NOC Charge Me Up! Mafia GAME OVER MAFIA (psy, Laurel, af) WINS!

[Tommy]

I think we do laurel first. celever has a chance of being combative town but I feel pretty confident about laurel flipping scum.

he's not really trying to scumhunt, a lot of his posts read like he's trying to appease whoever he's replying to without contributing new thoughts, he briefly acknowledged our scumreads but isn't trying to clear himself + just doing the bare minimum to skate by. he also had a string of defensive posts d1 and reverted back to being passive d2 so it felt like an act. and the d1 vote makes me think tiger was voted off to save laurel because I can't imagine 6 ppl being town and genuinely thinking tiger was the best vote

who do you think laurels partners are that voted to save him then?

 

[Tommy]

day 1 i would’ve told you both are scum but now pulsar feels more scummy than emerald does.

i liked emeralds interaction with psy. that seemed towny to me.

so how does that fit in with your theory that mafia voted celever to frame him?

 

[realiti]

who do you think laurels partners are that voted to save him then?

celever +1, I need to look back at the vc

 

[realiti]

this isnt even true im the only person who called out fairy, i said why the IPL spot is town, i have theorized about the mafia intent, i have posted full reads on every player. Idk if you’re just ignoring me or what.

I only saw your post with 4 reads before you went back to work

 

[imperfectluck]

the d1 vote makes me think tiger was voted off to save laurel because I can't imagine 6 ppl being town and genuinely thinking tiger was the best vote

I think you and I should have the best knowledge on tiger for obvious reasons and that's why I'm lynching Celever first since he defended his lynch of tiger so adamantly.

 

[realiti]

IPL - This slot seems town to me. Also skipper subbing out despite existing, maybe mafia encouraged him to stay? I like IPL’s general approach and I think we’re mindmelding over setup mechanics being frustrating.

joey - i still think that this is town but his day 1 was better than his day 2 he hasnt contributed that much to this point

Tommy - NAI idk what’s going on here i didn’t have tommy vs celever on my 2023 bingo card but i want to say that tommy is town because idk if mafia parks a vote on me and goes to sleep 6 hours before deadline.

Psy - kinda same as Joey

more to come

this one

 

[realiti]

I think you and I should have the best knowledge on tiger for obvious reasons and that's why I'm lynching Celever first since he defended his lynch of tiger so adamantly.

I agree celevers vote was bad and he's my 2nd preferred vote

 

[realiti]

laurel who do u think the scumteam is and whats your read on celever

 

[Laurel]

so how does that fit in with your theory that mafia voted celever to frame him?

i have retracted this theory as i believe its more likely if they did triple charge it would be on a much newer player eg etay emerald etc

 

[Tommy]

i have retracted this theory as i believe its more likely if they did triple charge it would be on a much newer player eg etay emerald etc

ok I missed that sorry

Celever have you retracted that theory yet?

 

[Celever]

ok I missed that sorry

Celever have you retracted that theory yet?

Partly but also not really, the fact that people aren’t claiming their charges en masse is making it far harder

Based on who’s claimed, perhaps the theory doesn’t work. The main way I think it would work was if Laurel open wolfed and outed the theory his own team executed, which I’m not ruling out.

but I still think circle charging is outright the worst strategy mafia could do, so if the view is they either circle charged or threw all their charges on town / on scum and then I still think the latter is likelier. Certain things so far haven’t added up and I’m inclined to believe that at least one person has lied about their charge target already, although I also think the one I have in mind is prob town motivated lie and the second possible lie probably isn’t

 

[Celever]

All in all after Emerald’s showing yesterday his towncred has superseded the fact he voted for me in my mind and that is basically the only effect of the vote stacking belief being pealed back anyway, the importance of it was overstated

 

[Celever]

Anyway, I wanna know why imperfectluck put Emerald in my faction yesterday I was drunk and didn’t care to think too deeply about it but that still bothers me today, don’t think it adds up

 

[Celever]

Contrary to that post I’m pretty sure I know what @NightEmerald’s role is and he shoulder holster tonight

 

[Celever]

NightEmerald ^

 

[imperfectluck]

Anyway, I wanna know why imperfectluck put Emerald in my faction yesterday I was drunk and didn’t care to think too deeply about it but that still bothers me today, don’t think it adds up

Because my first interaction with NightEmerald was him attacking me although he's since retracted that, and also because he has pulsar as scumlean while I townlean her

 

[Celever]

Because my first interaction with NightEmerald was him attacking me although he's since retracted that, and also because he has pulsar as scumlean while I townlean her

So the factions were only really based on you and pulsar? Guess that makes some sense given you only gave reads on me and her yesterday IIRC and said you were undecided on everyone else lol.

Do think it misses out a lot of stuff though, namely that when you made the faction list me and Emerald were scumleaning each other lol

 

[Celever]

I.E. I think you can barely call me and Laurel a faction since we seem to be the only people who townread both of us LOL

Which is because I think this game’s narrative is 100% being controlled by the scum but yeah

 

[Celever]

Basically if I’m right about Laurel I feel like that post was priming town to fall back into Emerald today, and then be like “oh well he was the least linked of that “faction” anyway we should still vote out Celever or Laurel”

IPL and Emerald have T/M eq imo

 

[realiti]

I.E. I think you can barely call me and Laurel a faction since we seem to be the only people who townread both of us LOL

Which is because I think this game’s narrative is 100% being controlled by the scum but yeah

who do u think is scum then

 

[Celever]

I hate the tinfoiling in my mind tho cos my town playstyle is “solves or nearly solved the game D1” or “plays anti-town the entire game” and I’m not confident which one is happening here but I’m pretty sure it’s the first LOL

 

[Celever]

who do u think is scum then

Tommy, pulsar, IPL has 1-2 scum in it, the third is harder to gauge

 

[Celever]

Someone is doing a good job of deepwolfing but I think there’s a 65% chance they do that by lying bout mech and getting found later

 

[Celever]

Tommy, pulsar, IPL has 1-2 scum in it, the third is harder to gauge

The alternative is Laurel, a fairy, Joey, Ehmcee, and realiti have 2-3 scum in it

That’s the universe where I’m playing anti-town

 

[Celever]

Particularly a fairy, Ehmcee, and realiti, since those are tone + style + content, the Laurel and Joey townreads are much more solid