Venuesaur said:no one is saying that amoonguss or smth is a problem
i am.
i dont like sleep in general, ive already explained my reasons for why i believe it has no place in a competitive space in the views from the council thread, but to elaborate further: being forced to either have gholdengo/hatterene/garganacl/a grass type as a switch in (one of which gets clobbered by giga drain, two others of which get clobbered by sludge bomb) is restrictive on teambuilding, and if you dont do that you sacrifice something to sleep, in other words clicking spore is just a free KO (and lets not act like sleep isnt basically a KO because it is, youre not burning sleep turns unless youre incredibly ahead). it doesnt matter which pokemon gets an instant sleep move, its gonna do work regardless.
not to mention, the sleep clause mod is no longer welcome under our tiering policy, so we might as well just get rid of it and ban instant sleep moves regardless. we're not gonna have unrestricted sleep, and we're not gonna keep sleep mod. if we were to allow literal mods just to nerf a broken mechanic, why not mod every broken mechanic just to allow them back? nerf every uber's stats, make it so ohko moves only work once, make it so baton pass can only pass one buff at a time - oh, wait, we already tried that, and it didnt work, because guess what? the mechanic was a problem in and of itself. same with sleep.
and people keep acting like its only darkrai that is a problem, when it really isnt. darkrai was just the straw that broke the camels back for inciting discussion on sleep; its always been an uncompetitive, cheap, luck-based, semi-viable (or fully viable, in the case of spore) strategy. and no, we're not keeping sleep just so we dont nerf certain pokemon, or else we wouldve kept baton pass just so we didnt nerf all the passers.
spore is just marginally less uncompetitive than hypnosis/sing/grass whistle due to the reduced RNG factor, but that is reduced - not removed, and while being a lot more certain to counter, it is a lot more powerful. and, well, ive also given my reasons on why i dont think yawn is nearly as problematic as the instant sleep moves. i have yet to see anyone counter the arguments i made in the views thread for a sleep ban
(though perhaps thats on me since i stopped reading after a while), but if you disagree with either this post or that one, please do make your opinion heard, thats what the forums are for anyway.