wesh papillon said:They can vary a lot, pokemon that win against water or rock like shroodle completly lose to dark. It would be true if one were packing 2-3 potential shellder answers, but that still assumes u play the whole game knowing which pokemon can get chipped on which have to stay healthy. I think he ability to bypass ur own checks on a pokemon that wins game off 1 interaction isnt healthy.
I addressed that in my post, could you mention how they vary a lot? Tera Dark leaves you better against Pawniard Sucker Punch and a Pivot Shroodle set that is relevant, but dropping usage. Without consuming Tera or boosting STAB or Rock Blast you will fail to get OHKOs. Foongus beats Tera Water or Tera Dark reliably. You can also construct teams that make it difficult to find set up opportunities early so you can establish your own gameplan, Roar Mudbray denies the Shell Smash, Giga Drain Alolan Grimer on Grassy Terrain OHKOs -1 Shellder. Shellder can be effective early game, softening up some of Numels answers, but teams are typically capable of diversifying their answers, not just having defensive solutions. Between the Unburden Pokemon (that you mention later and I will inevitably talk about), priority (Life Orb Pawniard is still good against Numel even if you're tera dark Shellder). You can generally afford to trade 1 for 1 for the Shellder early game assuming you haven't walked into a set up trap. Consuming Tera early in the game removes a lot of guesswork from your opponent and allows them to use theirs aggressively to even out the score, so it is not "1 interaction wins you the game" to the degree that you're describing. Theres a lot of game to be played before Shellder just wins the game, and that goes for numel especially given it requires an extra turn to be used.
wesh papillon said:While there are checks and you can tera to beat it, like I said, the issue really is not numel on its own, but the combo of shellder and numel. You can tera to beat one but then u prob lose to the other.
You have tools beyond Tera to handle them as I've mentioned some above. This is a gross oversimplification of the game, and makes no mention of how you can be the aggressor and put your opponent on the backpedal at times. Numel and Shellder are fantastic when you're in an advantaged state, because they help push that, but your team adds fragility, they cannot often manage to sacrifice life to handle threats and preform as well offensively. You are making sacrifices, and if you are down on tempo and your own Shellder, or Numel, or Unburden Shroodle can claim the win.
wesh papillon said:Again, if u tera the foongus, you are in an awful spot into the numel. Also like stuff gets chipped and trapped in games. Its pretty easy to force damage on pokemon that need to be at almsot full to check shellder
Yes using Tera has downsides, Foongus isn't exactly an answer to Numel pre-Tera anyway. Yes if your opponent executes their gameplan effectively. Succeeding in chipping your Pokemon that can answer a healthy Shellder or Numel, and making you burn Tera means they have played towards their win condition. You can do this exactly thing with Unburden Shroodle or looking to the past, basically any power set-up sweeper. Both players have the option to attempt this kind of strategy, and not simply weather the storm of hard hits and hope they live.
wesh papillon said:In a 1v1 yea maybe, but unless ur using dragon coco ur not beating both lol
These Pokemon that are using Tera Dragon are often Pokemon Shellder could attempt sweeps on, although again, Roar Mudbray or Giga Drain/Memento Grimer can deny these opportunities in certain circumstances w/o even using Tera. You seem to be very adamant that Tera is the only way to stop these Pokemon, please go into more detail about how they are no non-tera answers. Fuecoco is a 0 usage in LCPL Pokemon, lets keep the discussion to Pokemon relevant to tournament/high level play
wesh papillon said:Setting up unburden isnt that easy, you still need to sac pokemon, and potentially tera for shroodle vs numel. Again, I would not call this reliable like at all. Drifloon having to chip itself leaves 1 sac and itself vulnerable to be even further setup food
Yes it is, we've seen it often. 24 HP Drifloon if rocks are up can get Unburden reliably throughout a game, Unburden Shroodle simply requires Grassy Terrain, yes you might want to save it, but an out is an out and Shroodle is naturally fast regardless. Through a game you mention Pokemon get chipped, why suddenly can't the drifloon have been chipped as a means to Proc unburden at necessary times. These kinds of moments where you plan ahead to generate more counterplay are creative and skill expressive. This point about Tera 50/50s applies for Tera Ground Shroodle primarily here are the calcs for the almost as popular Tera Flying or simply Knock Off from base Shroodle.
