Oculars said:Who remembers a few months ago when people were saying how Darkrai is so "clearly broken" and "uncheckable" that we shouldn't even discuss unbanning it in here. Who remembers even longer back in gen8 natdex when they spent well over a year talking about how its z move sets kill everything and its also a clear uber just for it to be so mid it dropped to UU after we finally tested it. Blaziken was so overhyped in gen8 it started ubers while things like magearna and zygarde were legal.
:sv/metagross-mega: :sv/Roaring-moon: :sv/darmanitan-galar:
Learn from the past and apply it so in the future when these guys come up for consideration, dont overhype them on paper, actually hold the suspect and see how they actually play out in the context of a real game. Maybe some of them are broken (roaring moon imo might be) maybe some of them are no better than solid B rank mons.
People might look at darm g and immediately think of it as possibly overpowered but all things considered our megatame is way faster than last time it was around so scarf base 95 isnt some absurd speed tier, its not fast enough to revenge most setup sweepers even while lacking priority. Its also easily scouted and checked even the choice band sets by the most common pivot in the meta :alomomola:and is rediculously suceptible to hazards and helmet chip. The band sets are hard to wall if they click the right buttons but this is no different then other strong choice locked breakers in the exact same speed tier like tapu lele and banded urshifu R . The absence of also having a setup/taunt set thats viable like urshifu and lele have makes gdarm probably even easier to manage in the builder. Yes theres sub BD salac berry sets but these are super easily telegraphed and you can see it coming on team preview 9 times out of 10.
TL:DR its better to actually test down mons then to theorycraft in the calculator and write them off as broken.
I think there is a good chance we could try and start suspecting some mons in Ubers that are sadly stuck in limbo. If Darkrai of all mons look balanced in OU, im pretty sure that we could bring other mons to relevancy. Still, we shouldn't get carried away, as there could be some mons that end up broken even to this day. Now, i would like to give my toughts on the mons u mentioned to potentially be tested:
:metagross-mega:
This one doesnt seem to be that much of an issue on paper. The biggest selling point is that its a decently fast wallbreaker with electivire like coverage. 110 speed is basically the new standard in the current metagame, and its likely to stay this way. 145 atk do is a bit scary, especially adding its Tough Claws ability, which boostes all moves that make contact by 1.33. It also has a stellarbulk in 80 hp, 150 def and 110 spdef, which means it isnt an easy mon to wear down. These are all excellent , but it has some flaws. For 1 it doesnt have reliable healing, meaning that it be worned down over the course of a game. However, this can easily be fixed by slotting the good ol Alomomola, which just goes in almost evetything. This could bring a potential problem, as it can be able to heal Mega Metagross constantly, and the two synergize pretty well, Mola can block Fire attacks for Mega Metagross, an Mgross can take on Grass moves aimed at mola, while both having good bulk on their own. Mola does the support and Mgross does the bashing. Another issue with Mmeta is the 4 move syndrome, you want to be able to hit as many mons for super effective or at last neutral damage, meaning against the proper defensive core, it could struggle to hit if it doesnt have the proper coverage. And it can still be hard walled by certain mons, like everyone's favorite physical wall, Dondozo.
252 Atk Tough Claws Metagross-Mega Thunder Punch vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Dondozo: 152-180 (30.1 - 35.7%) -- 35.1% chance to 3HKO
Overall, im still a bit mixed baged about Mega Metagross, but i would for sure like to give it at least a suspect test.
:Roaring Moon:
YES, ABSOLUTELY YES, BRING IT SO THAT I CAN DESTROY EVERYONE WITH MY SUN TEAM AND WATCH THE WHOLE WORLD BURN.
Absolutely no bias aside, Roaring Moon is also a mixed bag fo me, as it would be a pretty good mon with or without Sun. It is a solid Dragon Dancer, with 139 Atk and 119 speed, it could outspeed a ton of mons after a single boost. It does have decent options in its moveslot, like Earthquake, Stone Miss, U-turn, Iron Head if u want to hit Fairies, Acrobatics for Booster Energy sets, Fire Fang if u want to use it under sun, and of course Knock Off. Knock Off alone can change the viability of certain mons, just look at Mega Tyranitar, from almost unseen to a solid mon in the meta overall. An sure, it has a quad Fairy weakness, but u know what else it has? Terastalization, so it can change to Tera Steel, no longer fearing fairies nor Toxic, or even Tera Fire to avoid burns. Im not soo confident on this one, if I were to choose between Mega Metagross an Roaring Moon, I think Meta Metagross would be the one I would give the suspect test, but I would give one to Roaring Moon, even if it ends up terrorizing the ladder for 2 weeks.
:Darmanitan-Galar:
Well u alteady gave a good explanation on GDarm, which i could agree on. Altough that same mon u mentioned that can wall it canalso support it with Wishpassing, but thats just Mola doing Mola things. It is a very powerfull mon, but it does require good positioning to use effectively, similar to Gen 3 Slacking in a way. Still not sure if its a good idea to leave it around, after all, it is a 140 atk mon with a Choice Band attached, and it could have a Scarf or 2 Bands. Probably the most broken looking of the 3. All 3 of these could use a suspect test, and i would like to see how people go and deal with these guys