-
Smogon Premier League is here and the team collection is now available. Support your team!
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Everchanging Mafia - Game thread - Night 4!
- Thread starter Alice Kazumi
- Start date
- Status
Oh that’s sick congrats on the consolidation
Sounds hectic ahah that’s a lot of relationship milestones in a short space of time
YEAH I wish we could be engaged for longer!! But we've been together for so long that it's like, doesn't make a huge difference really. Idk if I will still consider him my fiancé while we wait to have a "proper" wedding. I think the allure of "Husband" will be stronger lol
Wheatus was good btw
Wheatus was good btw
Here comes the greatly expected readlist by the likes of BlizihGuh and idk who else called me out for only talking of ECat when d1 I was very pushy against a lot of other people, it just happened that ECat throwed day 1 and I had to be the one to remind everyone that throwing is bad
This readlist is special, instead of scenarios or whatever I was doing last 2 games I dont have much time, so I'll give my views about everyone and detail what I think about them
1. LonelyNess - LonelyNess is a weird scenario, they initiated by generating discussion about how the game could develop, but after this he went silent, he has an excuse the excuse of capitalism but I think this could be interpreted like Pebble's strategy last game, where she made coherent posts early on with a lot of cohesion and opportunity for discussion, but went silent afterwards and defended herself by saying that she was busy with new years. At the end of the day she ended up being mafia, but id like to listen more to what LN has to say, although his recent posts havent been that good.
2. A fairy - AFK alert number 2, I actually like what fairy has been doing in the thread, while being busy she has made up effort to generate discussion and talk, the problem I have with her ways is how she is generating discussion but not accusing someone per say, Yesterday I said how I dont like people being neutral, yesterday she wasnt neutral at all. But now its like she doesnt have anyone on her suspicions list? It sounds like how a mafia would look at the game, her read posts sounds as she analyzing the game, but not specifying any reasons for any of them.
4. phoopes - We like doctors, who doesnt love doctors. I read up somewhere that whoever you think was doctor is probably mafia but mafia being scared yesterday by killing larry shows a bit of fearfulness mechanically on the doctor, like yeah phoopes could've killed Larry to gain the towncred afterwards by killing a "non target". But I dont dislike the posts they make a lot.
5. vishy fishy - Making this readlist is making me see how like the first 6 on the playerlist could be mafia, I cant say anything that hasnt already been said, their posts sounds like noobmafia trying to figure the game out, in general they just look confused on what to do and retreats very quickly when confronted, this could be a fearful mafia but I think it will be made obvious later on so I wouldnt vote them today.
6. des121 - The whole argument des has about not being mafia is that her reasoning for not being mafia is dumb enough for me to believe that she isnt mafia, who knows. Maybe she adapted after reading what happened last game, like we'll ever know. But she seems like active enough to answer doubts, which is like a lot better than some in this list?
7. Dead by Daylight - I dont have that much suspicion of DBD, ECat passed his mayor role to him so im looking at a world where ECat and DBD arent scum together and honestly I dont think that's happening?? He's mostly afk so we will have to hear from him more.
8. Miyami~~~ - I had to ISO Miyami to see the suspicious they're saying about her, I kinda get it? But I dont think there's a lot to go from, her accusing vishy at the first opportunity that she got or following the ECat wagon so fast, but I dont really scumread her atm
9. pulsar512b - Honestly I will just copypaste, Inactive for most of day 2, while playing as town they usually just go inactive Day 1, posts that are just nothingburgers while not showing commitment to the game, in other town games they've showed more entusiasm to reading the whole thread and supporting fact based arguments, while today they claimed "ecat vote felt horrible" and "i have such bad vibes"
10. Evie - Evie feels fine, they're contributing to the thread enough and her play just looks like every other 1 day that happened on the last games, which resulted in her dying n1 and being town. I like their arguments and I wouldnt vote someone contributing to the town this much in Day 2, specially considering how many AFK's we've got.
11. AirC - He's tunneling so hard in that my mech doesnt work but honestly it works I aint gonna lie, but yeah their arguments dont seem like mafiaposting to me, just different points of views, nothing more to say.
12. Celever - Same with Evie, but Celever got more doubts from me than Evie since he just could be Mafia posting well enough, but as I said with Evie, I am not going to vote out someone who's contributing to the town this much in Day 2.
13. Westcraft - Newbie who asked a lot of questions, I like their dedication, could be enthusiast mafia trying to gain towncred, he's also not had a lot of contributions since then, but I dont think a Mafia would reveal what everyone thought incorrectly about the mayor
15. ElectricityCat - You can see like any other post I made today to see my argument
16. Blizihguh - I dont dislike her posts, as I said with Celever and Evie, someone contributing to the town this much isnt getting my vote day 2. Even if their arguments differ from mine, having different perspectives about things sometimes helps more than harms.
17. Genisu - AFK, Not much to say, not much to contribute. I feel like Genisu posts more as town and all of his posts that I've seen (I've not isoed him) were him trying to defend himself.