Calcs
236+ Atk Tera Flying Shroodle Acrobatics (110 BP) vs. 0 HP / 36 Def Eviolite Numel: 13-16 (59 - 72.7%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
Possible damage amounts: (13, 13, 13, 13, 13, 13, 15, 15, 15, 15, 15, 15, 15, 15, 15, 16)
236+ Atk Shroodle Acrobatics (110 BP) vs. 0 HP / 36 Def Eviolite Numel: 9-11 (40.9 - 50%) -- 0.4% chance to 2HKO
Possible damage amounts: (9, 9, 9, 9, 9, 9, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 11)
236+ Atk Shroodle Knock Off (97.5 BP) vs. 0 HP / 36 Def Eviolite Numel: 8-10 (36.3 - 45.4%) -- guaranteed 3HKO
Possible damage amounts: (8, 8, 8, 8, 8, 9, 9, 9, 9, 9, 9, 9, 9, 9, 9, 10)
Ofc this is assuming Numel hasn't had to consume Tera to find set up opportunities, Shroodle is not perfect in this case but it acts a reasonable RKer if Numel had to sacrifice turns to set up. It is not free and you will expect to take damage. Lastly per your point about Drifloon again, what exactly is Drifloon set up bait for? It can run Will-o-Wisp for physical attackers, is 34 speed post unburden so you can't flame charge on it if its healthy. And has ran endure/memento/dbond as various options to act as a revenge killer or deny set up attempts.
wesh papillon said:the point is that Included EVERY replay where shellder and/or numel lost to a team without them lol
How do you watch this and think these Pokemon are a problem is why I questioned. People should want to be the best player if they're participating at a competitive level, these weren't some unattainable feats of skill. You're basically walking yourself into a l2p argument, but I'll spare the uselessness of that.
wesh papillon said:It also lost when hacker used it. The shellos is also much weaker and is teching clear smog, as well as TWO pokemon packing memento. Imo I think the players knew BBB would only ever lose this player mu to cheese. Teams like the are a rare sight for pretty obvious reasons, and saying otherwise is disingenuous lol. Im not saying the team is bad, it obv did well, but the amount of counter play to an archetype should at the very least indicate.
On the LC Discord (Shoutouts join if you haven't we're having a lot of LCPL discussion in VC and chats!), people, including Hacker have talked about this game. td;lr Odds were in his favor to win, and he had a cleaner line to win that was mentioned later. People are adapting to the meta with their moveslots and Pokemon choices, what is wrong with this. You aren't suddenly auto losing to other strategies if your memento becomes slightly less useful or clear smog isn't getting clicked. Shellos is tanky and puts Gothita in an awkward spot due to sticky hold and Tera (Dragon etc). I'm not here to talk about LCPL prep, but BBB is good we get the point. People have not consistently been rolling up w/ "bad" Pokemon to answer the Numel & Shellder duo, this is disingenuous and borders on straight lying. Even if they were these Pokemon would suddenly be less bad, as they have a newfound niche that should be celebrated rather than berating the meta.
wesh papillon said:I think u completly missed the point of the bottom half of the post lol. Im arguing against myself to give the post a fair chance. Again, nymble and meowth are almsot exclusively good into these two mons + like a few other ho dudes like shrrodle. They still see play cuz of how oppressive this archetype is.
