##Vote: genisu even tho i’m really not sure
-
Smogon Premier League is here and the team collection is now available. Support your team!
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2025 Smog Awards!
OC [Day 7] How can my role be THIS bad? An OC Mafia game
- Thread starter askaninjask
- Start date
##Unvote
something seems fishy now
something seems fishy now
So, I checked Discord and couldn't find the reasons. What were they?
##vote: no vote
#Vote: no vote
##Unvote
#Vote: No Vote
sure.
#Vote: No Vote
sure.
#Vote: genisu
##Unvote
#Vote: No Vote
gut says smth is off
#Vote: No Vote
gut says smth is off
You all gather in the town square looking for someone to murder. You decide that instead of killing genisu, whose win condition truly is to eliminate all members of the Village and the Wolf, it's better to kill no one. No idea what you guys are thinking.
No one dies.
It is now Night 1. Night 1 ends 44 hours (not 48) after this post. Also known as 6:40 PM eastern US time, February 14th.
No one dies.
It is now Night 1. Night 1 ends 44 hours (not 48) after this post. Also known as 6:40 PM eastern US time, February 14th.
You awaken to discover that despite knowing for sure that the mafia and wolf are trying their best to kill you all, they were unsuccessful last night. Huh!
Sending out results now.
It is now Day 2. Day 2 ends 48 hours as of this post.
Sending out results now.
It is now Day 2. Day 2 ends 48 hours as of this post.
You also hear a shout:
All results out. Happy voting.
"For" in the next-to-last word, so I'm thinking it's a copy/paste issue, or just getting the wrong number in a premade text thing.
how are you reading that weird announcement guys??? why is everyone so smart here
I'm making this post to start more discussion, but:
Strong Townreads:
Peum: Has been pretty aggro and solvey in the chat, he doesn't feel any different from his previous games and that paranoia about being night killed checks out with previous meta even though I find that behaviour quite scummy in vacuum.
Pulsar: She seems fed up w/ her role but also pubclaiming pulsar checks out with previous town history.
Medium Townreads:
Celever: I did say he was scum previously for being inactive but I dunno if I'd see scum!Celever picking a fight with Alice here when the activity this game has been pretty dead.
Diego: Vibes I guess. I would have to reread him in the server but he's responded to Peum's stuff well and sounded reasonable and active so far.
Alice: I'm not sure if scum!Alice messages a lot of people in the game to mole someone? Especially with roles being so weak here? This is the weakest townread in this group although I will say(wrt Celever's case on Alice) that idt Alice agreeing with his logic for voting genisu and then voting no vote necessarily implies her being scum.
Scum Pool:
AirC: I think airC feels very passive and only comes into discussion to defend people and then vanishes. While I think airC is a passive player in general I think he's feeling very similar to the previous 2 games that he's been scum in. And I don't mind the risk of this being a misvote here because he isn't going to get any better.
DbD: I feel less confident about this because idt DbD has made sense to me as any alignment but asking people in the server to pubclaim and then dip is a bad look and worth a vote.
zorbees: He said that because of how bad the roles are, that this game was better off playing with reads, but I haven't really seen him make any effort towards the game in general, be it a direction for oc centralisation of info or noc reads-based play. And he's too proactive of a person for me to believe that his best idea for the game is to play passively.
Other people that come to mind are jalmont, ag and genisue but I'm gonna brb in 20 min.
Strong Townreads:
Peum: Has been pretty aggro and solvey in the chat, he doesn't feel any different from his previous games and that paranoia about being night killed checks out with previous meta even though I find that behaviour quite scummy in vacuum.
Pulsar: She seems fed up w/ her role but also pubclaiming pulsar checks out with previous town history.
Medium Townreads:
Celever: I did say he was scum previously for being inactive but I dunno if I'd see scum!Celever picking a fight with Alice here when the activity this game has been pretty dead.
