NOC E.G.O Wielders Mafia - A 17P Role Madness (Game Thread) - MAFIA WIN

[StupidFlandrs48]

HydrogenHydreigon vc pls

 

[StupidFlandrs48]

I don't agree with this take at all

Why is that?

 

[NightEmerald]

CrreamyKitty get the fuck in here or ill hex you as i die th

 

[joey]

##Vote: Evie

I need to remember the format better

 

[apricity]

Wis being town makes the wis/ne interaction make perfect sense to me

yeah except wis has also been hard defending NE

 

[M2H]

EVIE IS HERE IM COUNTING ON YOU TO PRESS THEM SINCE YOU WERE THE WHOLE REASON THIS TURNED INTO A WAGON

Idk what you expect me to do bud

 

[Evie]

Goofy ahh role, something tells me that's not fake

if ne was scum, could they not claim a role that is quite unordinary so that they dont get cc'd, +WIFOM so they wont get called out for having an unordinary role as shown with you

 

[NightEmerald]

Idk what you expect me to do bud

FINE ILL DO IT MYSELF

 

[joey]

Why is that?

It seems like it would function fine as a mafia role to me, with the bonus that Mafia have a bit more information about where actions are going

We don't really know the power level or situations of any other roles in the game so far so it seems fair enough for me

Plus it doesn't even have to be real but . There's just not enough info to take anything solid from that claim

 

[NightEmerald]

can you at least reiterate your major sticking points on evie m2h

 

[StupidFlandrs48]

if ne was scum, could they not claim a role that is quite unordinary so that they dont get cc'd, +WIFOM so they wont get called out for having an unordinary role as shown with you

1. NE is too angy this game to have that level of imagination
2. WIFOM can be an argument for just about any interpretation of a claim/flip/read/whatever and I'd rather not get bogged down in that.
3. I don't scumread NE independently of this claim.

 

[NightEmerald]

id like those addressed before we blow them up

 

[joey]

I don't think NE was being pressured enough to actually justify a claim as mafia or town so I feel like that just came from a point of frustration which like, well, here we are

 

[NightEmerald]

1. NE is too angy this game to have that level of imagination
2. WIFOM can be an argument for just about any interpretation of a claim/flip/read/whatever and I'd rather not get bogged down in that.
3. I don't scumread NE independently of this claim.

You’re underestimating me but like, thanks i guess

 

[M2H]

can you at least reiterate your major sticking points on evie m2h

literally responded to celever and Flanders votes on her by piggybacking hals celever case and pushing a celever/Flanders scum team, weird defensive posturing towards fairy and fear of being pocketed by fairy joey but very consistently defensive of hal.

 

[wisteriapurple]

ok well my questions come from the fact that i swear hal posted this exact line of thinking earlier

and this just makes m2h's case on evie's treatment of cel ring in my head

found it

Why did NE's confidence in his read on you not come off as unfounded to you in this game then? At no point in time did you say "well it's weird that you're THAT confident in your read on me when you're 0/2 in our t/s games"

except its flipped to sr ne more(?)

 

[M2H]

Also town: NE wisp joey neon skipper AP (if hal is town)

 

[Evie]

1. NE is too angy this game to have that level of imagination
2. WIFOM can be an argument for just about any interpretation of a claim/flip/read/whatever and I'd rather not get bogged down in that.
3. I don't scumread NE independently of this claim.

for the wifom point i agree, my argument was moreso that a scum wont get immediately pointed out for claiming an unordinary role

the rest of the points are fine but to me theyre not enough to justify not voting for ne

 

[wisteriapurple]

##vote: evie
sue me i buy the claim

idg why ne/myself HAS to be one pocketing the other we've found each other as town before as well

 

[StupidFlandrs48]

I don't think NE was being pressured enough to actually justify a claim as mafia or town so I feel like that just came from a point of frustration which like, well, here we are

As someone who has definitely claimed prematurely before, that tends to ping +town for me when the player in question is consistently prone to frustration under pressure

 

[joey]

As someone who has definitely claimed prematurely before, that tends to ping +town for me when the player in question is consistently prone to frustration under pressure

I unfortunately agree with this

 

[NightEmerald]

for the wifom point i agree, my argument was moreso that a scum wont get immediately pointed out for claiming an unordinary role

the rest of the points are fine but to me theyre not enough to justify not voting for ne

It’s frankly unordinary i basically don’t have a role in a role madness game and ill only get one if i win a guessing game with the host on the ways actions can fail

But this is all dodging the question: when i flip town, what then

 

[Evie]

i might as well claim now but i dont think itll make a difference

im doctor except it fails if anyone else targets my target

 

[NightEmerald]

never mind evie’s a good vote

 

[apricity]

Oh jesus christ.