CAP 2 Smogon "Create a Pokemon" Part Deux: Poll 5

Status
Not open for further replies.
i would say pure fighting is a good type, maye not as good as fight/ghost but still good, it resists tyranitars STABS and hits it with 4x efective attacks, it switches into blissey, snorlax, regice and many steel walls it has only 2 weaknasses flying (not common, used mostly as STAB) and psychic (slightly more common, used only as STAB) figting types have been known to have good HP and some ghosts do two, like driftblim.
what will make or break this pokemon is not so much its defencive power, but ether its ability to bulk up, or its raw power with unresisted STABs.
 
Here's my vote:

1) Gothic Togekiss
(90/105/100/70/95/65)
2) futuresuperstar
(90/105/90/65/110/65)
3) Rhykune
(95/110/80/70/100/70)
4) King of Anime
(75/110/110/70/95/65)
5) Deck Knight
(83/101/118/71/86/66)
6) DougJustDoug
(90/95/100/70/90/80)
7) Lord Sunday
(110/95/80/70/75/85)
8) sanjay120
(110/120/70/85/70/70)
9) eric the espeon
(125/110/70/65/78/72)


Basically: Things I don't like, and are placed lower: HP too high, speed too high, attack too high or too low, imbalance in defenses. A combination of those will determine how low or high a spread gets in my opinion.


Did I mention I find Gothic Togekiss' one to be perfect?



Edit: By the way, this is the spread obtained through making the mean of each one's stats (I'm truncating the decimals, so the BST is lower than 525):

Mean spread: 96/105/90/70/88/70, BST = 519
 
I find that a spot in number 4 is perfectly warm for me. :)

Also Togekiss, I've not elected my own spread first. I chose it like 3rd or something.
 
1. sanjay120
2. Lord Sunday
3. KoA
4. Rhykune
5. DougJustDoug
6. futuresuperstar
7. Gothic Togekiss
8. eric the espeon
9. Deck Knight

If Deck Knight just hadn't given it ONE EXTRA BONUS POINT to outspeed base 65's, I would have put him closer to the top. But no, he had to make another Garchomp. >=^(
 
GengarCrysis92 said:
______________________________________________________Movepool.
Physical:
Brick Break
Mach Punch
Focus Punch
Sky Uppercut
Shadow Claw/Shadow Sneak
Shadow Punch
Elemental Punches
Night Slash/Payback/Knock-off
Double-Edge
Explosion/Selfdestruct
Dizzy Punch

Special:

HP
Focus Blast
Shadow Ball
Psychic


Support:
Slack-off/recover/Pain Split
Toxic
Thunderwave
Confuse Ray
Bulk - up
Detect

Well, those are my thoughts. i wasn't sure if i went with too little moves, but it is better than too much. I hope this is at least considered, even if it isn't really needed right now. I have been feeling left out, since I am not sure about BST.
Click to expand...
Just re-posting so people can comment. :)
 
Time Mage said:
Edit: By the way, this is the spread obtained through making the mean of each one's stats (I'm truncating the decimals, so the BST is lower than 525):

Mean spread: 96/105/90/70/88/70, BST = 519
Click to expand...

Waits for some math genius to say the mean isn't the proper way to do it and that some long and complicated statistical analysis that will give you marginally more accurate results is the better way.

But yah, wierd that the spreads that are winning are closer to that mean than the spreads that are losing.
 
Hey Hyra, should I post here the Attack and Defense Tiers for the contestant's spreads, just for the sake of reference?

EDIT: Oh yeah, the voting.

1. Deck Knight
2. Sanjay120
3. DougJustDoug
4. Lord_Sunday
5. Rhykune
6. futuresuperstar
7. Gothic Togekiss
8. KoA
9. eric the espeon
 
1. Rhykune
2. futuresuperstar
3. Gothic Togekiss
4. KingOfAnime
5. Lord_Sunday
6. DougJustDoug
7. Deck Knight
8. sanjay numbers
9. eric the espeon
 
Hey I'm back. Ok first off, my order...

1. Rhykune (Duh)
2. FutureSuperStar
3. Gothic Togekiss
4. Sanjay120
5. DougJustDoug
6. eric the espeon
7. Deck Knight
8. KingofAnime-KOA
9. Lord_Sunday

Wow, it's looking like people like my spread, awesomeness. I was winning a couple pages ago, I wonder what it is now. Doesn't look like people are campaigning, so I am just going to sit back and watch for now...
 
Okay, as Hyra allowed me to, here are the Attack and Defense Tiers for the contestants' spreads. Please keep in mind that all spreads (offensive and defensive) are 0/0 neutral, 252/252 +nature. If you want the neutral spread, subtract 1 from the Tiers; if you want negative, subtract 1 again and if you want the 0/0 +nature spread, add 1.

