-
Smogon Premier League is here and the team collection is now available. Support your team!
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Everchanging Mafia - Game thread - Day 5!
- Thread starter Alice Kazumi
- Start date
a fairy
At this point we have too much information id say, what matters now is the votecount
Tracker D1 is assumedly mafia, so that would make one of Des or WestCraft obligatory townies, and assuming that Mafia didnt use their only pass D1, Des would also be Town
But this would mean that Laurel voluntarily gave Tracker to Des
Anyways if you'd like to make use of our time make a readlist of every player
I think my solve atm is pulsar/one of ecat or dbd/vishy
I’m willing to take westcraft, peum, and des as conftown at the moment
After we vote pulsar today, im thinking about who we should vote, and if there is guaranteed one scum in ecat/dbd
Assuming pulsar flips town, if ecat/dbd is t/t, then the remaining options are airc/genisu/vishy. Is this a coherent scumteam? To me not really but it is theoretically possible.
Assuming pulsar flips scum, then it is two of the above three, which to me would be airc/vishy.
So maybe vishy is the vote tomorrow honestly
I’m willing to take westcraft, peum, and des as conftown at the moment
After we vote pulsar today, im thinking about who we should vote, and if there is guaranteed one scum in ecat/dbd
Assuming pulsar flips town, if ecat/dbd is t/t, then the remaining options are airc/genisu/vishy. Is this a coherent scumteam? To me not really but it is theoretically possible.
Assuming pulsar flips scum, then it is two of the above three, which to me would be airc/vishy.
So maybe vishy is the vote tomorrow honestly
Yeah sure
Towncore:
Peum
Westcraft
Des - I dont think either town laurel passes tracker to des or mafia use their one pass on d1; to me town!des is who mafia would pass tracker to. This idea actually supports the idea of ecat scum since they would not have known to pass mayor to laurel to keep it and instead passed to dbd who they think will make a bad vote.
Likely Town:
Genisu - the interaction with fairy was just so damn unpairing
AirC - has been playing like town!AirC all game, def less towny then genisu to me but still towny and shouldnt be voted anytime soon
Potential Scum:
Dbd - most likely unpaired with ecat
Vishy - weird behaviour all game but new so kinda black box; not incredibly scummy but has done absolutely nothing to justify towning them and so has to go in the PoE
Probable Scum:
ElectricityCat - I kinda convinced myself of scum!ecat when talking about des honestly
Pulsar
Dropping a readlist without any info before I go to sleep, will actually develop on it tomorrow if I'm not too sick anymore.
(Tiers are mostly not ordered)
Towncore :
Westcraft
Peum
Townlean :
Evie
Des
Genisu
Scumlean :
Ecat
Scumcore :
Vishy
Pulsar
DBD
I haven't ordered shit inside the tiers btw, will also do that tomorrow
-----------------------
Cool post to highlight, This post was also made before I scumleaned A Fairy and no one was pushing her so she didnt feel that much pressure to WIFOM this, But I would guess there's still some present
What A Fairy's readlist pushes
Town -
Peum, Phoopes, Vishy Fishy, AirC, Celever, WestCraft, Genisu
Town?? I really dont know what these are supposed to mean -
ElectricityCat, Blizihguh,
Scum -
LonelyNess, Des, Evie
Scum?? -
Dead By Daylight
No opinion
Miyami, Pulsar
Some that stand out
Vishy - Goes in circles to declare that they're town
Pulsar - Doesnt really give anything
ElectricityCat - Same as vishy, doesnt instantly declare that they're town but are suggesting that he isnt
Dead By Daylight - Doesnt give an opinion, just distancing.
I have to highlight that the Evie scum claim could also have been pacted in mafia chat incase Evie is maf, since the push of Evie of A fairy d1 while Celever who was the original push doesnt really get an opinion
Town:
ElectricityCat: I’m town, really.
Westcraft: the hero. Peum said that with these roles it wasn’t possible to find mafias…
Des121: I saw her way too happy when the first mafia was eliminated.
Townlean:
Peum: He’s sweating way too much, 85/15% t/s in my opinion. Over the last few days my opinion of him has changed a lot. If he turns out to be scum, he played us really well.
AirC: His thinking today about how the tracker worked felt genuine to me. I thought the same way. This time I tried to read his posts a bit more and didn’t find anything that seemed suspicious.
Dead by Daylight: I liked his posts over the last few days. I checked some of his earlier stuff and didn’t find anything weird. At the time I’m writing this he still hasn’t posted his list, but I trust him.
Neutral:
Genisu: I agree that it’s pretty hard to plan his interaction with A fairy. But maybe it was an improvision really well made... idk
Vishy fishy: He’s pushing to vote me, same as yesterday. As mafia I don’t think that would’ve benefited him, it would’ve been better to vote a fairy to avoid drawing attention. But he might be acting like that on porpouse.
Scumlean:
pulsar512b: I’ve never changed my opinion of her, I think.
Evie: She was one of a fairy’s scumreads. But it wouldn’t surprise me if they were working together on that. I feel like she’s lying.
like who? literally havent seen anyone besides celever townread vishy
i mean saying theres 1 towny in 3 sounds like good solving, but its really not going to change anything as thats basically rand no?