(copy pasting this from the
OM Workshop as I was told it would fit here better, and cutting out irrelevant parts. sorry if the format ends up being weird, its is almost 2am and I just want to go to bed.)
Good morning
fellas,
fellas and
fellas, it's your least favorite Smogon user back at it again to talk about
this pet mod/format idea I had, which sparked from
this mysterious letter somehow found in the Natdex Forums.
Presenting... SuperHome Playground (clearly-not-working Title)
The premise for this mod/format is to treat the franchise as if Pokémon Home had been around from the start of the franchise in 1996, and every
player-obtainable Pokémon, from either the main series games or games that have the mainline game battle system and can directly trade and interact with the main series games (such as
Colosseum/
XD Gale of Darkness,
Stadium[
2]), were able to be deposited in Pokémon Home and used in future, respective titles.
This would essentially be an entirely unrated mod/format, made simply to battle and experiment with other players while using any previously obtainable Pokémon you want. Aside from the currently obtainable NDexGen9AG Pokémon, this includes the following:
This does NOT include the following Pokémon:
- Pokéstar Opponents
- Missingno, 'M, TMTRAINER, Bad Egg, and all other glitch pokémon
- Eternatus-Eternamax
- "Ghost" from the Pokémon Tower
- The untouchable dog from the start of SwSh
- Floette-Eternal
- Some Unused Shadow Pokémon
- CAP (as in the format. Pikachu-partner and its bros are still allowed)
- Eggs (an egg can't battle!)
- You in the safari zone (throwing mud, rocks and bait)
Spoilers for final part of Scarlet/Violet Main Story
Not having a Pokémon on the field
- Other Pokémon in similar condition to these
Before we move on to the elephant in the aquarium, let's go over a couple things.
- Kind of torn between strictly keeping the newly available pokémon's movepools strictly the same as it was in the last game they were available, or allowing them to receive the moveset changes from their core species only (egg moves can be passed without breeding as of gen 9). Maybe multiple different metas could be made from this mod, with different rules?
- Pokémon caught in a newer generation can go back to a previous generation to learn from a move tutor or TM as long as it is able to learn the move (this rule might be redundant, or might lead to some movepools/legality expanding)
- Event Pokémon must still match their conditions
- As this is based on (NDex) Anything Goes (for now), there are no bans or restrictions that aren't in the games already (only 1 mega, etc.)
On to the big fish in the room... Shadow Pokémon.
1) Are they broken? Are they viable?
2) How do we classify their moves?
3)Which game's mechanics do we use?
These are all good questions, but let's take it one step at a time.
1)Here's the (showdown-relevant) list of differences for Shadow Pokémon from regular Pokémon,
copied from Bulbapedia:
A Shadow Pokémon is unable of doing the following:
- Level it up through battles or Rare Candy (When it is purified, it gains all the exp. accumulated as a Shadow Pokémon. In Colosseum the Shadow Pokémon only starts accumulating exp once it has opened at least 2 bars on the heart gauge. In XD the Shadow Pokémon accumulates exp right away but only gets 80% of the usual exp total.)
- Evolve it using an evolution stone (This doesn’t apply to Colosseum; however, none of the Shadow Pokémon in that game evolve through stone.)
- Change the order of or delete its moves
- Use a TM on it
- Give it a nickname (due to displaying an OT and ID of "?????")
- Trade it.
(Unlisted is the fact that they cannot have any friendship points, and transform will fail if used on one. Shadow Pokémon from XD also cannot be shiny.)
The three biggest factors right now that limit their usefulness are their level cap, their limited movepool, and their inability* to evolve. In a metagame where they have to be faithful, this would render them practically non-viable. However, in a metagame that would allow more leniency, such as a Hackmons or otherwise, they occupy a bigger role.