Oh yeah, I can't forget the main wall's tiers, just for reference:

Code: 
[B]Wobbuffet:[/B] 118.35 - 124.18 Physical [i]and[/i] Special.
[B]Lapras:[/B] 118.27 - 123.72 Physical; 119.76 - 124.87 Special.
[B]Walrein:[/B] 118.18 - 123.56 Physical [i]and[/i] Special.
[B]Swampert:[/B] 117.59 - 123.05 Physical [i]and[/i] Special.
[B]Dusknoir:[/B] 117.15 - 122.65 Physical [i]and[/i] Special.
[B]Spiritomb:[/B] 115.56 - 121.34 Physical [i]and[/i] Special.
[B]Hippowdon:[/B] 120.49 - 125.38 Physical; 116.15 - 122.01 Special.
[B]Forretress:[/B] 119.91 - 124.88 Physical; 112.51 - 119.12 Special.
[B]Skarmory:[/B] 119.17 - 124.27 Physical; 113.03 - 119.43 Special.
[B]Weezing:[/B] 117.75 -122.1 Physical; 113.03 - 118.43 Special.
[B]Gliscor:[/B] 118.87 - 124.01 Physical; 114.35 - 120.47 Special.
[B]Blissey:[/B] 110.21 - 120.08 Physical; 128.03 - 131.96 Special.
[B]Regice:[/B] 117.21 - 122.68 Physical. 123.65 - 128.06 Special.
[B]Milotic:[/B] 116.15 - 122.93 Physical; 120.22 - 125.14 Special.

Those are the walls/tanks I can think on top of my head now. I may add more later.

And now, the Tiers:

Code: 
[B]sanjay120:[/B] [I]110/120/70/85/70/70[/I]

Physical Defense = 116.03 - 121.93 (worse than Pinsir, better than Arcanine)
Special Defense = 116.03 - 121.93 (0/0 spread equals to Drifblim, max spread slightly worse than Metagross)
Physical Attack = 58.97 - 62.13 (Blaziken)
Special Attack = 55.90 - 59.70 (Clefable)

[B]Rhykune:[/B] [I]95/110/80/70/100/70[/I]

Physical Defense = 116.25 - 122.01 (Slowking, Salamence without Intimidate)
Special Defense = 118.2 - 123.51 (Gyarados)
Physical Attack = 58.18 - 61.49 (Swampert)
Special Attack = 54.25 - 58.46 (Castform)

[B]Deck Knight:[/B] [I]83/101/118/71/86/66[/I]

Physical Defense = 118.76 - 124.05 (0/0 spread slightly worse than Lairon, 252/252 better than Lairon)
Special Defense = 115.95 - 121.82 (slightly better than Arcanine)
Physical Attack = 57.33 - 60.81 (Mew) [b]Off by one Base Point[/b]
Special Attack = 54.37 - 58.55 (Loudred)

[B]DougJustDoug:[/B] [I]90/95/100/70/90/80[/I]

Physical Defense = 117.88 - 123.24 (Articuno)
Special Defense = 116.95 - 122.52 (Poliwrath, Zapdos)
Physical Attack = 56.87 - 60.45 (Kangaskhan)
Special Attack = 54.25 - 58.46 (Castform)

[B]Gothic Togekiss:[/B] [I]90/105/100/70/95/65[/I]

Physical Defense = 117.88 - 123.24 (Articuno)
Special Defense = 117.43 - 122.89 (Dewgong)
Physical Attack = 57.76 - 61.15 (Muk)
Special Attack = 54.25 - 58.46 (Castform)

[B]futuresuperstar:[/B] [I]90/105/90/65/110/65[/I]

Physical Defense = 116.95 - 122.52 (Moltres)
Special Defense = 118.73 - 123.92 (slightly worse than Togekiss)
Physical Attack = 57.76 - 61.15 (Muk)
Special Attack = 53.64 - 58.01 (Arbok)

[B]Lord_Sunday:[/B] [I]110/95/80/70/75/85[/I]

Physical Defense = 117.16 - 122.78 (equals to Mamoswine, slightly better than Dusknoir)
Special Defense = 116.61 - 122.36 (0/0 spread better than Hariyama, 252/252 spread worse than Hariyama)
Physical Attack = 56.87 - 60.45 (Kangaskhan)
Special Attack = 54.25 - 58.46 (Castform)

[B]KoA:[/B] [I]75/110/110/70/95/65[/I]

Physical Defense = 117.71 - 123.07 (equals to Sandslash)
Special Defense = 116.40 - 122.03 (equals to Magmortar, better than Dusclops)
Physical Attack = 58.18 - 61.49 (Swampert)
Special Attack = 54.25 - 58.46 (Castform)

[B]eric the espeon:[/B] [I]125/110/70/65/78/72[/I]

Physical Defense = 116.87 - 122.65 (better than Kangaskhan)
Special Defense = 117.79 - 123.33 (0/0 spread worse than Raikou, 252/252 spread better than Raikou)
Physical Attack = 58.18 - 61.49 (Swampert)
Special Attack = 53.64 - 58.01 (Arbok)

