should've probably spoilered the post but w.e
-
Smogon Premier League is here and the team collection is now available. Support your team!
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Everchanging Mafia - Game thread - Day 5!
- Thread starter Alice Kazumi
- Start date
never change genisu
Am I wrong in thinking vishy voting for me is what the kids call an "OMGUS"? Does that not reinforce my scumlean? I don't know if omgus'ing is town coded or scum coded... it feels the latter. Someone more familiar with NOC please tell me the meta?
Reinforce my scumlean on vishy, specifically, not "my" scumlean.
OMGUS, at least to me, is NAI
as far as the difference i feel like you just arent like. as invested or as defensive even
Very important to decide if I'm voting Pulsar or you ElectricityCat
Did you make your readlist very shortly to have some content to post or did you actually double check the info in it? If you did can you send the post that would lead you to believe what you wrote about? (Not necessarily about me, about anyone on the readlist).
Did you make your readlist very shortly to have some content to post or did you actually double check the info in it? If you did can you send the post that would lead you to believe what you wrote about? (Not necessarily about me, about anyone on the readlist).
omgus is nai until a case is made for why its scummy or towny, for a new player like vishy i dont think its really scum indicative
Before I leave for class I just want to establish a town/scumcore kind of.
Right now my top town reads are Westcraft and Peum (des is here too)
Westcraft I'd just like to see you post more reads or posts that states your opinion because even if the info posts are helpful and they are what leads me to townread you they're not really advancing the game at all.
Peum is just really driving the thread forward, and despite our differing views on some points I can't think of a way he'd be doing that this way as scum.
Ecat is in the middle of it all, and I'll make my choice depending on how he answers #1659.
I don't really want to argue about it rn so I'll wait for that
Vishy is leaning further and further into scum territory, having random, confusing posts is not that important as first but it's getting worse and worse as the game goes on
I don't like how the Pulsar flashwagon went, and I think it's indicating that something is wrong here, even if it was TvT I assume some scams would have attempted the flash wagon just to confuse how EOD was going. There's still a way that scums were just afk but that seems like way unlikely
I need to leave for my classes so the ones not in this readlist are not necessarily neutral, just I don't have enough time and a strong enough opinion of their slot
Right now my top town reads are Westcraft and Peum (des is here too)
Westcraft I'd just like to see you post more reads or posts that states your opinion because even if the info posts are helpful and they are what leads me to townread you they're not really advancing the game at all.
Peum is just really driving the thread forward, and despite our differing views on some points I can't think of a way he'd be doing that this way as scum.
Ecat is in the middle of it all, and I'll make my choice depending on how he answers #1659.
I don't really want to argue about it rn so I'll wait for that
Vishy is leaning further and further into scum territory, having random, confusing posts is not that important as first but it's getting worse and worse as the game goes on
I don't like how the Pulsar flashwagon went, and I think it's indicating that something is wrong here, even if it was TvT I assume some scams would have attempted the flash wagon just to confuse how EOD was going. There's still a way that scums were just afk but that seems like way unlikely
I need to leave for my classes so the ones not in this readlist are not necessarily neutral, just I don't have enough time and a strong enough opinion of their slot
Celever literally said "this is the fishiest flashwagon of all time" or smth, then you ninja'd them with a vote, and they were like "I was ninja'd but my opinion is not changed" lol
Also, can we agree that words have meaning:
1. It's not parroting if the person you're allegedly copying is also something they allegedly didn't say
2. It's not parroting to say "this person is 100% confirmed town so I trust their opinion"
I didn't say "vishyfishy is 100% confirmed town," I said "vishyfishy is obvtown to such an extent that I am suspicious of people who claim otherwise"
One last thing Evie. You say this:
But let's look at the posts you're talking about:
Saying "I dislike Bliz's chainsaw defense of ecat and the logic feels untowny to me" is like, barely scumhunting. Like seven people have already said the first half of that, and the second half is basically meaningless. Saying you're scumhunting because you said something everyone else has already said is like going to a steakhouse and claiming you shot a buffalo. And if "their logic feels untowny to me" counts as scumhunting, then well, "Evie feels untowny to me." There, I got you. Look how hard I'm trying to find scum, you guys!
Posting a POE is not much better when your POE is just "these four people are scum because I said so." When I say "Evie is not scumhunting" I don't mean "Evie has not accused anyone of being scum." What does that prove? The reason I'm trying to look for people scumhunting is that most people have trouble pretending to look for scum when they themselves are scum. If scumhunting was just posting a list of four people you claim are scum, then any mafia player could scumhunt by just copy pasting from the signup post.
If you're town, and reading all that and thinking, "how am I supposed to find scum, I can't just look at peoples' posts and tell if they're scum," then I dunno what to tell you. You're playing a game with three power roles and two of them don't even provide info. It is kind of what you signed up to do.
More or less, yeah. The thread was dead and I had things to do over the weekend. I just wanted to post something. I did look up LN’s posts and read them since he was first on the list; I did the same with A fairy and Peum. For the rest, I mostly based it on looking at the votes and what I remembered from memory, because I didn’t have much time left.
The post got some interesting reactions lol, pretty entertaining.
I think you’re right, I’ll try to make it better next time.
Rather than quibble over vibes, let's start voting some people based on voting history and whether they're in the chain of role history.
Blizihguh, phoopes and Peum have all proven misvoted a villager twice now. phoopes is in the chain of known role history, so let's pick between Bliz and Peum. My natural inclination is Bliz because he started the roll on Flandrs. But I'm willing to entertain that both Peum and he could both be mafia, especially since Peum heroically leapt to save him at the last second yesterday on the absolutely random Miyami roll.
Blizihguh, phoopes and Peum have all proven misvoted a villager twice now. phoopes is in the chain of known role history, so let's pick between Bliz and Peum. My natural inclination is Bliz because he started the roll on Flandrs. But I'm willing to entertain that both Peum and he could both be mafia, especially since Peum heroically leapt to save him at the last second yesterday on the absolutely random Miyami roll.
Oh i should probably put a placeholder since deadline is in only a couple hours
Vote Blizihguh
Vote Blizihguh
Every time I get airc mafia vibes they makea very townie post and then I think they’re town but then they make a post that seems very mafia to me
Alice Kazumi could I/we have a votecount pls idk who is voting for what