NOC Smogon Mafia Mafia (Won by the Mafia)

[genisu]

Skimmed through the thread during work but feeling a bit sick right now. Gonna go back, skim again and call it a night

there are so many messages ikr

 

[HydrogenHydreigon]

i hate pulsar's tiger vote but also her general vibes are town

 

[realiti]

oh that would make sense, I was p sure I've never seen him scum either lol

not sure I wanna just fully back realiti's read on Hydro's scum game then, especially if it was his first one. realiti hardlocking Hydro as town rn seems predicated on the idea that Hydro is a polarised slot who's either obvscum or not scum and 1 scum game isn't enough of a metric to lock that in as the meta

I was on the scumteam with him and he was playing extremely scared as scum, he gave more reads in the first hour of this game than in the entirety of thatMU game

 

[realiti]

Vote HydrogenHydreigon

Kinda came out of nowhere...

Man i wish i was scum this game, post-death talking with team ability sounds so fun

OMG THIS IS WHAT I MEAN

HOW DO YOU GO FROM "I was probably over-defensive" TO "fairy is the only one not scumreading me" IN THE SAME POST OMGGFHDOSFLKJAFKJHDNG(PUSHNFUSAFKJLSDNFKLN

Ehmcee seems pretty natural in these two posts

 

[realiti]

I'm on page 12 and frankly kinda sick of how 3 people felt the need to repeat the fact that yes, no vote is not the optimal play

 

[realiti]

*Page 11

 

[pulsar512b]

fwiw w.r.t. the actual attempt to make progress by zippy by focusing on blazade

i agree blazade has not done anything that makes me read him as towny

my read of blazade is that he posts solve-ily and focuses on trying to read slots and interactions and stuff. but he does that as mafia too imo. i'd caution people from seeing blazade try to be productive and read the things he's saying as town-leany bc he'd say the same stuff as scum too imo

yes i think blazade is just null afaict

everyones kinda just playing as they normally would, tbh

as far as the vote on tiger, i felt like him basically repeating stuff that The Good Players had just basically been like Nope Bad at was suspicious, but i guess it makes sense if you dont read the thread. it makes sense to not just randomly shoot someone with little info, basically.

so im down to believe that tiger is just a new player who doesnt know the ropes unvote

as far as the rest, hydro is playing his town game

 

[realiti]

Lol.

Noticed Celever and pulsar both voting tiger. Not sure about that bad entrance claim.

NGL I've never seen AG live interact as scum without feeling stiff so I townlean this post. Man I have so many townleans

 

[realiti]

vote pulsar512b

that vote on tiger was bad

Who were you going to vote based off your 1st post, was it pulsar or somebody else?

 

[realiti]

Blazade, Unclesam, Rostam all seem pure town.

Can you elbarote on this

 

[realiti]

I don't think Blazade's posts have been towny at all.

Everyone should re-evaluate that slot.

I agree actually, I've read all of their posts and not once do I remember them throwing out a game-related opinion

 

[realiti]

So many unfamiliar players, this game is going to be harder for me to read than the average Smogon game

 

[ImaginaryNeon]

NGL I've never seen AG live interact as scum without feeling stiff so I townlean this post. Man I have so many townleans

Welcome to absolutely nobody's favorite game show:
Is Four a Lot?

 

[realiti]

Not a fan of Celever's posting, aside from talking about himself and grilling tiger he doesn't seem too interested in scumhunting and advancing the gamestate

 

[genisu]

wait how do we vote ? will there be a form or is the bolded vote (user) binding

 

[realiti]

Neon these spreadsheets are actually super helpful

 

[realiti]

wait how do we vote ? will there be a form or is the bolded vote (user) binding

Yes

 

[realiti]

And the role reveal thing is just weird with the context of last game

Did you read the last game or are you just going off context clues from this thread?

 

[pulsar512b]

actually lemme do a readlist


1. a fairy - nothing interesting coming to mind would have to iso to be sure
2. Aura Guardian - dont think posted much? didnt really make reads either
3. Blazade - null, hasnt posted shit. honestly maybe the most likely mafia?? im down to pressure vote Blazade
4. Celever - voted tiger but eh i voted tiger i dont think its unreasonable. but im not as good a mafia player so a bit sus ig? dunno
5. Ehmcee - towny
6. HydrogenHydreigon - towny, frankly could/should be town leader
7. ImaginaryNeon - neon
8. Jalmont - has he posted??
9. pulsar512b - hi im me
10. realiti - seems to be playing like he did last game as mafia. might be my imagination but he was more chill in popcorn where he was town, maybe something?
11. Rostam - not a lot of info either, if saying i was wrong early gives any towncred he deserves the most for being the first and not just jumping on the bandwagon
12. skippergamez - hasnt posted idt?
13. Tigershark/genius1 - see above, townlean?
14. UncleSam - doesnt feel like much of substance tbqh
15. ZippyDoo200 - making wild reads that i think are way too strong and weird but thats zippy ig. doesnt really feel mafiay to just say people are town out of the blue?

 

[ImaginaryNeon]

Blazade, Unclesam, Rostam all seem pure town.

Bookmarked this, forgot to actually record it.

 

[realiti]

10. realiti - seems to be playing like he did last game as mafia. might be my imagination but he was more chill in popcorn where he was town, maybe something?

This read is so troll btw

 

[Ehmcee]

Kinda zonked rn, don't have a ton of stuff on my mind, might drop some thoughts l8r

 

[pulsar512b]

This read is so troll btw

yeah maybe im misremembering but it seemed like you were doing more town leadering in the game where u were scum

 

[realiti]

I've given so many reads, do you have anything to comment on any of them pulsar512b

 

[ImaginaryNeon]

wait how do we vote ? will there be a form or is the bolded vote (user) binding

The "Vote _" is how you vote but you can change it at any point during the day.