When I say "slightly worse/better", it means the difference is REALLY small (0.01-0.03). When I just say "worse/better", it's pretty much that, the difference is bigger >_>
 
Updated Vote Totals
This is what I got up to and including Rhykune's vote:

1) Rhykune – 133
2) Gothic Togekiss – 150
3) Futuresuperstar – 155
4) Deck Knight – 168
5) Sanjay120 – 172
6) King of Anime – 178
7) Eric the Espeon – 184
8) DougJustDoug – 185
9) Lord Sunday – 201
 
1-FFS
2-Lord Sunday
3-DougJustDoug
4-Eric the Espeon
5-KoA
6-Sanjay120
7-Deck Knight
8-Gothic Togekiss
9-Rhykune

Easy choice imo.
 
... Did that guy just totally vote backwards to help me win?

... That's awesome! Lol. Well, honestly, it may seem cheap, but it's no different from waiting to vote in a poll until the results are close, or any kind of Hurt / Heal game. This is, essentially, a Hurt + Heal Poll ... which brings me back to the point that this should have been just a poll with perhaps two or three options to vote.

But, since it isn't, strategic voting will most likely occur (as we just saw).
 
futuresuperstar said:
... Did that guy just totally vote backwards to help me win?

... That's awesome! Lol. Well, honestly, it may seem cheap, but it's no different from waiting to vote in a poll until the results are close, or any kind of Hurt / Heal game. This is, essentially, a Hurt + Heal Poll ... which brings me back to the point that this should have been just a poll with perhaps two or three options to vote.

But, since it isn't, strategic voting will most likely occur (as we just saw).
Click to expand...

Sorry, honestly I couldn't help myself. The next 8 spreads didn't really matter to me, and maybe it was just me, but you seemed to put the most effort into the spread. If the judges want to take my post down, I guess I can't really complain.
 
Hyra said:
Waits for some math genius to say the mean isn't the proper way to do it and that some long and complicated statistical analysis that will give you marginally more accurate results is the better way.

But yah, wierd that the spreads that are winning are closer to that mean than the spreads that are losing.
Click to expand...

Well, I just did it for fun. It really doesn't represent anything, and I doubt any other method would be really more accurate. Well, I guess I could also calculate the standard deviation for each parameter, but the truth is that with a sample of 9 you can't really do a good statistical analysis anyway. I'm not exactly math illiterate, mind you ;)

Also: Gothic Togekiss, don't be so bitter. You spread is the best, I know it, you know it. But truth is, most if not all the other spreads have their merits, and some of them are really close to yours in greatness.
 
1-FFS
2-Lord Sunday
3-DougJustDoug
4-Eric the Espeon
5-KoA
6-Sanjay120
7-Deck Knight
8-Gothic Togekiss
9-Rhykune
i gotta agree with proto, no matter how cheap it is

IMO it was between gothic togekiss and FSS, since the spreads are so much alike but because of the huge deference in the amout of effort put in it i choose FSS.As wells as the fact that it's only supereffective hits this thing should see often would be Special thus needing a high special defense
 
Time Mage said:
Gothic Togekiss, don't be so bitter. You spread is the best, I know it, you know it. But truth is, most if not all the other spreads have their merits, and some of them are really close to yours in greatness.
Click to expand...
I'm not all that bitter, just a bit hurted. Honestly...I know there this has to be done and all, but I still feel attached to my stat spread like my own son and seeing my spread being erratically placed on people's list with reason like "Didn't care for the other 8 so I randomly placed them in any order without cause" make me feel hurted. I can understand if you actually thought it through and chose your choices out with care and give a little explaintion onto your reasoning but saying that something simliar to my little phrase...well I take that as an personal attack.

I fully aware that everyone else spread have their good points and bad points and that all deserve it but, damn randomly placing someone spread/idea/whatever last for no damn reason tick me off.


Yes...ignore the weird coloring above as I don't know how to do spolier tagging. Anyway....this is a heated battle and I still have faith in my spread.
 
To be honest, I think the majority of these votes are not random. As I tallied everything up, I saw huge correlations in votes. Obviously, there are a few exceptions, but in most cases, they were very much alike. For instance, Gothic Togekiss, we were voted all over the map. However, a *huge* amount of people voted for us back-to-back. When you were first, I was second. When I was sixth, you were seventh. When you were fourth, I was fifth.

I noticed that on page 2 and 3, specifically, we were almost always right next to each other.

And the recent votes are also not random. They are the exact vote totals backwards. In other words, they voted for their favorite, and then anti-voted the rest. It is cheap, I agree -- and, again, I think a regular poll (with two to three options) would have been better to avoid this. But, it still isn't random.

In fact, with the exception of the recent two votes of "anti-voting," your vote actually has our two spreads the farthest apart of any vote, =p.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top