*Technically speaking, a lv.43 Shadow Wyrdeer may be possible, since evolving Stantler requires using Agile Style Psyshield Bash 20 times, a move which a Shadow Stantler may know at that level in Legends Arceus, depending on how we allow cross-generational moveset updates and in-game mechanics. Mega Stones would also be 100% usable on Shadow Pokémon, making Mega Evolution possible.
2) Now as for
Shadow moves, the XD system would be in place for most of the moves, with the exception of Colosseum's
Shadow Rush, which would be given to Shadow Colosseum mons to make their movesets closer to their initial design and balance. XD's Shadow Rush would still be on its applicable mons, with the move being renamed to "
Shadow Rush XD" to avoid confusion between the two.
This means that
Shadow Rush (Colosseum) will deal neutral damage to every pokémon, while the rest of the shadow moves deal super effective damage to all non-shadow pokémon and not very effective on shadow pokémon. They cannot receive STAB, have unlimited PP and cannot be Sketched. This might give Shadow Pokémon a niche in gimmick roles.
What about the physical/special split? How do you decide which moves are physical and which are special? That's the neat part, we actually don't have to decide! Shadow moves from Pokémon XD were the first moves to be physically and specially split within a type, well before the generation that made it universal! That means special attackers from XD get to have their nice special shadow moves, and special attackers from Colosseum can go home to their physical
Shadow Rush and cry about it. Boo freaking Hoo.
3)
Which game's mechanics do we use?
With the
2023 Bullet Point #2 Shadow Rush Distinction™ established, I think it's fair to say that Colosseum and XD Shadow mechanics should be applied on a per-mon basis, for the sake of balance and consistency.
Hyper Mode can greatly enhance
Shadow Rush's viability by making its crit rate ridiculously high, at the cost of potentially disobeying you if you choose another move.
Reverse Mode, the XD Counterpart, has almost no positive benefits compared to Hyper Mode, apart from not taking up a turn to activate, as it has no critical-hit ratio-raising effect, not even on
Shadow Rush XD. Fortunately, XD also has a mechanic that gives a 50% Speed boost to all Shadow Pokémon in battle, Reverse Mode or not, so at least XD Shadow mons have that going for them.
Should we implement the
Call function? Without it, Hyper Mode is difficult to end (requiring RNG), and Reverse Mode is inescapable. But with it, Colosseum mons skip a turn for free, and XD mons get a free +1 accuracy at no pp cost. It also wakes up sleeping Pokémon at the cost of a turn. I think the "Call" option should only appear when a pokémon is in Hyper/Reverse mode, to prevent abusing it for stall.
From this base, I could see different variations of this mod changing and making its own formats with its own playerbases: one where everything stays unchanged from the base games, one where movepools are expanded on the new mons, one where level limits are removed, one where we bring back all previously usable items (
:berserk-gene: :ginema-berry:
:flying-gem:), and even then we can have one with STABmons on top of it, or Draft, or do some for past gens, or have usage tiers...
Quick things I should clarify since this isn't on the OM forums anymore:
1. This is a gen 9 mod. It could easily be updated to gen 10 by removing tera, adding the gen 10 mechanic, and the mons, abilities, moves and items.
- This means no Dynamax, for the same reason as NatDex, as this mod is based on it.
- Gen 8 would be kind of weird, since you could technically have two different mods, one based on the SwShBDSP battle system and mons, and one based on the Legends battle system and mons, which I don't even want to think about right now (ask me some other time tho)
- Gen 7 and under should be simple enough.
2. I do not count Pokémon Go as an addition to the mod, as although it can transfer to home, its combat style is very different from the main series game and would clash greatly with the rest of the series.
You cannot tap the screen repeatedly to do constant damage in the main series games, as much as 10yr old me would have loved it to be so.
3. If possible, I'd like to have Shadow Pokémon have their Colosseum/XD models and animations, to help differentiate them from their regular counterparts (also they look more dynamic and lively imo). Shadow aura is optional.
Anyway, Free Shadow Pokémon, Free Pikachu-PhD, my brain is shutting down rn so I may have to answer lots of questions. Feel free to ask!