-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Smogon Mafia Mafia (Won by the Mafia)
- Thread starter imperfectluck
- Start date
I agree, although he's done some things earlier in the game that I feel scum wouldn't do? hard read
There aren't that many scum in this setup, and imo they haven't been acting coordinated or I'd have been seeing signs of it by now, so that pushes things more into PoE for me. What I do see is a lot of people independently reading or not reading the thread and shooting from the hip.
4 is a decent amount imo but I agree with the rest of your post
Whats going on?
Question, do you read past games, it seems you know some Meta about some players
Idk, you tell me. I've got 1.5 hours until I can game.
curious why Blazade is now town and I'm in "the rest", last time you commented on us it was both of us moving to town IIRC
there basically isn't a way that Rostam doesn't get voted out today, but I feel in my bones that Rostam is getting framed here. I think JALMONT's Rostam read was memorable because it was the first read of the game he gave and it was against the grain p hard, so I think a scum team shooting JALMONT to frame the newbie is a play that quite a lot of scumteams in this game would do anyway tbh. and then the role was martyr and they basically got 7s on the slots.
I think it's apparent that most people, scum included, didn't even notice Jalmont's post until I pointed it out. Even I didn't notice until I looked back at the beginning of D2. If I'm wrong I'm prepared to face any scrutiny for it, but I stand by my read of the situation.
I also think it's apparent that Rostam fits the profile of a likely mafia player based on the game flow, he's active and reading the thread but slightly careful in his posting style.
Does Indie know who 3p is
This bitch needs to die
TBF, if it was an intentional frame and you're town, optimal play is to feign not remembering the read's existence once it's brought up by you because it distances the scum players from the act of framing Rostam (once Rostam flips town if that happens). I did remember the post TBH, I didn't remember that Rostam's name was specifically bolded or anything, but I hard mentally noted that JALMONT scumread Rostam out of the blue toward EoD.
I mean I'm more partial to this but there are definitely scummier players in the game that could be voted. Rostam I could see being scum based on posting style especially because there was a great D1 entrance and then quality and quantity of content has sort of gradually declined (though again, I actually like their most recent posts here).Blazade said:
Basically I think you're the only one who, as scum, would think of the Jalmont kill as a frame on Rostam in this spot (because I know you and I have differing logic on such things). Like, it's such a weird line. Rostam wouldn't exactly be in danger of being lynched because I wouldn't really believe that scum Rostan kills Jalmont for being the one guy to cast side eye on them, it's basically only a martyr flip that would convince me and no one would have known that.
Again, it comes back to probabilities. You're treating the Jalmont kill like this "standard" line and then the martyr flip is them getting lucky. I'm just not seeing it.
Again, it comes back to probabilities. You're treating the Jalmont kill like this "standard" line and then the martyr flip is them getting lucky. I'm just not seeing it.
Who do you think is scummier in a vacuum and why?
TBH all of AG, zippy, Hydro, Sam, and maybe some others I switched to phone so not looking at player list.
Rostam is a very neutral slot to me but in a vacuum I still townlean them I think