where
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Death on the Dance Floor [Game Over: X Wins]
- Thread starter Panic Station
- Start date
I should get to bed
in case I forget about the game I'll just
unvote
vote: haruno
I haven't looked too hard at u turn yet, nothing they've done seems egregious
in case I forget about the game I'll just
unvote
vote: haruno
I haven't looked too hard at u turn yet, nothing they've done seems egregious
where I'm at atm
idk tennysons last post seemed p good, or at least it beat my expectations.
Up-To-Date Votal
dopog - 1 (Energy)
Haruno - 3 (MoodyCloud, Mega-Pokebattlerz, smogon account)
Energy - 1 (Haruno)
U-Turn Out - 3 (HeaLnDeaL, Tennyson, M2H)
Tennyson - 1 (dopog)
DawningWinds- 1 (U-Turn Out)
Bold indicates the player up for elimination. As mentioned in the ruleset, ties are determined by FIFO order. I swear the order of votes is accurate, but let me know if any errors have been made. Y'all were voting while I was tallying.
13 hours until deadline. I will try to get one last votal in at the T-2 hours or T-1 hour mark.
dopog - 1 (Energy)
Haruno - 3 (MoodyCloud, Mega-Pokebattlerz, smogon account)
Energy - 1 (Haruno)
U-Turn Out - 3 (HeaLnDeaL, Tennyson, M2H)
Tennyson - 1 (dopog)
DawningWinds- 1 (U-Turn Out)
Bold indicates the player up for elimination. As mentioned in the ruleset, ties are determined by FIFO order. I swear the order of votes is accurate, but let me know if any errors have been made. Y'all were voting while I was tallying.
13 hours until deadline. I will try to get one last votal in at the T-2 hours or T-1 hour mark.
back, first i'll get my reads on the past few pages out of the way
plus, this is a vote coming out of the blue from someone I scumread more in the first place
this pings me bad
>uturn on dawning
dawning not making reads is kind of annoying so I guess i'd have to doublecheck dawn's post but that's fine
>uturn vote on m2h
what
I mean, I guess they could be a deepwolf but there are way better lynches [I hope I used deepwolf right]
>HealnDeal on their content
withholding reads doesn't really help the gamestate, it's not like the scum can't sort out who seems scummy from who seems town
like, i'm not saying you're completely fluff, you aren't at this point, but sharing tentative reads isn't going to hurt anything and if you say interesting stuff that makes you 'locktown' or 'lockscum' then bam, slot solved
you do you though
>m2h on moody being the disco king if scum
I liked this question from smogon and, uh... I guess the answer is fine but I really don't agree with it. Not a big deal overall but it's a leap in logic I get but don't personally agree with. NAI.
>meta reads on moody
lul meta
maybe it stops being lul meta if you play a bunch of smogon mafias though
who knows
>I can't even tell what your reads are
i'm town, m2h and mega are probably town, m2h gives off a good vibe and is, like, solving and stuff while mega kind of spewed himself town at game start
smogon is asking some cool questions so I put them as light town
tennyson/dopog/energy are null, low content. You were here and I have yet to form a solid read on you besides "why do you like moody so much oh look they voted m2h"
haruno I scumread hard, moody i've scumread at points but I need to read through their iso again (will do after this post), healndeal felt fluffy and was pinging me as scum earlier but they're feeling a little better to me now, I think dawning was pinging as scum but I can't remember on what exactly and all I remember now is "they agreed with me on energy not being clear, I like them"
>energy, the null, tries to vote another null
I am null confused on this
>I made tennyson sick with my terrible formatting or content or something
um
thanks I guess
oh yeah, I just realized this is posting from them, hopefully they'll move from null soon
anyways, uto is weird but i'm not willing to drop a vote on them as of now, leaning towards haruno
will reread moody before I place any votes down though
it's nice to see people who agree that energy isn't magically lock town but from what I recall they didn't seem scummy either
plus, this is a vote coming out of the blue from someone I scumread more in the first place
this pings me bad
>uturn on dawning
dawning not making reads is kind of annoying so I guess i'd have to doublecheck dawn's post but that's fine
>uturn vote on m2h
what
I mean, I guess they could be a deepwolf but there are way better lynches [I hope I used deepwolf right]
>HealnDeal on their content
withholding reads doesn't really help the gamestate, it's not like the scum can't sort out who seems scummy from who seems town
like, i'm not saying you're completely fluff, you aren't at this point, but sharing tentative reads isn't going to hurt anything and if you say interesting stuff that makes you 'locktown' or 'lockscum' then bam, slot solved
you do you though
>m2h on moody being the disco king if scum
I liked this question from smogon and, uh... I guess the answer is fine but I really don't agree with it. Not a big deal overall but it's a leap in logic I get but don't personally agree with. NAI.
