Recent content by Gondre19Wedj

You realize that there were no actual tier shifts this month, right? We're now at the stage in which shifts happen every three months. So Tink and Pecharunt are still here and Deo-S is still OU. These will just be projected shifts if usage stats are consistent for the next couple of months until...

???? VGC doesn't have a usage limit? There was one ruleset during the pandemic years in which the top 10 Pokemon in the singles and doubles ladders were banned, but no major tournaments happened at the time. The whole point was to just create something different for people to play and wasn't...

I wanted to touch on Volcarona, however, because of my place in the player base and my inability to get reqs (and unwillingness to improve to do so?), it feels disingenuous to post in the suspect thread. So, I'm not going to wait for the suspect thread and post some preliminary thoughts here...

Friendly reminder to give UU Iron Treads again s'il vous plait merci :) In all seriousness, since Arch left and rain has become a lot less common, has Iron Treads been seeing any use? I haven't played OU for a bit, so I don't actually know its status.

A large point that I know Finch has been stating is that we can’t truly predict what will happen after a ban in the tier, so there’s not much point in doing so. Instead, it may be better to take a pause after a ban to see what happens. In regards to weather, it’s true that sun will likely become...

I haven't seen anyone respond to this, so even though it was a few pages back, I do want to bring it back up because, at the end of December, I asked Finch this during his Office Hours. The following is his response: Hopefully this response can be brought back up if anyone else has a similar...

I literally laid out why your post was bait. At this point you’re arguing in bad faith and not willing to hear me out, so I will not be continuing the conversation if you reply. I hope you’re having a good day and have fun in the community. Best of luck

Reread my first reply, I explained it there why your question came off as antagonistic. I’m sorry if I hurt your feelings, but disregarding an argument that you disagree with EVEN THOUGH it is clearly outlined in tiering policy as a goal of the Smogon “institution” is being counterproductive to...

You’re the one trying to vilify people arguing for cart accuracy, and as one of those people, I don’t appreciate it

If you kept reading, you would’ve seen that I did answer it. As for your point about knowing how much you did affecting decisions, it’s kind of irrelevant for 2 reasons: 1. Everything is a role. If you do 50% one turn, you can do 48% the next and they can live. If you gauges your damage range...

This is a trap question designed to invalidate the opinion of anyone who answers it in your eyes: either we commit all the way for the sake of cart accuracy and agree to get rid of a QoL change that people would be upset about removing, turning public opinion against us, or we pick and choose...

Because, frankly, if sleep mod could be replicated on cart, I would actively be working to keep it on PS. I think it does a pretty good job maintaining sleep balance. However, because it is different, my buddies that I do play cart with have to make rules for balancing. Some of my friends prefer...

I do want to respond to you as a "cart purist." In my mind, the reason this is bad is because, fundamentally, we are playing Pokemon. And, at the end of the day, we don't make the rules of Pokemon. Sure, we can decide that we will play a singles match with up to 6 Pokemon, but we can't decide to...

Writing as a cart purist, I absolutely agree that sleep needs to change. It is tiering policy that we strive to make the game as accurate to cart as possible. Therefore, if anyone is dismissing the "cart accuracy" argument, I interpret their thoughts as wanting to change tiering policy, which is...

My goodness. The :Ninetales: disrespect is so real. Is it really that bad? Is Sun without Torkoal that bad here in RU?