WHO WOULD I VOTE FOR (from the least to the most)
Evie
Celever
AirC
BlizihGuh
WestCraft
Dead By Daylight
Phoopes
Miyami
Genisu, Des, Vishy, LonelyNess
Pulsar
A Fairy
ElectricityCat
This readlist is special, instead of scenarios or whatever I was doing last 2 games I dont have much time, so I'll give my views about everyone and detail what I think about them
1. LonelyNess - LonelyNess is a weird scenario, they initiated by generating discussion about how the game could develop, but after this he went silent, he has an excuse the excuse of capitalism but I think this could be interpreted like Pebble's strategy last game, where she made coherent posts early on with a lot of cohesion and opportunity for discussion, but went silent afterwards and defended herself by saying that she was busy with new years. At the end of the day she ended up being mafia, but id like to listen more to what LN has to say, although his recent posts havent been that good.
2. A fairy - AFK alert number 2, I actually like what fairy has been doing in the thread, while being busy she has made up effort to generate discussion and talk, the problem I have with her ways is how she is generating discussion but not accusing someone per say, Yesterday I said how I dont like people being neutral, yesterday she wasnt neutral at all. But now its like she doesnt have anyone on her suspicions list? It sounds like how a mafia would look at the game, her read posts sounds as she analyzing the game, but not specifying any reasons for any of them.
4. phoopes - We like doctors, who doesnt love doctors. I read up somewhere that whoever you think was doctor is probably mafia but mafia being scared yesterday by killing larry shows a bit of fearfulness mechanically on the doctor, like yeah phoopes could've killed Larry to gain the towncred afterwards by killing a "non target". But I dont dislike the posts they make a lot.
5. vishy fishy - Making this readlist is making me see how like the first 6 on the playerlist could be mafia, I cant say anything that hasnt already been said, their posts sounds like noobmafia trying to figure the game out, in general they just look confused on what to do and retreats very quickly when confronted, this could be a fearful mafia but I think it will be made obvious later on so I wouldnt vote them today.
6. des121 - The whole argument des has about not being mafia is that her reasoning for not being mafia is dumb enough for me to believe that she isnt mafia, who knows. Maybe she adapted after reading what happened last game, like we'll ever know. But she seems like active enough to answer doubts, which is like a lot better than some in this list?
7. Dead by Daylight - I dont have that much suspicion of DBD, ECat passed his mayor role to him so im looking at a world where ECat and DBD arent scum together and honestly I dont think that's happening?? He's mostly afk so we will have to hear from him more.
8. Miyami~~~ - I had to ISO Miyami to see the suspicious they're saying about her, I kinda get it? But I dont think there's a lot to go from, her accusing vishy at the first opportunity that she got or following the ECat wagon so fast, but I dont really scumread her atm
9. pulsar512b - Honestly I will just copypaste, Inactive for most of day 2, while playing as town they usually just go inactive Day 1, posts that are just nothingburgers while not showing commitment to the game, in other town games they've showed more entusiasm to reading the whole thread and supporting fact based arguments, while today they claimed "ecat vote felt horrible" and "i have such bad vibes"
10. Evie - Evie feels fine, they're contributing to the thread enough and her play just looks like every other 1 day that happened on the last games, which resulted in her dying n1 and being town. I like their arguments and I wouldnt vote someone contributing to the town this much in Day 2, specially considering how many AFK's we've got.
11. AirC - He's tunneling so hard in that my mech doesnt work but honestly it works I aint gonna lie, but yeah their arguments dont seem like mafiaposting to me, just different points of views, nothing more to say.
12. Celever - Same with Evie, but Celever got more doubts from me than Evie since he just could be Mafia posting well enough, but as I said with Evie, I am not going to vote out someone who's contributing to the town this much in Day 2.
13. Westcraft - Newbie who asked a lot of questions, I like their dedication, could be enthusiast mafia trying to gain towncred, he's also not had a lot of contributions since then, but I dont think a Mafia would reveal what everyone thought incorrectly about the mayor
15. ElectricityCat - You can see like any other post I made today to see my argument
16. Blizihguh - I dont dislike her posts, as I said with Celever and Evie, someone contributing to the town this much isnt getting my vote day 2. Even if their arguments differ from mine, having different perspectives about things sometimes helps more than harms.
17. Genisu - AFK, Not much to say, not much to contribute. I feel like Genisu posts more as town and all of his posts that I've seen (I've not isoed him) were him trying to defend himself.
WHO WOULD I VOTE FOR (from the least to the most)
Evie
Celever
AirC
BlizihGuh
WestCraft
Dead By Daylight
Phoopes
Miyami
Genisu, Des, Vishy, LonelyNess
Pulsar
A Fairy
ElectricityCat
Clearly you were never a Teenage Dirtbag (baby)
Who is one of them?
Hello des, any thoughts about the current state of thread?
Ok, I am FINALLY caught up and I'd like to Unvote and Vote Vishy Fishy
I don't buy the "vote lots of people and see their reaction" strategy as +town. To me it reeks of throw darts at a dartboard hoping that something might stick and a roll forms. Which means I guess simultaneously I'm townreading all of their targets so that's what
DBD / Ecat / Peum / Miyami (forgive me if i'm missing anybody)
I don't buy the "vote lots of people and see their reaction" strategy as +town. To me it reeks of throw darts at a dartboard hoping that something might stick and a roll forms. Which means I guess simultaneously I'm townreading all of their targets so that's what
DBD / Ecat / Peum / Miyami (forgive me if i'm missing anybody)
I'm kinda of still confused about one of vishys votes and I'm a Lil bit furious at blitz
Just trust me that if you're town it will turn out okay
I am town and not mayor
- Status