>meta reads on moody
lul meta
maybe it stops being lul meta if you play a bunch of smogon mafias though
who knows
>I can't even tell what your reads are
i'm town, m2h and mega are probably town, m2h gives off a good vibe and is, like, solving and stuff while mega kind of spewed himself town at game start
smogon is asking some cool questions so I put them as light town
tennyson/dopog/energy are null, low content. You were here and I have yet to form a solid read on you besides "why do you like moody so much oh look they voted m2h"
haruno I scumread hard, moody i've scumread at points but I need to read through their iso again (will do after this post), healndeal felt fluffy and was pinging me as scum earlier but they're feeling a little better to me now, I think dawning was pinging as scum but I can't remember on what exactly and all I remember now is "they agreed with me on energy not being clear, I like them"
>energy, the null, tries to vote another null
I am null confused on this
>I made tennyson sick with my terrible formatting or content or something
um
thanks I guess
oh yeah, I just realized this is posting from them, hopefully they'll move from null soon
anyways, uto is weird but i'm not willing to drop a vote on them as of now, leaning towards haruno
will reread moody before I place any votes down though
when uto flips wolf this dies next
I had no expectations and it disappointed me
I know I said I was going to bed but I'm an addict or whatever
this probably doesn't need to be said but vig should shoot the counterwagon if we flip town today, unless you're 100% sure on a hero shot, and even then it's still more pro town to not do that
this is pretty stinky too wow
>energy gets to be lock town until I change my mind
first post of the game besides their confirmation
why, I don't like this weird buddying
after this are some interactions that don't ping me much either way, little bit of fluff, and mega stuff
one gamesolvey question at m2h is nice, then some vague "i'm uncomfortable with this scummy thing but will not explain what it even is", which adds no real content while making it look like you're solving
>pushing on haruno
policylynches bad but haruno has proved themselves to be, uh, scummy if nothing else, so ultimately good push with a weird start, NAI.
>prodding people (including me)
I mean, it's not amazingly townie content but it's useful, pings me town a little I ugess?
>asks for reads from mega and a couple other questions
this is nice, pings me town
>more policy lynch stuff
meh, find a scumread dude
>4D chess move with smogonaccount
pings me neither way but confuses me slightly
was this you going "smogon seems scummy" because it seemed like they were trying to buddy with you? That's my guess but I can't really be sure.
>do you expect haruno to try d2
this is after haruno actually posted
big agree with this
and nothing much after this, overall I'm reading them as kind of scummy but not as much as haruno
Vote: haruno
it's not a line of logic I really get but it's not as bad as ignoring the point of mafia
first post of the game besides their confirmation
why, I don't like this weird buddying
after this are some interactions that don't ping me much either way, little bit of fluff, and mega stuff
one gamesolvey question at m2h is nice, then some vague "i'm uncomfortable with this scummy thing but will not explain what it even is", which adds no real content while making it look like you're solving
>pushing on haruno
policylynches bad but haruno has proved themselves to be, uh, scummy if nothing else, so ultimately good push with a weird start, NAI.
>prodding people (including me)
I mean, it's not amazingly townie content but it's useful, pings me town a little I ugess?
>asks for reads from mega and a couple other questions
this is nice, pings me town
>more policy lynch stuff
meh, find a scumread dude
>4D chess move with smogonaccount
pings me neither way but confuses me slightly
was this you going "smogon seems scummy" because it seemed like they were trying to buddy with you? That's my guess but I can't really be sure.
>do you expect haruno to try d2
this is after haruno actually posted
big agree with this
and nothing much after this, overall I'm reading them as kind of scummy but not as much as haruno
Vote: haruno
please explain to me why you think uto's moody read and jump on m2h scummier than haruno's "I will contribute nothing and be proud of it" extravaganza
it's not a line of logic I really get but it's not as bad as ignoring the point of mafia
oh yeah, I forgot to mention it at the start of last post but that was the moody iso
this makes more sense now, wow
is haruno and moody both being scummy to you not a problem?
can i interest you in a town moodycloud
okay I'm really going to bed
tennyson not actually having an example of dawning's "level 2 reasoning" is extremely n o t e d
I have a bunch of associatives that I wish I didn't but sometimes that's the way it goes
tennyson not actually having an example of dawning's "level 2 reasoning" is extremely n o t e d
I have a bunch of associatives that I wish I didn't but sometimes that's the way it goes
BLOODYRAIN10001 not contributing isn’t ai. I strongly think you’re being bad.
this was the level 2 smogon
Some how I had only seen the post before it
Still lame reasoning and no I'm not just tunneling
Good night
Still lame reasoning and no I'm not just tunneling
Good night
if haruno flips scum then moody will seem less scummy although I guess his play would make sense as long as haruno isn't the disco king
Step 1: bussing
Step 2: ???
Step 3: profit
I guess that ties into m2h's "moody is the disco king" if he's scum thing although my logic to get there isn't the same as is, and in this case it's more "haruno ISN'T the disco king if moody is scum"
anyways, moody isn't lockscum or anything, there's, like, a not-negligible chance he's town
his posts just feel scummier than most of the other people
i'm confused, town want to gamesolve, scum want to prevent us from gamesolving by either providing no real content or derailing us
if haruno isn't interested in solving the game or providing any sort of content they're either not interested in playing mafia or they're scum
i'm
what the actual fuck
doesn't that just defeat the point of playing mafia at all
maximize-
i'm sorry i'm legitimately just confused by why anyone would do that besides liking big wins
i'll take your word on it and glance over some of their past mafias in the morning, this style of play being NAI and intentional as all roles is intensely confusing though
it sounds like trying to play mafia as an idle game
and for what it's worth the energy vote isn't something I scumread them on completely, the townreads on him felt weird to me too