We aren't debating whether clarinet slipped--that much is obvious. I am debating that Clar's TMI infers that scum has a rolecop, but Caff inferred that to mean that Clar is a rolecop. You seem to think that Clar was slipping himself as a rolecop and Caff just interpreted it as it is.
I disagree that your interpretation is the only one. I think both are possible and I don't like how you're pushing the option that reduces the lynch pool you're swimming in.
