December 2024 Tiering Survey Results
Competitiveness and Balance:
5.95/10
Enjoyment:
6.95/10
The numbers are slightly down from what they were in October, though the council consider the enjoyment numbers to still be within acceptable parameters. We are satisfied with the playerbase enjoying the current metagame. Competitiveness and balance is always a controversial one, and we have taken steps, which will be mentioned down below to try and alleviate the issues that the playerbase is having. Despite slightly above average competitiveness and balance, players
do enjoy the current meta so that's all we are hoping for.

Jolteon
3.05/5
In regards to the responses given for Jolteon, over half of the voters wanted some sort of tiering action and 9/20 of the voters wanting a Jolteon suspect. The council took initiative and decided to hold a vote on Jolteon whether to quickban it or suspect it and with a resounding 7 members voting for a quickban, Jolteon was subsequently quickbanned and replaced by Carracosta. We understand that 30% of the voters thought Jolteon was balanced but as explained on the Discord, Jolteon really lacked consistent checks, with only one ground type in the tier and two electric immunities, one being itself. It was quite constraining on the builder and Calm Mind and Choice Specs sets could overwhelm many teams. Overall, we believe we made the right decision for the health of this metagame and we are excited to see how Carracosta will function going forward!

Lokix
3.3/5
Lokix has even more people that believe it to be unbalanced versus the just banned Jolteon! In terms of these statistics, the council held 2 votes. One to quickan
and one to suspect Lokix and Lokix did not receive sufficient support for either action to occur. Hopefully, the upcoming tournament will give us enough to see if Lokix really is too much for the tier or not, though it is unlikely Lokix will have tiering action towards it unless something drastic happens and the playerbase turns on it so council to consider re-voting on it.

Chandelure
2/5
The vast majority of the voters believe Chandelure is balanced in the current metagame, and we will not be taking any action on Chandelure for now.
Finally, we had an open question at the end of the survey to ask the playerbase what they would like to see suspect tested.
- 9 people wanted a Jolteon and Lokix suspect test. Jolteon was quickbanned and there was not enough support in the council to suspect Lokix.
- 7 people didn't want a suspect at all.
- 1 person wanted a Chandelure suspect.
- 1 person wanted a Milotic suspect.
- 1 person wanted to quickban Jolteon then see how Lokix is in a post Jolteon metagame.
- 1 person was 50/50 on "no suspect" and a Jolteon quickban, citing it's too late for another suspect test.
It's always interesting to see how everyone has differing opinions on the metagame. The council will continue to tier accordingly and produce the best meta we can have possible.