NOC Everchanging Mafia - Game thread - Day 5!

Peum · 2026-01-28T15:19:01-0500

AirC said:
I was tracker last night and tracked West

why would you track west

Peum · 2026-01-28T15:19:07-0500

most useless action of all time

AirC · 2026-01-28T15:19:08-0500

Idk if he's scum or not but he is guard

AirC · 2026-01-28T15:19:23-0500

Peum said:
most useless action of all time

I mean if he dies I know who killed him

Peum · 2026-01-28T15:19:44-0500

We only track west if there's 1 mafia left they're not giving him the kill

Peum · 2026-01-28T15:19:55-0500

AirC said:
I mean if he dies I know who killed him

You did this Westcraft

AirC · 2026-01-28T15:20:03-0500

No but if they wanted to kill him

Peum · 2026-01-28T15:20:26-0500

AirC said:
No but if they wanted to kill him

Westcraft had the same missconception yesterday, you only see the abilities used on him, not the people that visit him

AirC · 2026-01-28T15:20:52-0500

Peum said:
Westcraft had the same missconception yesterday, you only see the abilities used on him, not the people that visit him

Oh

Peum · 2026-01-28T15:21:08-0500

AirC said:
I'm currently really sick so won't be able to be as active as before, why did we hammer yesterday?

I dont like stalling so we just went with it, not much we could gain anyways of a day with a free vote

genisu · 2026-01-28T15:22:05-0500

s

Peum said:
(Westcraft isnt confirmed so he gets a lightly darker shade of green)

Votecount EOD 1

StupidFlandrs48 (7): Blizihguh, Miyami~~~, phoopes, des121, peum, Westcraft, a fairy
Lonelyness (2): Laurel, vishy fishy
no vote (2): pulsar512b, Dead by Daylight
a fairy (1): evie
Dead by Daylight (1): LonelyNess
des121 (1): StupidFlandrs48
Miyami~~~ (1): Airc
phoopes (1): Celever
pulsar512b (1): genisu

Not voting: ElectricityCat

Votecount EOD 2

Miyami~~~(6): vishy fishy, Blizihguh, phoopes, ElectricityCat, Celever, Peum
Blizihguh (5) Dead by Daylight, a fairy, pulsar512b, Evie
vishy fishy (3): Miyami~~~, des121, LonelyNess
ElectricityCat (1): Westcraft
pulsar512b (1): Airc

Not voting: genisu

Votecount EOD 3

pulsar512b (5): peum, AirC, Evie, phoopes
Blizihguh (5): genisu, Lonelyness, des121, a fairy, Dead by Daylight
evie (3): Blizihguh, ElectricityCat, vishy fishy
Dead By Daylight (1): pulsar512b

Not voting: Westcraft

Votecounte EOD 4
A Fairy (7): Genisu, Evie, WestCraft, Peum, Vishy, Phoopes
WestCraft (1): A Fairy

Not Voting: AirC, ElectricityCat, Des121, Dead by Daylight, Pulsar

so what have u gleaned from this? i dont see much of anything of note

Westcraft · 2026-01-28T15:23:47-0500

Peum said:
You did this Westcraft

My bad. I'm asking about this for sure rn.

Peum · 2026-01-28T15:24:00-0500

genisu said:
s

so what have u gleaned from this? i dont see much of anything of note

Pulsar was never on the winning vote
DBD is weirdly passive with his votes
Blizih wagon cant be trusted
Evie pushed A Fairy day 1
Day 1 flandrs was majtown

Peum · 2026-01-28T15:24:30-0500

By the way, now that we're in the lategame, is there a downside on revealing who current tracker is?

Westcraft · 2026-01-28T15:25:41-0500

Peum said:
By the way, now that we're in the lategame, is there a downside on revealing who current tracker is?

A little bit? It means we're playing WIFOM every night. We don't get the info from tracker if they're dead.

Peum · 2026-01-28T15:25:43-0500

We have 2 heavily towncored players, putting a target on tracker makes mafia have to distract from actually killing the towncored players and makes it so that Mafia cant gatekeep the tracker role by having them reveal themselves the same day

genisu · 2026-01-28T15:25:51-0500

the downside is they get shot no?

Peum · 2026-01-28T15:26:39-0500

Like the problem is that mafia can gatekeep the tracker role if they actually get it in their hands by how we are playing now

Westcraft · 2026-01-28T15:27:13-0500

The downside is the tracker could get shot. Also the towncored players could have tracker and that just puts a very large target on them; not that this is exclusively a bad thing.

Peum · 2026-01-28T15:27:15-0500

genisu said:
the downside is they get shot no?

yeah, but then the towncored players get to not die

Peum · 2026-01-28T15:27:31-0500

Westcraft said:
The downside is the tracker could get shot. Also the towncored players could have tracker and that just puts a very large target on them; not that this is exclusively a bad thing.

That's why we have a doctor

genisu · 2026-01-28T15:28:19-0500

Westcraft said:
The downside is the tracker could get shot. Also the towncored players could have tracker and that just puts a very large target on them; not that this is exclusively a bad thing.

who do you think is towncore besides yourself?

Peum · 2026-01-28T15:28:27-0500

genisu said:
who do you think is towncore besides yourself?

Me I am

Westcraft · 2026-01-28T15:28:42-0500

Peum said:
That's why we have a doctor

Exactly why it's not exclusively a bad thing.

Peum · 2026-01-28T15:29:12-0500

If I didnt put such a big target on A Fairy then tracker wouldnt have tracked a fairy on the day she killed