Sticky Hold: Disincentivizing one of the moves we purposely wanted to incentivize is crazy work.
Since I suggested
Sticky Hold, I want to defend my suggestion.
In my post suggesting the ability, I talked about how losing boots makes it really difficult for us to do our job of wanting to click Beak Blast, especially against U-turn due to the charge telegraphing exactly what we are using. Sticky Hold partially fixes the U-turn matchup by allowing us to ignore hazards.
Here I want to follow up by talking about how the
burn aspect of BB is just outright bad at discouraging Knock Off.
One of the biggest strength of our typing is that we have a really good matchup into Dark and Ghost types, since we don't have Fighting weakness, which many Dark types like to carry. Ghosts usually don’t carry Knock since it provides redundant coverage, so on offensive mons it’s usually seen as Dark STAB or as coverage on something else.
Most users of Knock Off already don’t want to click it after we switch in
We are working with a typing that excels at switching into Dark STAB attacks, which means that chances are high that we are getting Knocked on the switch. There is already no incentive for them to click Knock Off again into a resist. BB is not doing anything here.
Some of the main STAB users of Knock Off include Weavile, Tyranitar and Meowscarada. If we were to switch into Knock Off, they are not going to click it again; and if were to switch into anything other than Knock Off, chances are we are in Triple Axel/Stone Edge OHKO range, so they are not going to follow up with Knock Off either. And there’s also Colossoil who doesn’t care about the burn.
Many users of Knock Off are outright Flying weak
BB being Flying type is already a huge disincentive for the opponent to click Knock Off on us. Think about who are the best users of Knock Off in the meta: Tusk, Pon, Argo, Malacoda, Valiant etc. They are already not going to click Knock Off on us, not because they are afraid of the burn, but because they are just going to get OHKOed by our 100 BP STAB SE move. In this case, Beak Blast is outright worse at discouraging Knock Off than Brave Bird because the latter doesn't have negative priority.
Similar to the previous scenario, if we were to switch into something that is not Knock Off, they either have something that threatens the 2HKO on us, or they are switching out in fear of the damage coming their way.
Utility users of Knock Off don’t care about being burned
I initially thought that we have a bunch of mons in this category, but there really isn’t. The common users of the moves are just Clefable and Torn-T, both of which would be happy to click Knock on us and take the burn.
------------------------------
tldr;
The burn as BB is never discouraging Knock Off in the first place, so leaving that as a pseudo-weakness makes no sense.
Yes, we decided that Knock Off is something that we want to punish, but our matchups as Dark/Flying means that nothing is going to click Knock Off against us in the first place unless it's on the switch.
And removing the pseudo-weakness to Knock Off on the switch means we can capitalise on our defensive typing to come in and actually use BB more often, while patching up the U-turn matchup a bit more.
------------------------------
As an addendum, since soft banned abilities are now allowed as I was starting to write this, I'm going to preemptively show some soft support for Magic Guard for the same reason, but I'm too tired to write specific reasoning for it at the moment.