he basically soft claimed his first post (or near it) in the game, then later full claimed d1
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Charge Me Up! Mafia GAME OVER MAFIA (psy, Laurel, af) WINS!
- Thread starter JALMONT
- Start date
he basically soft claimed his first post (or near it) in the game, then later full claimed d1
i have been saying this omg. if youre mafia friendly neighbor you literally can only visit the kill target because it burns your charge and makes you appear towny without actually having to reveal your role
cant have been a bus driver. i wouldve seen 6 actions on n2 instead of 5
yeah there's actually no world mafia picked friendly neighbour, if joey was mafia, it's just he fakeclaimed that and is another role, in reality though it's most likely he is just town though
cool, none of the other roles make sense really either as mafia to be on emerald while mafia is killing emerald I feel so his friendly neighbour game is most likely real
which also means joey bossed the fuck up with his early reads in his first town game
idk i dont think its a clear but it doesnt matter for today because like
vote laurel
vote laurel
whats the alternative iyo? where joey is mafia?
also ftr if laurel is scum here it SUPPOSEDLY is never tommy because ALLEGEDLY he never busses (even though he definitely found a loophole in this during smalltown) but idk i dont think hed go this hard against laurel if they were partners for a few reasons
you think Joey's not cleared you said right, but I'm wondering what the situation is where joey is mafia, like mechanics wise what was he doing on emerald?
honestly if its not laurel i have no idea what to do like hope i just get killed so i dont have to think about it anymore tbh
tbf my role is I don't bus, moreso than I don't get bussed, but i also don't get bussed 95 percent of the time
the categorical never rule though is me doing the bussing
he has to do something with his role right? so if hes mafia he goes onto night, who he knows is going to be killed and cant report results back to town the next day, and given how town responded to realiti the previous day, he can assume the mere act of taking friendly neighbor and using it will give him free town points
I'm pretty sure laurel is just mafia though
yeah but you will also anti spew your teammates so like the rule applies to your intention but it doesnt necessarily apply to the outcome
i mean yes
yeah but he picked his role after he got alignment, why would mafia ever be friendly neighbour? the only way he could be mafia imo is if he lied about his role, then you still gotta ask what role he would've been using though, if not friendly neighbour
we just fundamentally disagree on whether or not mafia would pick friendly neighbor. i dont see any reason why its any more off the table as a choice than any other role in the list. or like no i understand why you and others doubt it but i also think its wrong and its a reasoning that can be exploited by mafia
it kind of does, but I don't expect you to agree in this moment in game, and it's probably not relevant here anyways since my push on laurel has been a pretty consistent desire to get him flipped
like the fact that weve treated friendly neighbors as clears without actually having the mechanics from the role pretty much proves my point imo
fair enough, we can agree to disagree but I do think it is severely unlikely, even if possible, that joey would select a role that tells someone his alignment as mafia
maybe, but it's playing so hard into the wifom that I wouldn't expect mafia, especially first time mafia to actually go through with it tbh
i dont really see it as wifom? and its not just joey making these decisions either. like the whole team is choosing what to do pregame so i dont feel like you can cite joeys inexperience as a reason he wouldnt go for it
There's room for one mislynch so I think the final three who I would vote for are Ehmcee/Hydro/Laurel here. Psy acted townie to me by waiting for my claim before reporting his mystic results and a mafia mystic would be trying to push someone harder I think. Only reason why I'm not hardcore reading Psy townie is because a fairy voted to charge him.