NOC Charge Me Up! Mafia GAME OVER MAFIA (psy, Laurel, af) WINS!

joey said:
who claimed VT lol I genuinely don't think I've seen a single claim besides Laurel's which came well after your posts
Click to expand...
If I reeled them off I’d be revealing which vts I believe and based on threadstate mafia aren’t mindmelding with me on that lol

might look em up at PC but I mean you could do that same thread searching so probably not
 
I just searched VT and the only VT claim I see is my "btw I'm VT" post that came immediately after my post saying "I think it would be stupid for VTs to claim"
 
Psypsypsypsypsythe said:
to me theres just a lot of scummy people, and then outside of that theres a lot of gaps in the pl. etay/joey/tiger/night escape my scumpool because what would i even have available to place them in there based off of? etay like sole post is saying hes town, joey has engaged but felt like an extreme non presence, tiger has selective reading and was here and responding but only to a handful of posts that tried to engage with them, ignoring the rest and not saying anything of significant value, and then night like seems to be doing his best but it doesnt change that we really cant read him at all or at least i have no idea what to do with him
Click to expand...
if you have 9 scumreads I'd re analyze
 
joey said:
NightEmerald - I still think the entry is kind of weird, coming in as a new player and immediately placing a vote off of what seems like very little information. Nothing else they've said/done gives me indication of town or scum so I'm just keeping this as a very slight scumlean.
(
Click to expand...
Fair enough about me, I just immediately voted since I do not know how to read people and I saw there was a majority, that being said, forgot to do it earlier but I’m gonna
unvote
vote Laurel
 
joey said:
I ordered these from least strong to most strong

NightEmerald - I still think the entry is kind of weird, coming in as a new player and immediately placing a vote off of what seems like very little information. Nothing else they've said/done gives me indication of town or scum so I'm just keeping this as a very slight scumlean.

Celever - It seemed weird to me at the beginning that he was making assumptions off of "claims so far" when there were literally no claims. That doesn't necessarily mean scum but it feels to me like he was just making stuff up to sound insightful/involved in the game but not add pro-town content.

pulsar - Feels like pulsar has done a lot of fishing for information and that kind of raises red flags for me. Suggesting a mass claim at the start is the biggest red flag. Then wanting the Friendly Neighbour to expose themself (which, honestly I'm not sure if this is actually a good idea or not so maybe don't count this). Then from there they scumread Laurel and then backpedaled the scumread but wanted to vote Laurel as a "safe vote" instead. I know opinions can change and I'm kind of grasping at a straw with this one but idk just reads weird to me.

Ehmcee - Did not like the thing at the beginning about getting VTs to come out. I feel like any outcome of that happening just puts information into the hands of the mafia that town doesn't really benefit from. And then after that I don't feel like they've really contributed anything. It's early and I probably need to see more posts from them but this is where they are in my mind for now.
Click to expand...

think this is towny from Joey
 
The wagon on me is pretty bad. The only one who feels towny on it is maybe Tommy.

Tommy - Psy pressured me about “not caring” which is the only reason I elaborated. So while I think your argument is fair it’s not like I have actively been “leaning into it” as I believe you said.

Let’s actually be productive and find scum.

I think Realiti is within his town meta, so is Psy (to a lesser degree I think he is slightly less chaotic but maybe he’s just learning) I do think a fairy is ghosting the thread which she always does, Celever hasn’t tried much yet either with strikes me more as town thats not hard committed one way or the other — I think mafia celever tries very hard to fake town.

NightEmerald is new and I said i’d give them the benefit of the doubt but that vote is really bad and just looks like taking advantage of an opportune “wagon” and pulsar is just tunneling me at this point.

I’m inclined to say 1/2 or 2/2 is scum. Pulsar only scum read me after I said their massclaim idea was bad which was a pretty lousy FOS.
 
Laurel said:
The wagon on me is pretty bad. The only one who feels towny on it is maybe Tommy.

Tommy - Psy pressured me about “not caring” which is the only reason I elaborated. So while I think your argument is fair it’s not like I have actively been “leaning into it” as I believe you said.

Let’s actually be productive and find scum.

I think Realiti is within his town meta, so is Psy (to a lesser degree I think he is slightly less chaotic but maybe he’s just learning) I do think a fairy is ghosting the thread which she always does, Celever hasn’t tried much yet either with strikes me more as town thats not hard committed one way or the other — I think mafia celever tries very hard to fake town.

NightEmerald is new and I said i’d give them the benefit of the doubt but that vote is really bad and just looks like taking advantage of an opportune “wagon” and pulsar is just tunneling me at this point.

I’m inclined to say 1/2 or 2/2 is scum. Pulsar only scum read me after I said their massclaim idea was bad which was a pretty lousy FOS.
Click to expand...

I feel like even before you were obviously softing it to anyone who knows you, so even if you didn't actively claim half the game knew you were softing vt so you might as well have claimed
 
Laurel said:
NightEmerald is new and I said i’d give them the benefit of the doubt but that vote is really bad and just looks like taking advantage of an opportune “wagon”
Click to expand...

i’m sorry but what? I literally was one of the people at the start to propose a vote on you, literally last night. The only reason I changed now was because I got caught up in something else and forgot. Sorry you feel that way about me, but let’s get the timeline straight.
 
26 Fucking Ground Types.jpg
 
Laurel said:
I think Realiti is within his town meta, so is Psy (to a lesser degree I think he is slightly less chaotic but maybe he’s just learning) I do think a fairy is ghosting the thread which she always does, Celever hasn’t tried much yet either with strikes me more as town thats not hard committed one way or the other — I think mafia celever tries very hard to fake town.
Click to expand...
i feel like this is all out of wack and i dont really understand it. what is realitis town meta vs scum meta in your eyes because to me theyre virtually the same and its near impossible to tell what realiti is based on posting outside of certain tells he may give that i havent seen yet so far. fairy is usually better than this as either alignment tbh. like i think the inactivity is more likely to come from scum because shes self meta'd herself in such a way in the past but like idk why shed suddenly take a drop here when even when shes played scum shes actually played. idt she normally ghosts the thread at all and i feel like thats way off base

celever definitely tries to be tred but it doesnt mean him tryharding means hes more likely to be scum. celever usually has big gaps in his presence when hes scum that are more noticeable that when hes town which im feeling here
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top