Diego: Vibes I guess. I would have to reread him in the server but he's responded to Peum's stuff well and sounded reasonable and active so far.
Alice: I'm not sure if scum!Alice messages a lot of people in the game to mole someone? Especially with roles being so weak here? This is the weakest townread in this group although I will say(wrt Celever's case on Alice) that idt Alice agreeing with his logic for voting genisu and then voting no vote necessarily implies her being scum.
Scum Pool:
AirC: I think airC feels very passive and only comes into discussion to defend people and then vanishes. While I think airC is a passive player in general I think he's feeling very similar to the previous 2 games that he's been scum in. And I don't mind the risk of this being a misvote here because he isn't going to get any better.
DbD: I feel less confident about this because idt DbD has made sense to me as any alignment but asking people in the server to pubclaim and then dip is a bad look and worth a vote.
zorbees: He said that because of how bad the roles are, that this game was better off playing with reads, but I haven't really seen him make any effort towards the game in general, be it a direction for oc centralisation of info or noc reads-based play. And he's too proactive of a person for me to believe that his best idea for the game is to play passively.
Other people that come to mind are jalmont, ag and genisue but I'm gonna brb in 20 min.
Yeah so I usually give jalmont a pass for not being active during the first few phases because he usually pulls up later if he's town, but I do think this is a very good situation for him if he's mafia so I'm not sure about it this time.
I think genisu claiming miller is townie on principle but town genisu is much more excited and active to at least make reads so the lack of that is ??? to me.
ag hasn't posted much but he reacted to peum claiming to be a role related to rolenames as "you know you aren't the only role that interacts with role names right?" which makes me think that's more likely to come from town? I can't think of why mafia would do this. I guess scum!ag tries to do this to discredit a possible town leadership centered around peum from forming but, hm. Well at least I can safely say that peum and ag can't be on the scumteam together here. I had a good impression off of that interaction but I'm unsure if that's solid.
Vote: airC
I think genisu claiming miller is townie on principle but town genisu is much more excited and active to at least make reads so the lack of that is ??? to me.
ag hasn't posted much but he reacted to peum claiming to be a role related to rolenames as "you know you aren't the only role that interacts with role names right?" which makes me think that's more likely to come from town? I can't think of why mafia would do this. I guess scum!ag tries to do this to discredit a possible town leadership centered around peum from forming but, hm. Well at least I can safely say that peum and ag can't be on the scumteam together here. I had a good impression off of that interaction but I'm unsure if that's solid.
Vote: airC
Oh I remember talking to Peum about Sijih and him jumping to conclusions all the time. I just ISO'd him in the server and it feels like a lot of mech spec and "idk what to do with genisu" which feels a lot like mafia trying to drive a narrative to vote the miller without actually pointing fingers at him. HMMM that does looks scummy to me, do you wanna vote Sijih with me, Peum?
liquidrelief, going by past meta, seems inactive, a plausible votebait, and I would not vote him here.
I remember posting in the server earlier and feeling ShyPebble posted stuff as like, a reaction to people noticing that they hadn't said much. So I feel a little sus of that. But in the convo w/ peum I remember him saying that SP was throwing a lot of reads and speculations out there, but I think that's normal SP meta. I think they like to shoot wide and then narrow down their conclusions from there. I don't very strongly about SP but I wouldn't say I'm sus of them atm.
I have 0 thoughts on vishy fishy. Anyone help me out here?
liquidrelief, going by past meta, seems inactive, a plausible votebait, and I would not vote him here.
I remember posting in the server earlier and feeling ShyPebble posted stuff as like, a reaction to people noticing that they hadn't said much. So I feel a little sus of that. But in the convo w/ peum I remember him saying that SP was throwing a lot of reads and speculations out there, but I think that's normal SP meta. I think they like to shoot wide and then narrow down their conclusions from there. I don't very strongly about SP but I wouldn't say I'm sus of them atm.
I have 0 thoughts on vishy fishy. Anyone help me out here?