Personally I think this post is really weird, just based on vibes tho
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
Popcorn Mafia 4 - Cycle 3 Deadline August 23 at 10PM EDT
- Thread starter Aura Guardian
- Start date
Well I have god reads shoot me later when there’s enough content for me to know who the scum are
Nah mostly I’m getting kinda bored of being the default scumread every game it’s becoming too much of a pattern now lol
I get what Celever is saying though why are we letting one person dictate the thread with one post ijbol
You think I'm dictating the thread?
That does not look like the reaction of a town to me, I've stated my perspectives on things but hardly interacted with people otherwise. Why as town would you feel pressured by my assessment of celever or suggestions on how to approach the game? This reads like a scum team uncomfortable by the thread direction stepping in to try and shift the narrative winds.
They posted during confirmation phase and are just always like this as town
you don't think everyone's saying "sure shoot Celever" after you posted because of your post?
I don't think skipper was making any kind of accusation there but if you don't think you caused it that's a strange lack of self-awareness lol
Originally I wanted bluedoom to get shot but his recent posts are quite good. Pulsar also looks better. Evie seems good.
Skipper and Clouds seems scum. Skipper has no passion and chaos in his posts, big red flag. Clouds popped in to give level 1 reads that seems very safe & I dont even think AP is that towny (he is null for me ATM). Shoot Skipper before Clouds tho.
ShyPebble also seems scum, the AirC joke has run its course and it feels like mafia awkwardly trying to play a persona to avoid making real reads.
Agree that Celevers last posts were not good.
Skipper and Clouds seems scum. Skipper has no passion and chaos in his posts, big red flag. Clouds popped in to give level 1 reads that seems very safe & I dont even think AP is that towny (he is null for me ATM). Shoot Skipper before Clouds tho.
ShyPebble also seems scum, the AirC joke has run its course and it feels like mafia awkwardly trying to play a persona to avoid making real reads.
Agree that Celevers last posts were not good.
AngryPidgeon what was your strong opinion on skipper?
fwiw the way to break this game IMO is to just, not put all your reads in the thread until you have the gun
it limits scum's strategic opportunity because they can't try to push the gunman to shoot someone who has bad reads, because they don't know what the reads are yet
which is boring gameplay but
it limits scum's strategic opportunity because they can't try to push the gunman to shoot someone who has bad reads, because they don't know what the reads are yet
which is boring gameplay but
I like how three people scumread skipper on the same page for three entirely different reasons
skippergamez do u have any reads rn
skippergamez do u have any reads rn
Yeah I don't think Texas is dictating the thread by any means. Maybe I'm biased because he made a helpful post towards me specifically though lol
I kind of disagree with the above Celever post if I'm reading it right. I think waiting until you have the gun to give your reads isn't a good idea, because when you have the gun and say your reads if even one of them is wrong the maf can try to steer you in that direction, and there's a good amount of them in this game so the train of influence or whatever you want to call it can build quickly.
In fact, I think it's probably best to keep reads close to your chest the whole game until a good amount of maf are eliminated for that very reason.
I kind of disagree with the above Celever post if I'm reading it right. I think waiting until you have the gun to give your reads isn't a good idea, because when you have the gun and say your reads if even one of them is wrong the maf can try to steer you in that direction, and there's a good amount of them in this game so the train of influence or whatever you want to call it can build quickly.
In fact, I think it's probably best to keep reads close to your chest the whole game until a good amount of maf are eliminated for that very reason.
right, but the mafia are going to steer whoever has the gun regardless. why get influenced early in addition to when you hold the gun. and why also give mafia information about the best places to steer the gunman towards
- mafia member who picked hh
probtowning des from saying "Hi" "Hello" and "Yes [I am Town]" is crazy talk
This bait is a bit suspicious to me
I don't think this is necessarily wrong but it also completely removes pressure on people so I feel like we need to push people to not actually do thisfwiw the way to break this game IMO is to just, not put all your reads in the thread until you have the gun
it limits scum's strategic opportunity because they can't try to push the gunman to shoot someone who has bad reads, because they don't know what the reads are yet
which is boring gameplay but
To expand on this we're definitely going to end up in scenarios further on in the game where someone has a gun and doesn't know what to do with it, and if there are no established thread reads at that point it will be really hard for them to narrow it down. Especially since everyone will start pushing them with ulterior motives at that point
I do actually think this is very much what a mafia member says after they were outspoken in scumchat on who to pick and want to gain themself some towncred
I agree and it’s possible but a fairy makes posts like that as town too lol
“Wow why would mafia do this”