I saw the point, I think the point had nothing of value. These "counterarguments" were mostly awful and borderline are parody/mocking of people who disagree with your viewpoint. Meowth is a fast, hard hitting priority user that has coverage to OHKO the Ghost types of the tier. Its just generically strong, and benefits especially from this meta. I think both have been slept on (and Nymble actually saw a lot of use in Growlithe-H meta), and now is Meowths time to get acknowledgement. These are meta developments to make Pokemon less effective, in spite of these changes we will see if they somehow continue to show dominance.
wesh papillon said:Again, the reason why shellder win rate wasnt 100% week 3 is cuz of this game.
The winrate being "low" is because ppl are fishing heavily against these 2 mons, shellder players misplaying, or just pokemon.
Also no offense but I think I could pilot this team lol it doesnt look that hard
None of these replays have shown any fishing, could you provide some or is the onus on the person not arguing for change to go dig your argument out for you.
I never said the team was hard to play nor do I care lmao if a team gets the job done it gets the job done. I said Shoddy's game required solid piloting to win and it is not mindless. Please don't put words in my mouth.
wesh papillon said:This is so disengenious lol. My point is that they WIN if you dont hard mu fish for, lose a coin flip, if if the opponent doesnt randomly fuck up.
Again, ppl are getting better and better at using shellder, this win rate is only going up on average.
Again, in the latest week, it won 6/7 games
My point is that you have to bring answers to beat these Pokemon, and there was no matchup fishing, prepping and bringing answers to common, powerful Pokemon is how you play the game. Where were the coinflips, please point them out. Sample size of 7 whole games, average it out with the other weeks and Shellders sitting around a 50% winrate. Shellder is not some hard to pilot Pokemon that isn't intuitive, and you're seeing extremely similar teams week after week. You're very much cherrypicking.
wesh papillon said:I think mine are much closer to the truth as we're seeing highly ranked players like hacker getting completly destroyed by shellder. We're also seeing shellder and numel pair with other pokemon like goth, axew, shroodle, etc, to make that archetype stronger each week.
Good player loses to other good players in bo1 tournament. Hacker might be better overall then a lot of the competition, but he has to play well in the actual game to win. No one is entitled to win a game based off their sheet record. Set up sweepers when built around become a win condition. These are not new or problematic parts of the game. You're very much showing your personal bias against this kind of strategy without saying why its a problem outside of "theres no counterplay" or "its 50/50s" without showing any substance or why it devolves down to this.
wesh papillon said:Okay well I disagree, I havent been having fun playing vs HO every other game? Shellder has been an issue for a long time now lol and I think it's time something is done about it. Also yeah theres a reason the offensive pokemon were banned in ss lol.
The point of your post was to say Numel/Shellder should be suspected, not just a post to vent about how you feel about the meta right? You not enjoying it, and the Pokemon being broken are different things. Whether Shellders been an issue doesn't matter, we're talking about the current meta. If you could actually respond to my points on why some of the counterplay mentioned doesn't make for a healthy metagame I will respond accordingly.
wesh papillon said:What does grindy matches even mean lol, like multiple turns of interaction? Obv these teams exist but they are severely restricted, which isnt too surprising, considering this tier has a LOT of offensive powerhouses for few defensive checks lol.
A game that goes long or isn't necessarily decided early. This is just how the meta is, you haven't explained why this is bad and needs to be changed outside of your personal preference.
wesh papillon said:So what was the point of all this lol? If I think the meta would be better, and you think it wouldnt change the dynamic of the gen, then... we can just ban it? Why are you writing a post if u think a suspect is reasonable, you are allowed to vote no ban lol
The dynamic in regards to how fast paced and offensive it is, I do not want Pokemon banned simply because people do not like the meta. If they're broken they should get suspected, not just because or to shake things up. Not how tiering should work.
wesh papillon said:For a decently large post, theres a lack of substance beyond buzzwords, and vague statements.
You quote not even half of what I wrote, and barely responded to everything you did quote. I'm sorry if this offended you, but to repeat my actual concern with your initial post with childish sass, instead of creating an actual discussion is reductive and defeats the point of making your post in the first place.