Okay so.. the game is fun, like it genuinely is fun, the battle system and the way Mega Evolution has been handled is incredibly smooth and I really hope aspects make it into the next game, the way that items proc in battle and things of that nature make it more smooth and if they are keeping the traditional system for Gen X, I would like to see those things implemented as they are good QOL changes IMO.
I'm not going to go into much detail on the graphics, for the most part I guess they're "okay". Textures are grim and SV beats it by a mile, at least SV doesn't look as if we're just sticking on a door with no depth / dynamic.
So the setting of Lumiose is somewhat interesting, I wish there was a little bit more to it and utilised more effectively, PLA took inspiration from BOTW and I can see bits of TOTK being shown here through the verticality of the game. But I wish the Sewer system was more complex and had more to it, I knew we would never get the full catacombs or anything, but the Sewers with maybe a few links to it / hidden rooms, even some areas leading to outside Lumiose (but would still be considered Lumiose, like the outskirts etc) just to add a bit more flourish to the game.
I don't think it was a total misfire, but a bit more to it would've been very beneficial. I get the DLC is seemingly adding a "new" map, but we shall see.
The characters are next, and alongside the general plot of the game, is probably my biggest issue. Legends is meant to showcase the overall world they have built, PLA set a good precedent with having obvious ancestor links and even characters from the "present" and setting up a genuine unnerving villain who is linked to probably the most beloved human character in the series. So many iconic moments to pull from and to build on and to add new life to.
PLZA did.. essentially none of that. Emma and Mable were genuinely pleasant surprises but that seems to be it? Lysandre doesn't really do anything other than act as Zygarde's translator, given how much trauma and damage he caused, there doesn't seem to be too much resolution / understanding to this. I haven't finished anything in the post-game, so this could come to fruition, but so far I am just seeing someone who was seemingly dead in XY and now he's back but is now exceedingly good?
AZ I did like, and his ending was genuinely lovely as well as a bit sad.
Team MZ were fine but so underdeveloped, why didn't we get to spend any specific time with Lida and Naveen? I think some sort of relationship mechanic could've been beneficial in this game, but eh, maybe that's my recent obsession with Clair Obscure talking. Lida is obvi a relation to Tierno, which is a nice nod, and Naveen is speculated to either be related to Grant or Cyrano but nothing of that is confirmed, Naveen's introduction on the official website states he is shrouded in mystery but we don't ever get to find out why or what he's about outside of being a streamer fanboy and into fashion.
I do not see the point in Jett.. like at all.. she appeared 3 times in the story but she was officially announced prior, which leads you to think she'd be influential across the game and she isn't? I spoiled myself on her being the rival's Grandmother due to being genuinely perplexed that I finished the game and she hadn't done anything at all. Not even a battle. Quasartico weren't really the overarching big-bad we thought they'd be either.
Team Flare Nouveau was a bit of.. nothing, again, an opportunity for further characters to return, why use the old villainous team but not have them represented through known characters? Mable being the Professor but nothing for Aliana, Bryony, Celosia or Xerosic? No returning Gym Leaders, not even Clemont / Korrina? Alexa? No Elite 4 cameos? No Diantha? Looker? Sycamore? Malva? There is absolutely no reason why they couldn't have incorporated more of Kalos' lore / characters into this game, given how dirty XY was done.
The new characters are fine, but so underbaked it's hard to get into most of them. Canari could have easily been Bonnie. Ivor could have been a relation to Korrina with her stepping in when he gets too much. Gwynn not being a relation to Shauntal was a missed opportunity too.
I personally think Volo should have been the villain and the overarching villain for the Legends series, what better testament to the strength of a well known character (Cynthia) to have their ancestor ruthlessly hunting down the legendary Pokémon and jumping through time?
The Plot / Features of the game also are very underutilised. The Plot was a bit.. nothingy.. Rogue Megas were fun (and hard at times!), but that seemed to be it? The incorporation of the ZA Royale is fun, but again in the postgame it seems like such a missed opportunity to bring in legacy characters.
The side quests are boring for the most part, there's nothing to them other than to gain items. You aren't helping out established characters with anything and learning more about them. Where were the individual side stories for Team MZ? Where are the Detective cases side stories for Emma? Given we have the Rust syndicate, Team MZ, Team Flare Nouveau, Fists of Justice etc I would've liked to have seem some sort of Faction plot too? This is a huge, huge city, of course there are going to be gangs and crime and egos and things like that.
The entire game being marketed on the "Redevelopment of Lumiose" when in reality this was simply just adding holographic barriers to already established locations. Why wasn't anything changing overtime? Why weren't we able to develop the Wild Zones to add further Pokemon, similar to SV with the biomes? The Dex is too small, having around 300-350 with DLC adding an extra 50-80 would've been nice, I get these games aren't quite full scale but still.
The game is fun, again, I just want to reiterate that, and I haven't fully completed the post-game yet, so there could be more and the DLC could also answer a lot but there is such a disappointment to the content and what the game truly could have been. People will probs disagree maybe, fair enough, but I was expecting so much more given how immersive PLA was. (Although that had similar issues)