NOC 16P Role Madness Mafia (CANCELLED)

actually i think they came up in a couple group theory hws tho that was more of a 'hey heres a descriptor of a group figure out what it is' sort of thing
 
can you give the 5 second pitch for m2h being scum other than:
annoying
pushing massclaim
besides those, she has literally made the wrong push at every single avenue today. I save you from the nightkill (or, I mean, I thought I did and probably still did???) and she's like "pulsar and Cel are just scum together then". the a fairy and me situation happens and even though both of us are saying "this is not a 1v1 there are loads of things that could have gone on here" M2H is like "NO THIS IS A 1V1 WE MUST KILL THE TOWN'S PROTECTION! RALLY, TROOPS, TO CASCADE UPON THOSE WHO CAN KEEP US ALIVE!!" and it's like :pikuh: this ain't really solving.
 
m2h continues to go "oh that's a possibility" (or just ignoring them) and then pretending there's a for-sure scum btwn cel and i. and he's willing to sacrifice 2 protective roles to get it

this should alarm anyone

There are seven options I can think of

1. host error moot point, game is bastardized anyways
2. mafia have a strongman kill
3. neon is a silent scum!roleblocker and targeted specifically celever
4. celever is scum and fake-claimed bus drive on pulsar/saber, and just killed saber.
5. NightEdge/a fairy are both scum and the BG didn't happen.
6. there is a town PGO and saber visited them, both NE and celever's actions were effective. massclaim solves for this
7. there is a town (unlikely)/scum safeguard that targeted pulsar, removing both celever and a fairy's actions. this is about as plausible as a SM kill, but less likely from a setup perspective.

I think 2, 3, and 4 are the most plausible. I don't think a 1 for two trade makes sense from mafia perspective. I think you dislike the 1v1 solve because you town read celever and dislike me for the massclaim, when this mech solve is actually p likely. I think celever is against the idea of a 1v1 because it just isn't in his interests as scum. This is not a 1v2 that he ever wins. He always goes first (because if its wrong, we get two scum anyways), and it just never goes well for him.
 
besides those, she has literally made the wrong push at every single avenue today. I save you from the nightkill (or, I mean, I thought I did and probably still did???) and she's like "pulsar and Cel are just scum together then". the a fairy and me situation happens and even though both of us are saying "this is not a 1v1 there are loads of things that could have gone on here" M2H is like "NO THIS IS A 1V1 WE MUST KILL THE TOWN'S PROTECTION! RALLY, TROOPS, TO CASCADE UPON THOSE WHO CAN KEEP US ALIVE!!" and it's like :pikuh: this ain't really solving.
ok yeah agree
vote M2H
 
ok yeah agree
vote M2H
oh I didn't even mention the Emerald thing where she was HARD pushing that a JOAT having a one-shot that's also just a town player's role is outright impossible.

It isn't. It's common.

Whenever I pointed that out she just didn't even reply to me, too. And then repeated the point, sometimes to me, and then I repeated myself and she didn't reply to me again.
 
oh I didn't even mention the Emerald thing where she was HARD pushing that a JOAT having a one-shot that's also just a town player's role is outright impossible.

It isn't. It's common.

Whenever I pointed that out she just didn't even reply to me, too. And then repeated the point, sometimes to me, and then I repeated myself and she didn't reply to me again.
this is fun internet discourse innit
 
I still think M2H is the best vote here and mafia might just have extra kp ftr.

The indie had no extra kp, it's fully within the realm of possibility. Everyone would assume that the extra nks were from the wolf which throws solving off a bit and probably makes a non-lethal indie a slightly more viable role in the game. Vig doesn't really do that; if anything the power level of this game with us having a 3-shot vig makes this almost an auto-lose for the indie

Do mafia really have multiple kills, and a strongmanizer ._.
 
Back
Top