NOC Everchanging Mafia - Game thread - Day 5!

[Peum]

It would also make no sense to target A fairy if mafia was doing this strategy, accusing someone like DBD or Phoopes would be a better idea

 

[a fairy]

between someone widely townleaned and someone widely scumleaned we're always going to vote you out

if i ever roll scum w/ you in the game ill keep this in mind. i hope you're scum bc saying this while scum isn't losing anyone this cycle is a huge fumble as one of town's more vocal players

 

[Peum]

if the strategy is planning to take us to MYLO and force a mislynch throwing a mafia for someone widely scumleaned is not a good play

 

[a fairy]

It would also make no sense to target A fairy if mafia was doing this strategy, accusing someone like DBD or Phoopes would be a better idea

you just explained why it's a good strategy

 

[a fairy]

if mafia have mayor tomorrow and they successfully kill another town tonight have we lost? does someone have that math

 

[Peum]

you just explained why it's a good strategy

No, In a LYLO situation we would always vote you out someday, while throwing DBD or Phoopes under the bus makes it so that Town has to gambit more

 

[Peum]

if mafia have mayor tomorrow and they successfully kill another town tonight have we lost? does someone have that math

its a 6v4, they would get 5 votes and 6 votes would be the hammer iirc

 

[Evie]

its a 6v4, they would get 5 votes and 6 votes would be the hammer iirc

chat this is why you dont no vote d1

 

[Westcraft]

We have 12 rn, we'd have 10 at the start of tomorrow, meaning we're always fine if we shoot wrong tonight and you guys know to vote me out. I guess there's a slim chance I'm misunderstanding my role, but I think I've covered for everything.

 

[Westcraft]

chat this is why you dont no vote d1

Yeah, mayor would make that a tie. Fair enough.

 

[a fairy]

so then they hope on someone to vote bad and hammer
town be careful about your scumreads when i flip town and someone dies tonight cycle

 

[des121]

I'm on for questions or anything

 

[Peum]

Yeah I guess all a fairy can do after being redchecked is appeal to emotion

 

[Peum]

When is the "if u vote me out you lose" happening

 

[Westcraft]

If a fairy turns town, that is my fault as a town for throwing the game, and it is in all of your guy's best interest to shoot me then and there.

 

[a fairy]

love to be talked about as if im a child that can't understand what the adults are saying

 

[a fairy]

hope y'all dont let peum lead you off a cliff

 

[Peum]

love to be talked about as if im a child that can't understand what the adults are saying

I mean I wasnt talking to you but to let the other towns know what strategy would mafia do in this scenario

 

[Westcraft]

love to be talked about as if im a child that can't understand what the adults are saying

Sorry, I'm talking as if you're already dead because I don't see any way that it doesn't happen. Maybe I shouldn't talk as if it's so certain, but that's how I see it right now.

 

[a fairy]

I mean I wasnt talking to you but to let the other towns know what strategy would mafia do in this scenario

"if a fairy was mafia she'd be doing all of these things she's not currently doing"
"hey im still here"
"not talking to you, mafia"

 

[Peum]

"if a fairy was mafia she'd be doing all of these things she's not currently doing"
"hey im still here"
"not talking to you, mafia"

Its a pretty well documented move by mafia. In the words of a random mafia page I found on google:

"An appeal to emotion is a particularly devious sort of fallacious argument, particularly in a game of unknowns such as Mafia. "If you eliminate me, you'll lose!" is an easy example, but there are many others, played by both/all factions in most games at some point. The nature of the game lends itself to appeals to fear or hope or trust.

This tactic is in general very effective against people who are not aware of it. As such, deploying it in a Mafia game with experienced players tends to backfire, as they'll be aware that you're trying to manipulate them, behaviour which is more typically seen coming from scum than from town."

 

[a fairy]

i know what ATE is lol. im saying i am not doing it

 

[Peum]

Yeah im just letting vishy and des know

 

[des121]

Vishy is afk

 

[Peum]

how much is hammer btw Alice Kazumi